Captains Captains Thread

[DustyTiggers]

Plus 1 for Grundy this week. Burnt to many times trying to be clever.

 

[Crashy]

Rain is making me think twice about ruckpig

 

[Crashy]

Rain is making me think twice about ruckpig

Didn't have the balls to make the switch

 

[amazingjoshy]

Rain is making me think twice about ruckpig

Considered it too but hard to take it off someone who just smashed 181...

Reward for those who had the balls to do it

 

[_Cayz_]

Every time I pick the popular choice they fail.

Sigh.

 

[melbourneboy_84]

For those who have Grundy as VC
Are we happy with 117? Im pretty happy with that

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

For those who have Grundy as VC
Are we happy with 117? Im pretty happy with that

??

 

[JADED]

??

I've read about this kinda thing.
Something like "another dimension"
Only, in THAT dimension, Grundy didn't spud it up.

 

[desTROY]

??

Must think he's on the SC board

 

[hjckr]

Almost caught out by the old roll back side (cos that was easier than reversing two advanced trades)
Cripps again? No thanks. Grundy it is.
Wouldn't mind a gamble on Billings.

How this post has aged I too captained Cripps last week so I feel your pain

 

[JADED]

How this post has aged I too captained Cripps last week so I feel your pain

Yeh, and I should've been asleep with no chance to pick up on my roll back. (shift work)
I actually opened team to see if I'd put the C on Macrae and saw it on Cripps... Realised the rollback did that and promptly put it on Grundy. Felt quite lucky. (Til now)

 

[Cotchy9]

I’m thinking Macrae this week

Witts is a pretty solid unit, still expect Grundy to score well but maybe not huge

 

[JADED]

Macrae, locking in the safe 110 like Grundy last week..
Oh wait..

 

[samFFC]

Rd 1: Grundy 84
Rd 2: Treloar 152 (VC)
Rd 3: Danger 132 (VC)
Rd 4: Treloar 82
Rd 5: Treloar 112 (VC)
Rd 6: Rockliff 107
Rd 7: Dangerfield 38
Rd 8: Grundy 149
Rd 9: Rockliff 109
Rd 10: Grundy 149
Rd 11: Grundy 112
Rd 12: Jelly 128
Rd 13: Jelly 148
Rd 14: Gawn 129
Rd 15: Dangerfield 92
Rd 16: Jelly 89
Rd 17: Macrae 110
Rd 18: Macrae 132
Rd 19: Grundy 79

Average: 112.3

I've owned Lloyd (av 110), Treloar (114), Taranto (115), Grundy (122) for the entire season. Picking any of them every week (and capitalising on the early partial lockout rounds) would have been just as good/better and less thinking!!

Is that just me?

 

[nob2210]

Rd 1 - Macrae, 107
Rd 2 - Rocky, 115
Rd 3 - Sloane (VC), 120
Rd 4 - Lloyd (VC), 122
Rd 5 - Sloane, 125
Rd 6 - Grundy (VC), 123
Rd 7 - Sloane, 105
Rd 8 - Grundy, 149
Rd 9 - Grundy, 152
Rd 10 - Grundy, 149
Rd 11 - Grundy, 112
Rd 12 - Jelly, 128
Rd 13 - Dunkley, 158
Rd 14 - Yeo (VC), 132
Rd 15 - Jelly (VC), 120
Rd 16 - Duncan, 75
Rd 17 - Dunkley, 189
Rd 18 - ROB, 134
Rd 19 - Grundy, 79

Average thus far - 126. Only twice under 100 for the year which has been good, and got most of the big ones from Grundy and Dunks. Might need to captain Dunks again this week, he seems to repay the favour!

 

[Crashy]

Macrae	114​
Macrae	124​
Danger	132​	loop
Macrae	109​
Cripps	93​
Grundy	123​
Danger	38​	I forgot about this
Grundy	149​
Grundy	152​
Grundy	149​
Grundy	112​
Treloar	124​
Brouch	129​	loop
Grundy	163​
Grundy	112​
Taranto	93​
Danger	123​
Grundy	181​
Grundy	79​
Ave	121​

 

[Ateen7tee]

I choose not to embarrass myself by revealing my captain average for the year.

All I do is admit to making 2 very late (2 minutes before lockout) changes to my selected captain this year.

The first time was in round 9 when I changed from Grundy (152) to T Kelly (56).

And more recently in round 18 when I changed from Grundy (181) to Cripps (55).

Enough said..

