undies37
Senior List
who are gonna be dropped this week after that effort??
I think Bell out and mcdonald in
I think Bell out and mcdonald in
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Changes this week
- Thread starter undies37
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Supermercado
The straw that stirs the drink
White back in for mine.
- Aug 30, 2007
- 9,004
- 6,155
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Warney's IPL team!
White for Jamar, imo our worst loss of the year 34 points against a team 2 spots ahead of us we could of gotten of the bottom with a win but at the very elast a competitive performance. Hopefully green's hammy was only 1 week (fingers crossed).
Yeah that was a poor effort. 3 goals or whatever in 3 quarters after such a good start.
For mine as well. He better come in.
I hope white doesn't come in just to piss off all you dreamteam c__ksuckers.
This is a melbourneFC board, if you don't really give a rats about melbourne, f__k off
deeswant13
Rookie
Bartram out and McDonald in.
Bell tackled well and I thought his disposal was better than it has been this season. Bell was looking like a star of the future until he got hit by Johnson. Hopefully he can get back to that same form.
Bell tackled well and I thought his disposal was better than it has been this season. Bell was looking like a star of the future until he got hit by Johnson. Hopefully he can get back to that same form.
I like Bell as a player, and as such I feel he should be given more time in the senior side. I know a lot of people feel his disposal and decision making could be enhanced somewhat, but he is worth persisting with. A lot of his issues relate to the mental side of the game, not the physical side. I would suggest more experience will help him develop greatly.
I'm probably going to piss some people off with this, but I'd be happy for Wonaeamirri to have a rest this week. He's looked a bit slow in recent weeks and opposition clubs have appeared to have found him out. Give him a week or 2 in the reserves and get his confidence up. Yze can come straight in for him, and to be honest, I'd like him to play out the year for al he's given to the club. Agree with Bartram for Junior too. Looked somewhat overwhelmed yesterday, maybe needs a reminder that his spot isn't guaranteed. Bell wasn't the reason we lost yesterday and from what I saw looked like one of the more composed defenders on the day. White in as well. I know Jamar was ok yesterday, but surely Jeff has got the message now and knows what he must show at top level.
Out: jamar, Wonaeamirri, Bartram
In: White, Yze McDonald
Out: jamar, Wonaeamirri, Bartram
In: White, Yze McDonald
My care factor as to which players get a game has almost reached an all time low.
But list management must be very important in these last 6 rounds so we have to decide on White, Carroll and McDonald futures, so they should get a game before the end of the year, maybe PJ can have a rest, it would open up the forward line for Juice and let Jamar continue to show if he is up to it. Then Holland and Yze could be in line for a farewell show. The odd mystery illness for blokes who have had a long season like Bruce, Jones and Bate, and a few games to get a bit of confidence for Meesen, Bode and Petterd wouldn't hurt.
But list management must be very important in these last 6 rounds so we have to decide on White, Carroll and McDonald futures, so they should get a game before the end of the year, maybe PJ can have a rest, it would open up the forward line for Juice and let Jamar continue to show if he is up to it. Then Holland and Yze could be in line for a farewell show. The odd mystery illness for blokes who have had a long season like Bruce, Jones and Bate, and a few games to get a bit of confidence for Meesen, Bode and Petterd wouldn't hurt.
Supermercado
The straw that stirs the drink
Wouldn't mind seeing a few randoms get a token game before the end of the year.
Meesen, Grimes and Maric for mine.
Can't do any harm, might get destroyed mentally by the thought of being smashed by 100 in their first games but other than that, can't do any harm.
- Banned
- #14
I dont see why everybody is calling for Jamar to be dropped, played his best game for us on the weekend
- Nov 24, 2007
- 13,156
- 950
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Is there a realistic chance of White returning this week..?
He adds experience to your mob and when he is up and running he is one of the best ruckman going around without a doubt.
He adds experience to your mob and when he is up and running he is one of the best ruckman going around without a doubt.
No he hasn't. Ball doesn't come into the 50, he doesn't get the ball. It's that simple.
Agree with this, I still think Yze has what it takes to play at the highest level and could continue next year but it seems I'm the only person.
Can agree with this aswell, Bartram hasn't been good.
Composed isn't tackling high every time he gets near the player with the ball, he was shocking no way around that.
Jamar was good but I do agree White needs to come back in.
00Stinger
100 - 7
Jamar would have to be our worst player to play 50 games since Nicholson and I can't believe we persist with him
This week out- JAMAR, BATRAM, BELL
In- WHITE, MCDONALD, YZE
This week out- JAMAR, BATRAM, BELL
In- WHITE, MCDONALD, YZE
In fairness to Jamar, he does give his all each week, and whilst he may not be the most talented player on the list, he has some solid attributes. In saying that, I agree that White needs to return to the side this week. By this time, he should have got the message that he isn't one of the first names on the team sheet each week, and hopefully he will play with a renewed vigor as a result.
00Stinger
100 - 7
Jamar is a trier and does give his all every week, however i still think he isn't good enough. Its AFL football not junior football, it doesn't matter how hard he tries if he's not good enough (which I dont think he is) then he shouldnt be playing
redandtheblue
Debutant
love to see some of the more experienced heads come in this week as I see it as a very winable game. we usually step up and have a good contest with north along with the fact they strangely do not play as well against lowly placed sides.
look for the roos to run over the top of us however as they played in melb last friday and we played in perth on sunday. that could be good reason for a few fresh faces in the side...
look for the roos to run over the top of us however as they played in melb last friday and we played in perth on sunday. that could be good reason for a few fresh faces in the side...
TelkoTheGreat
Club Legend
in : White, Mcdonald
out : Jamar, Bartram
out : Jamar, Bartram
Go-Ricky15
Senior List
Who??? Thats some sick-ass gene splicing.... Either that or Batman just shagged a sheep.
