Unofficial Preview Changes & Pre-match Discussion - RD 4 vs. Carlton. Thur 03/04 @ 7:30pm (MCG)

[Jen2310]

Geez i hope Ryan or Dimattia play well today in the VFL, I guess they have a shot next week too. Same with Frampton and Dean. We can't go to WHE this early in the season, need to give another key defender a go.

I'd be looking to move Jaicos back to a wing or high half forward and have one of the above move to half back. Jaicos is still getting ball, but his defensive efforts are just bad. Maybe he learns it in time. But surely Markov, Dimattia or Ryan would add some speed down back. WHE could perform this role as well.

At the game last night, we looked out coached or out structured around the ground. Hoping Fly takes the break to work out why we have an opposition kick out go to an unmarked defender running by themselves outside our 50.

If we are willing to free up space in our fwd line by giving that kick, maybe have more coverage over the back of this? To my eye when this occurred they were kicking to one on one's on the wing in space.

There was a guy behind me that kept saying "We give them the easy kick coming out of F50 every single time."

 

[domus]

Best case scenario is we belt them by 10 goals making them 0 and 4 and Voss gets sacked. Head scratching selection meeting coming up. Framps is a must, Checkers back too, it's out of Cox or Membrey for the chop. The tag team of Cox and DC is potent against 1 ruck teams like Carlscum. TDK will be outworked. But I like Membrey. Good problem to have. Carltons longbombs to no one gameplan favours tall interceptors. If Crisp misses then Ed Allan or Hosk.

If Crisp misses it will be due to bribery by Styne's family.

 

[sr36]

im not confident with the Crisp one tbh, arms free but they've suspended Sicily for less

The difference is no one likes Sicily.

 

[Run n Spread]

Out McCreery Mcinnes Crisp (if suspended)
In Hoskin-Elliot Jiath Allen

 

[Finnishpie]

One of the issues I think we're gonna continue to face is pace against the quicker teams. GWS already taught us that lesson. The Hawks will too.

Losing McInnis is a blow in that department, since his replacements are going to be slower -- Frampton or Dean.

For this reason, McReery is a lock.

But we're going to need to add some pace, I think.

Who has it who hasn't been playing?

Jiath? Who else?

 

[Ctracks]

One of the issues I think we're gonna continue to face is pace against the quicker teams. GWS already taught us that lesson. The Hawks will too.

Losing McInnis is a blow in that department, since his replacements are going to be slower -- Frampton or Dean.

For this reason, McReery is a lock.

But we're going to need to add some pace, I think.

Who has it who hasn't been playing?

Jiath? Who else?

Gout Gout

 

[JoinDate]

Do i really need to defend myself here lol pathetic to suggest I was implying that

No, you don't. For some reason, if you say you like blue, people will take it to mean that you're saying you hate red...

 

[parano1a]

Cox is important for structure - Cameron plays better when Cox is in to back him up as 2nd ruck. Plus after a shaky start he was actually competing well and taking marks until being punched by Lobb.
Would McStay to defence be an option?

 

[nahnah]

I dont mind trying Checkers in defense

 

[FAIRANDBALANCED]

No, you don't. For some reason, if you say you like blue, people will take it to mean that you're saying you hate red...

Are you implying i hate green?

 

[Pistol Night]

Watch Carlton get bashed by the Bulldogs next weekend then we get them off a 6 day break.

 

[Spiral_Out]

Who in the hell would consider McCreery an out?

Brain damage is the only explanation.

I didn't understand why Reef was in ahead of Frampton to begin with, Moore and Howe play too loose and Frampton is a perfect FB because he actually defends, has size, has experience, has overhead prowess. It's Frampton's spot.

Frampton also gives options in the ruck, I would rather Cox out and Frampton rotating in the ruck, rather than McStay.

The only issue is WHE, but he is an in for me.