 

[Sixpence]

Rd 1: Grundy 84
Rd 2: Cogs 50
Rd 3: Danger 132 (VC)
Rd 4: Whitfield 124
Rd 5: Whitfield 104
Rd 6: Grundy 123 (VC)
Rd 7: O'Meara 83
Rd 8: Grundy 149
Rd 9: Grundy 152
Rd 10: Grundy 149
Rd 11: Grundy 112
Rd 12: Houli 105
Rd 13: Fyfe 104
Rd 14: Yeo 132 (VC)
Rd 15: Grundy 112
Rd 16: Macrae 106
Rd 17: Macrae 110
Rd 18: Whitfield 109
Rd 19: Grundy 79

AVG: 111.5

That's actually better than I expected, considering I have 4 sub 100 scores. Cogs in Round 2 was a disaster, O'Meara in Round 7 looked like a master stroke at quarter time when he was on 40+ (**** you Harmes!). 9 different Captains, should have really just left it on Grundy all year.

 

[kozi]

Coniglio - 166
Rockliff - 115
Dangerfield - 132 VC
Lloyd - 122 VC
Coniglio - 126
Rockliff - 107
Dangerfield - 38
Grundy - 149
Rockliff - 109
Grundy - 149
Grundy - 112
Coniglio - 90
Merrett - 99
Gawn - 129
Grundy - 112
Grundy - 100
Macrae - 110
Grundy - 181
Grundy - 78

Average - 117.1

Remove Dramaflog’s 38 - 121.5

 

[VSTone]

114 ave for me with Danger 38 and M Crouch 53...

 

[DynamiteDons]

Rd 1:Cogs 161
Rd 2: Fyfe 119
Rd 3: Danger 132 (VC)
Rd 4: Cripps 163
Rd 5: Danger 104
Rd 6: Boak 127
Rd 7: Cripps 111
Rd 8: Brayshaw 76
Rd 9: Merrett 125
Rd 10: Merrett 117
Rd 11: Whitfield 74
Rd 12: J Kelly 128
Rd 13: J Kelly 148
Rd 14: Lloyd 109
Rd 15: Parker 105
Rd 16: J Kelly 89
Rd 17: Merrett 114
Rd 18: Grundy 181
Rd 19: Grundy 79

Average: 119. No idea why I ever decided to Captain Brayshaw ahaha.

 

[_Cayz_]

Cogs 161
Adam Treloar 152
Dangerfield 132
Treloar 82
Treloar 112
Rockliff 107
Treloar 120
Treloar 116
Whitfield 190
Whitfield 120
Whitfield 74
Dangerfield 162
Dusty 140
Yeo 132
Danger 92
Treloar 102
Whitfield 117
Whitfield 109
Grundy 79

Averaging 121 with some highs and lows.

 

[Beau_Waters for PM]

R1 Macrae 214
R2 Macrae 248
R3 Macrae 264
R4 Boak 218
R5 Macrae 200
R6 Macrae 182
R7 Macrae 198
R8 Grundy 298
R9 Boak 220
R10 Grundy 298
R11 Grundy 224
R12 Grundy 190
R13 B.Crouch 258 (VC loop)
R14 Gawn 258
R15 Macrae 270
R16 Macrae 212
R17 Taranto 234
R18 Grundy 362
R19 Grundy 158

Average = 111.8 (223)

Probably going to back in Grundy this week to bounce back.

 

[JADED]

3 tonnes.
Rd 1: Grundy 84
Rd 2: Coniglio 50 (coming off 163)
Rd 3: Rockliff 43 (v Bris, old side come on)
Rd 4: Treloar 82
Rd 5: Grundy 78 (coming off 158)
Rd 6: Whitfield 39
Rd 7: Macrae 99
Rd 8: Macrae 98 (give up on him)

Rd 9: Dangerfield 88
Rd 10: Grundy 149
Rd 11: Whitfield 74 (damn it, back to Grundy)
Rd 12: Grundy 95 (typical)
Rd 13: Martin 140 (VC Loop)
Rd 14: Gaff 92
Rd 15: Grundy 112 (coming off 168)
Rd 16: Fyfe 61 (Derby)
Rd 17: Coniglio 0
Rd 18: Cripps 59
Rd 19: Grundy 79

 

[Chris99]

3 tonnes.
Rd 1: Grundy 84
Rd 2: Coniglio 50 (coming off 163)
Rd 3: Rockliff 43 (v Bris, old side come on)
Rd 4: Treloar 82
Rd 5: Grundy 78 (coming off 158)
Rd 6: Whitfield 39
Rd 7: Macrae 99
Rd 8: Macrae 98 (give up on him)

Rd 9: Dangerfield 88
Rd 10: Grundy 149
Rd 11: Whitfield 74 (damn it, back to Grundy)
Rd 12: Grundy 95 (typical)
Rd 13: Martin 140 (VC Loop)
Rd 14: Gaff 92
Rd 15: Grundy 112 (coming off 168)
Rd 16: Fyfe 61 (Derby)
Rd 17: Coniglio 0
Rd 18: Cripps 59
Rd 19: Grundy 79

So ahhh, who you captaining this week?