Chapman V Hayes

[BluesKreuz]

Who is better? Just thought it was an interesting comparison.

 

[anti_]

Chapman if you already have a good team. he really tops of geelong, wins hard ball, breaks tackles and kicks goals. Top 5 in the AFL this year.

Hayes if you're building from scratch, his bullocking work in the center for stkilda is invaluable. just doesnt have the class that chapman does.

i'd take Chapman.

 

[Gazza_11]

But you don't have a good team

Chapman has become really elite in the last two years, while Hayes has just been a champion player without killing it week in week out with class.

 

[DrTomSwift]

A poll worth having.

 

[Donakebab]

Both immense players who have barely showed signs of age catching them. Chapman now but it's close. Over career Hayes has been performing higher for much longer. Hard to split, prefer not to vote.

 

[Goldencats]

I'm happy with Chapper but Hayes is my favourite footballer outside the Cats, have immense respect for the guy

 

[BONG RIPS MKII]

hayes

chapman is getting a little overrated lately

 

[StillWaiting5689]

I'd pick Hayes, he could play at any club and still be an absolute gun. He is the epitome of tough inside midfielder, he gives his all each week and his leadership quality is clear to see from the outside so can only imagine the effect he has in house.

Chapman is a superstar though and is probably having a better season. I think he benefits from the team he is in, I don't mean that he plays above himself by any means or is only good in a good team but think sometimes teams can't pay him the attention he requires due to the vast talent in the side and as a player as good as him does he carves it up weekly - though that is the case with a lot of top teams.

 

[Play by Numbers]

I'd pick Hayes, he could play at any club and still be an absolute gun. He is the epitome of tough inside midfielder, he gives his all each week and his leadership quality is clear to see from the outside so can only imagine the effect he has in house.

Chapman is a superstar though and is probably having a better season. I think he benefits from the team he is in, I don't mean that he plays above himself by any means or is only good in a good team but think sometimes teams can't pay him the attention he requires due to the vast talent in the side and as a player as good as him does he carves it up weekly - though that is the case with a lot of top teams.

Disagree strongly.

Chapman is a big game player, in fact he often performs at his best when the most pressure is on.

Nor is it true he has only hit his strides recently, he has been a good player with brilliant patches for quite a while, but it has been injury/fitness not Geelong's form which has been his barometer.

 

[09wasalwaysours]

A poll worth having.

Agreed, may have been done before, but both outstanding players. Both Ball players with enormous ups and little downs, maybe Chapman for more goals, but take either one any day and thats as unbiased as I can be!

 

[Claude Balls]

But you don't have a good team

Chapman has become really elite in the last two years, while Hayes has just been a champion player without killing it week in week out with class.

Chapman became elite in '06, more or less as a lone hand when Geelong finished 10th or so. He just gets far more recognition now.

 

[Carlton_Blues]

Chapman, he's just that little bit tougher!

 

[a_fighting_fury]

I voted for the player who will win his clubs B&F this year.