Hot Topic Carlton 2024 Trade Discussion

[pressurepoint]

North: pick 2 and 43
Carl: pick 13, F1, 34

We take that 43 and 65, 68, 71 and trade them all to Brisbane for pick 20.

Gives us 2 and 20

Get Campos by swapping futures with GWS or Owies pick

 

[RAPPA]

North: pick 2 and 43
Carl: pick 13, F1, 34

We take that 43 and 65, 68, 71 and trade them all to Brisbane for pick 20.

Gives us 2 and 20

Get Campos by swapping futures with GWS

North and Brisbane fans would rightfully dump manure at the front of their respective home grounds if they agreed to those deals.

 

[pressurepoint]

Wishful thinking! Bris do need points.

What’s a fair deal for pick 2

 

[Arr0w]

North: pick 2 and 43
Carl: pick 13, F1, 34

We take that 43 and 65, 68, 71 and trade them all to Brisbane for pick 20.

Gives us 2 and 20

Get Campos by swapping futures with GWS or Owies pick

Someone like the Saints could offer pick 8 + F1

Personally, I think North would want more picks in the 1st round this year

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Someone like the Saints could offer pick 8 + F1

Personally, I think North would want more picks in the 1st round this year

It might unlock Houston for North if they take our picks

 

[Arr0w]

It might unlock Houston for North if they take our picks

North will get better offers than ours

 

[swuzzlebubble]

North will get better offers than ours

Yes but Houston might be holding out for Port to deal with us whilst we still hold the picks

 

[pressurepoint]

North will get better offers than ours

Are North interested in Kennedy?
13, F1 and Kennedy
For 2 and 43

 

[Arr0w]

Are North interested in Kennedy?
13, F1 and Kennedy
For 2 and 43

They should be, but with Parker reportedly heading there, unlikely I'd say

 

[Ninja Worrier]

Listening to Austin we're after more picks in the top 30, not trading up

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Austin on Trade Week and Draft

Takeaways ...

* We are taking 4 picks to the National Draft

* Kennedy asked for more midfield time in his exit interview. We can't guarantee that so have said he is free to look around. Point seems to be that we aren't forcing them out. We just can't give them what they want.

* Young asked for more senior games in his exist interview. Obviously we can't guarantee that so he is free to look around

* We want more pace across the ground

* Houston still a possibility but will see how it plays out

* We have some flexibility if something comes up

* All of our 2025 picks are on the table. We want to get better this year

* 5 options to go number 1. Throw a blanket over the next 15

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Austin on Trade Week and Draft

Takeaways ...

* We are taking 4 picks to the National Draft

* Kennedy asked for more midfield time in his exit interview. We can't guarantee that so have said he is free to look around. Point seems to be that we aren't forcing them out. We just can't give them what they want.

* Young asked for more senior games in his exist interview. Obviously we can't guarantee that so he is free to look around

* We want more pace across the ground

* Houston still a possibility but will see how it plays out

* We have some flexibility if something comes up

* All of our 2025 picks are on the table. We want to get better this year

* 5 options to go number 1. Throw a blanket over the next 15

* Owies may or may not have an offer

 

[carlton_99]

 

[bradfisher14]

Some stuff about Carlton and pick 13 in here

Blues up bid as Houston race heats up, Darling switch close, five deals to unlock key trades

Check out all the latest trade news from around the League

www.afl.com.au

Paying overs for Pick 13 to snooker the Pies/Power

 

[Rustica]

Pretty much offering almost all our valuable picks from next year for GC Pick 13

 

[FitzroyBlueBagger]

We’re apparently upped the offer for pick 13 “for the Houston race against Filth”
Next year’s future First and Second for GCS pick13, trading this years second pick 34 with *** future second, they need points this year for Kako…

 

[carlton_99]

Pretty much offering almost all our valuable picks from next year for GC Pick 13

We would also move our 2024 2nd (#34) for a 2025 2nd so we aren't getting out of both the 1st and 2nd round next year.

 

[BluStreak]

Of course you can trade.
I can tell you that we have not offered Owies a contract.

But in the Blumours thread we have posters saying that Owies has been offered a 2 year contract.

On another note, just to correct the on going rants from the gettable crew and other outlets.
Owies has been offered a deal from us, a reasonable deal of 2 years + triggers. But he has been offered some much higher and longer deals from several other clubs.

 

[carlton_99]

What's odd with this is #13 alone won't be enough for Houston and we would have traded away #34 to make this deal work. Unless we get picks from any player outgoings (Kennedy/Young/Owies/Carroll etc) not sure how this gets us Houston.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Very smart business. It's a more than fair offer for the Suns, and they get to deathride us all next year.

I'd try to get their #41 or #49 back though, just to make sure we cover the Camporeale twins, or move up a bit with our last couple of draft picks.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

What's odd with this is #13 alone won't be enough for Houston and we would have traded away #34 to make this deal work. Unless we get picks from any player outgoings (Kennedy/Young/Owies/Carroll etc) not sure how this gets us Houston.

It's a take it or leave it scenario for Port. If they don't take it, we have 2 picks in the draft where we want them.

 

[carlton_99]

Very smart business. It's a more than fair offer for the Suns, and they get to deathride us all next year.

I'd try to get their #41 or #49 back though, just to make sure we cover the Camporeale twins, or move up a bit with our last couple of draft picks.

They'll get a choice of who they want to deathride - Pies also offering a F1 apparently with Noble but want #13 and #23 back.

 

[bradfisher14]

What's odd with this is #13 alone won't be enough for Houston and we would have traded away #34 to make this deal work. Unless we get picks from any player outgoings (Kennedy/Young/Owies/Carroll etc) not sure how this gets us Houston.

If we get that pick, we stop the Pies getting Houston, corner the market for Houston/potentially acquire him if Port lower their asking price, and at worst we get another player in a very strong draft.

Getting pick 13 is a massive massive win if we can pull it off, even if it means paying serious overs.

If we get it done on Monday, we can basically sit there and watch Port sweat for the rest of the week.

 

[carlton_99]

So the deals seem to be:
Carlton give F1 and F2 for #13
Collingwood give F1 + Noble for #13 + #23

If it is truly the above our offer is far more attractive to the Suns when comparing it to the Pies offer. However, we may also want something back with #13 in our deal (like The Old Dark Navy's mentioned above). Our offer also seems better than the ones mentioned for the Dogs (F1), Dees (F1) and Swans (#19 + #22) in the article

NB: It is the Suns we are dealing with - hard to predict what idiocy they are capable of.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

But in the Blumours thread we have posters saying that Owies has been offered a 2 year contract.

You didn’t post the persons name you quoted… why not?

I’m not going to go into it anymore but anyone saying Owies has been offered a deal for 1, 2 or however many years at this point is incorrect and is feeding you porkies