Carlton's list of non-recycled players

[Lazarus]

you're talking about recycling and carlton are sponsored by visy

oh, the irony

 

[whatimtalkingbout]

lol. hodgepodge, trent croad is the definition of recycled.

or more like scrunched up and chucked in to the trash can, then carefully extracted with tweezers and decontaminated...

Nah, Croad was a draft pick in 98 i think, then he went to fremantle to have the spunk scared out of him He returned a humble servant to our football club

 

[The Real Deal]

Pick a good one. Can't be a recycled player, can't be a No.1 draft pick (too easy, you just pick the one who has the most hype around him). Fevola is a liability to that club, as shown by their pitiful ladder positions even when he's kicking goals

So pick their best Non No.1 Draft Picks or Rookie List Recruits.

So far I think it's going to be between Walker and Jordan Russell.

Now compare that with your own club's non-recycled, non No.1 pickups.

With Hawthorn for example, it would be Ellis, Mitchell, Sewell, Franklin, Roughead, Croad, Lewis, Rioli, Brown, Young, Williams, Birchall. There are others, but let's leave it at that.

It becomes clear after doing this excercise why Carlton continue to fail

A lot of them aren't re-cycled- they WANT to play for Carlton. There's a big difference.

 

[SOSForever]

I don't even see why it matters if they are recycled or not, surely it only comes down to being capable of playing the game

 

[blue gunslinger]

Bored Hodgepodge - not much to do? Contemplate this,

[FONT=&quot]Wooden Spoons [/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]Hawthorn (11)[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Carlton (3)[/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]Nuff said[/FONT]

What he said - you know we are coming for you Tassie Hawks

 

[whatimtalkingbout]

A lot of them aren't re-cycled- they WANT to play for Carlton. There's a big difference.

It all comes down to Carlton not being able to pick up any quality players from the draft.

 

[blue gunslinger]

Who did Hawthorn get?

 

[SOSForever]

It all comes down to Carlton not being able to pick up any quality players from the draft.

We drafted Simon Beaumont, Hawks seemed to want him ...

 

[Silvagnis]

Who did Hawthorn get?

Hawthornton are still making a last minute play for Thornton because they can't develop their own KPP.

They had to bring Croad pick and re-draft that spud Gilham to make ends meet.

Gilham pantsed mighty Tom Lonergan when he missed his chances, so he's a star.

Hawthorn's next best tall defender is Campbell Browne because Birchall refuses to go near a contest.

They couldn't get ROK because they kept pick 16 to draft another Dowler, Thorp, Muston or Bailey...

 

[whatimtalkingbout]

Who did Hawthorn get?

Read the OP Carlton have the worst list of draftees. Hawthorn has guns like Franklin, Lewis, Croad, Mitchell, Sewell.

 

[blue gunslinger]

Read the OP Carlton have the worst list of draftees. Hawthorn has guns like Franklin, Lewis, Croad, Mitchell, Sewell.

That might be why you won the flag - no arguments there But we are getting closer and developing our kids into guns
Is Croad really a gun?

 

[whatimtalkingbout]

That might be why you won the flag - no arguments there But we are getting closer and developing our kids into guns
Is Croad really a gun?

Yes, he's a gun CHB/FB, missed a lot of the year, but did well when he played.

 

[blue gunslinger]

Yes, he's a gun CHB/FB, missed a lot of the year, but did well when he played.

Lucky he did not get tainted by the purple haze!

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

I don't think it's anywhere near as complicated as that

He likes seeing his hero with his shirt off

Luke hodge may be a champ in his eyes

But I know one champ (hodgepodge's bald headed champ that is) that really gets a workout at his house when it turns dark

Ever since Jon Dorotich was caught spanking the monkey in his car, the Carlton faithful have had a fascination with self pleasure. If it works for you guys then good luck to you, but trust me on this, you can keep it on the Blues board.

 

[Team Mo']

I would of thought Geelong and Hawthorn would be the last 2 clubs giving Carlton a bad go about the way they get their players.

What with Hawthorn's tree of 1st rounders and Geelong stock of Father-sons i find it laughable that someone can bag a club for trading for better players?

 

[Johnny Utah #9]

Ever since Jon Dorotich was caught spanking the monkey in his car, the Carlton faithful have had a fascination with self pleasure. If it works for you guys then good luck to you, but trust me on this, you can keep it on the Blues board.

Could be worse, Doro could have been like Crawf and sought his satisfaction playing the back 9 with another bloke.

 

[WeAreHatedAgain]

Could be worse, Doro could have been like Crawf and sought his satisfaction playing the back 9 with another bloke.

Hodgepodge?

 

[thatswhatimtalkinabout]

What he said - you know we are coming for you Tassie Hawks

You must be coming off the long run.

Give us a yell when you get within 2 seasons of us.


























BTW Nick Stevens

 

[Coondogs]

Could be worse, Doro could have been like Crawf and sought his satisfaction playing the back 9 with another bloke

You mean just like Peter "Percy" Jones.

 

[WeAreHatedAgain]

Or Simon Atkins

 

[whatimtalkingbout]

I would of thought Geelong and Hawthorn would be the last 2 clubs giving Carlton a bad go about the way they get their players.

What with Hawthorn's tree of 1st rounders and Geelong stock of Father-sons i find it laughable that someone can bag a club for trading for better players?

Every club, every year, gets a 1st round pick We have only the single No.1 pick, and that was traded for. You guys have three . In a row

 

[Leather Poisoning]

What he said - you know we are coming for you Tassie Hawks

Didn't we hear that before round 22?

 

[Big Red is back]

What's a hair doll?

No i got it off a website. I needed an avatar.

Are you gay?

 

[Hodgepodge]

Are you gay?

No I'm not interested but thanks

 

[Johnny Utah #9]

Every club, every year, gets a 1st round pick We have only the single No.1 pick, and that was traded for. You guys have three . In a row

You've actually had two - Alex McDonald and Luke Hodge.