In: Frampton, Mihocek, WHE

Out: Reef, Membrey, Cox


Membrey is not better than Mihocek, he's good backup.

 

[MoreMoore]

B. IQ. Frampton. Maynard
HB. Houston. Moore. Howe
C. WHE. Crisp. Jaicos
HF. Beau. McStay Shultz
F. Elliot. Checkers Hill

R. Cameron Naicos Degoey

Int Long Sidey Membrey Perryman
Super Sub Pendles

 

[timokane]

This is my line up:
fb: howe whe iq
cb: manyard moore houston
c: josh daicos perryman crisp
cf: hill checkers shultz
ff: elliott mcstay cox
r: cameron jdg nick daicos

for Reef WHE,Dean,Frampton,TJ,Ryan,Cochrane are the choices.

Or you could play Tim membrey down there as well.

i still yet to think about interchange and the sub.

I think they will try something different and bring in WHE as that defender that can replace Reef might be a long term thing too.

Also like to see if they can bring in a kid to play their first game as well.

After a bye rest i think Cox will come up from that hit by Lobb.

I think as a team we need a rest up time now.

Get our selfs fresh again.

Kind of like Cox up forward.

Bad news on Reef but i do think we have options.

Crisp will also be given the all clear from MRO.

He from my knowledge has never been rubbed out for anything.

there wasnt much in that tackle the dogs player rode his head into the ground.

Was trying to milk the free but thing is it wasnt a free was a ball up instead i saw it.

Anyhow i think a freshen up Pies will beat the blues by 23 points.

 

[stormskye]

This is my line up:
fb: howe whe iq
cb: manyard moore houston
c: josh daicos perryman crisp
cf: hill checkers shultz
ff: elliott mcstay cox
r: cameron jdg nick daicos

for Reef WHE,Dean,Frampton,TJ,Ryan,Cochrane are the choices.

Or you could play Tim membrey down there as well.

i still yet to think about interchange and the sub.

I think they will try something different and bring in WHE as that defender that can replace Reef might be a long term thing too.

Also like to see if they can bring in a kid to play their first game as well.

After a bye rest i think Cox will come up from that hit by Lobb.

I think as a team we need a rest up time now.

Get our selfs fresh again.

Kind of like Cox up forward.

Bad news on Reef but i do think we have options.

Crisp will also be given the all clear from MRO.

He from my knowledge has never been rubbed out for anything.

there wasnt much in that tackle the dogs player rode his head into the ground.

Was trying to milk the free but thing is it wasnt a free was a ball up instead i saw it.

Anyhow i think a freshen up Pies will beat the blues by 23 points.

WHE has played wing and forward in the VFL.

 

[Magnanimous]

I know theyll go Frampton and call me crazy but I'd love to see them throw Checkers to defence . People forget he was a gun key defender in the VFL before we drafted him mature age . And we finally have enough key forward with McStay , Membrey , Cox available .

For Harry?
Be room slow for Curnow surely.

On SM-A556E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Watching VFL and Dean is not AFL quality.

 

[Kes1984]

Watching VFL and Dean is not AFL quality.

Frampton is our best option. Not a bad option either.

 

[stormskye]

Frampton is our best option. Not a bad option either.

He’s been solid today old Billy

 

[Kes1984]

He’s been solid today old Billy

Good. He got the memo that there is a spot for him now.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

In frampton Mihocek
Out McInnes Cox

Would love to find room for Allan and he’ll force Long out sooner or later. He should be first man in ahead of Sullivan and even WHE. Gotta think long term.

 

[Rorzza]

Long omitted, Reef injured.

In: Mihocek, Frampton.

 

[MoreMoore]

Frampton was really good today

 

[jmac70]

Long omitted, Reef injured.

In: Mihocek, Frampton.

Long omitted, WTF!

 

[stormskye]

Long omitted, Reef injured.

In: Mihocek, Frampton.

We aren’t playing cox, checkers, mcstay and membrey all together