Changes for Brisbane

[PatientMental]

Out:
Pittard (inj)
Hartlett (inj)
Carlile (inj)
Stewart - Just terrible

In:
Surj
Motlop
Chad
Brogan

Keep Lobbe in, he made Stewart look like a muppet.

 

[b0ydman]

Just bring in Salter and Banner

Don't really care about the rest one way or another

 

[Powerade 08]

Salter in the middle.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

OUT: Jacobs, Thomas, Pittard, Moore
IN: Banner, Chad (farewell game), Surjan, Brogan/Motlop

 

[PAFCsince1870]

Out:
Pittard (inj)
Hartlett (inj)
Carlile (inj)
Stewart - Just terrible

In:
Surj
Motlop
Chad
Brogan

Keep Lobbe in, he made Stewart look like a muppet.

If Primus actually made those changes he would be chased out of town and rightfully so.

Thankfully his selections so far this year would suggest there's more chance of hell freezing over.

Brogan the only player over the age of 23 who should even be considered.

 

[Jumbo]

What exactly does Kornes bring to our side at the moment? (I'm looking for positives here!)

 

[PJ Power]

They have to drop Moore and possibly Jacobs after today. You can't gift games to players who just aren't up to it.

Salter in for Carlile (just hope they don't bring back Pettigrew).
Banner for Moore (mega disappointment for me).
Surjan for Pittard.
Brogan if fit, for Stewart who just doesn't get what it takes to play AFL.
I expect Hartlett to come up. Not sure about Cassisi though.

 

[BigBroMike]

Out:
Pittard (inj)
Hartlett (inj)
Carlile (inj)
Stewart- you could put a cone on the field and it'd have more influence upon the game then what Stewart has. What is wrong with this guy? It's not a 1 off thing it's pretty much every single game he fails to make any sort of an impact
Phillips- spud. it's gotten to the stage where it's just comical seeing him lose his feet. he's not much better in the air either i swear i saw him butcher multiple uncontested marks today. I get it this is a rebuilding stage for the club and all but you've got to ask the question- would this guy be in a premiership team? no. so why are coaching staff wasting their time on this guy when you've got players like Surjan and Motlop sitting on the sideline making room for him.

In:
Surj
Motlop
Brogan
Salter
Banner

 

[b0ydman]

On the bright side, we will surely keep Lobbe in, and please for the rest of the season

That being the case, even if Brogan returns, could it give brogan the rest he needs?

could that buy him another season?

could it mean Stewart and Worsthoff have a different latitude?

I don't know

I don't knwo if we can drop Moore and Jacobs either. Oshea is no better, but his disposal is alrgith, he simply doesnt get the ball. (dont confuse possessions as meaningful when you spend an entire game unopposed and free to go anywhere on a field too people)

It would appear that we have massively overpaid on Moore and Jacobs, i follow the sentiment of the "mega disappointment"

But if we drop them, and they go to the SANFL reserves, they may never come back in

I mean look at Banner, we wont give him a game- although he's a dead cert in for next week at least, but do we really see them performing in the SANFL?


can anyone say how they did in the early weeks? i could go to the threads and find it but i'd prefer it itemised here

are they raw, or maybe just not good?

 

[Schulzenfest]

Out: Pittard (inj) In: Motlop, to play off of half back in Pittard's role.

Out: Carlile, In: Salter? I guess we don't really have much other choice, other than Chad who there's no chance Primus will play. Or we could go for a shorter defence and bring in Surj, considering that Trengove won't be needed for ruck duties with Lobbe and Broges in and that unless Clark comes back the Lions don't have a noteworthy key forward other than Brown. Just for the love of god please don't bring Pettigrew back.

Out: D. Stewart, In: Brogan

Out: Moore, In: Banner

Out: Jacobs, In: Salopek (this is a should happen but won't happen move. Primus won't drop Jacobs after he had 24 touches, but I don't care how many touches you have when you're just so ****ing useless with them like Jacobs is. Worst 'good kick' I've ever seen)

 

[Honeyboy Wilson]

Out:
Moore
Stewart
Jacobs
O'Shea

In:
Surj
Banner
Salter
Dean

 

[GinnyT]

Time for the thalidomide experiment to end, chaplin and carlisle traded or delisted or dropped asap!

 

[SupportMe]

What I want -

Out: Stewart, Jacobs, Moore, Pittard (Inj.), Carlile (Inj.)

In: Brogan, Salopek, Banner, Salter, Surjan

What we'll get -

Out: Lobbe, Phillips, Pittard, Carlile

In: Brogan, Hitchcock, Davenport, Pettigrew

 

[b0ydman]

Out:

Stewart- you could put a cone on the field and it'd have more influence upon the game then what Stewart has. What is wrong with this guy? It's not a 1 off thing it's pretty much every single game he fails to make any sort of an impact
r

my guess- never been in a street fight

never had a polynesian running at him

needs to get reported for charging

striking

anything

appears to have added a few kilos of mass

he and westhoff need 5kgs more + testosterone injections

stewart needs a game of 5 contested marks 5 goals to get a feel for what he is capable of

if he doesnt add the mass just don't play him

 

[Seriously]

I must have been watching a different game to everyone else because i thought Jacobs had a good game

 

[BigBroMike]

I must have been watching a different game to everyone else because i thought Jacobs had a good game

He had a kornesque like game- acquired a lot of touches but didn't do much with them.

 

[Peck]

OUT: Pittard (inj.), Carlile (inj), Hartlett (inj), Westhoff (his defensive running, or lack therof is awful), Moore.

IN: Banner, Salopek, Young, Bass, Hitchcock

Though I doubt Westhoff will be dropped.

 

[FishingRick04]

OUT: Pittard (inj.), Carlile (inj), Hartlett (inj), Westhoff (his defensive running, or lack therof is awful), Moore.

IN: Banner, Salopek, Young, Bass, Hitchcock

Though I doubt Westhoff will be dropped.

I don't wanna start a Westhoff bash again because yes he's had a better year but it's good to see I'm nit the only one that sees this bad side to his game. I also thought Grays man ran off un pressured to many times also.

 

[oporto]

I must have been watching a different game to everyone else because i thought Jacobs had a good game

Wow ! Clanger & turnover king. No commitment to several contests and caught well behind his man on at least a dozen occasions. Not AFL standard atm

 

[Relativity]

Out:
Moore
Stewart
Jacobs
O'Shea

In:
Surj
Banner
Salter
Dean

Fallen off the Chad bandwagon already Bernie?

 

[Waspy79]

I must have been watching a different game to everyone else because i thought Jacobs had a good game

He was far from our worst, plenty to work with there, calls for him being dropped are ridiculous.

 

[Waspy79]

Statue Stewart returned this week, I thought he showed some signs last week, but oh no. OUT

 

[Schulzenfest]

plenty to work with there

Like what?

Ben Jacobs' good points: Gets lots of the ball.
Ben Jacobs' bad points: Horrifically bad kick, even over short distances to uncontested opponents. No idea what he's doing defensively.

 

[Seriously]

Whilst I agree his kicking wasn't great, 71% DE suggests he was pretty decent with the ball.

p.s. everyone was saying how good Levi Greenwood was his DE was 58%

 

[Schulzenfest]

There are so many things wrong with using DE as a measure for a players kicking ability that I can't even be bothered going into it again.