Chris Judd - The Crime and the Punishment - 4 Weeks

[jackess]

Are there any pressure points in the shoulder? Maybe we should check with his local Blockbuster to see if he rented any Steven Seagal movies recently.

 

[Dagless]

One limb at a time.

Were you not entertained?!?!

 

[Pessimistic]

Maher is more than happy to push for any other teams player to be suspended. Will reak of double standards if he doesn't come down hard on Judd.

The medias response is the most disappointing. Its clearly one rule for one....

In the hawk board someone compared what the AFL had dished out to Judd - who commits dog acts which are unacceptable in any 'era' - to what Buddy has had dished out - buddy would have been deemed a 'pussycat' back in the 80s but has a punishment record which ranks him up there with some of the 80s biggest hardmen.

Comparisons are pointless but compare Guerras 3 weeks (probably warranted) with nothing for Kelly a few weeks back. no difference except Guerra was actually lower down !!!

Kelly is judd lite - good player but tends to commit dog acts occasionally - just ask Prismall !!!

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

good to see other players sticking their head out on this. although they will probably get fined as well..

Harris has retired.

 

[Obeanie1]

Hartlett didnt even get looked at and it was a Kimura.

Judd will use this as a precedent.

At least Hartlett was the player making the tackle and it was in play. Someone else tackled Adams and he was faced down with a Blues player lying over his back with no chance to move the ball on before Judd came in as the 3rd man.

Totally different incidents. Why did Hartell grab the arm? To lay a tackle.

Why did Judd grab the arm. pull it back and up and then twist it? To hurt him.

 

[KnaveyBlue]

Judd is a good enough bloke to do some free chiropractic work for Adams and you guys all turn on him?

Tough crowd.

 

[LordLucifer]

I'm here !!

I've looked at that vision a few times and just cannot fathom the hysteria you guys are whipping yourselves into over this.

Yes, Judd might be in strife for this incident but he sure as hell didn't go to the Belanglo Forest like you lot are making out.

 

[Lance Uppercut]

imagine if it was, say, Barry Hall or Cam Moonee or Kyle Reimers or someone who did this. They would be hanged from the neck until they were dead in the media

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I'm here !!

I've looked at that vision a few times and just cannot fathom the hysteria you guys are whipping yourselves into over this.

Yes, Judd might be in strife for this incident but he sure as hell didn't go to the Belanglo Forest like you lot are making out.

So you agree with us? Then why are you disagreeing?

Most people are calling for 2 weeks on this. You are imagining the hysteria.

 

[IluvHarvey]

I'm here !!

I've looked at that vision a few times and just cannot fathom the hysteria you guys are whipping yourselves into over this.

Yes, Judd might be in strife for this incident but he sure as hell didn't go to the Belanglo Forest like you lot are making out.

So you think he might be in strife? So clearly even through your navy blue glasses you can see it was a dog act!

 

[bluemarq]

Shuey swings his arm back to get a player behind him off him so he can get up. Classed as intentional strike to the groin. THEN gets downgraded to intentional stike to upper leg and gets 2 weeks. I mean seriously WTF are these guys on?

It was a clear elbow to the groin area. Disgraceful defense by west coast too, claiming that Thomas is a serial stager and was just play acting after being elbowed in the balls.

Piss poor action by Judd though. 3 -5 weeks.

 

[Groupie_]

Will get 1 week.

 

[themarkedman72]

attack the ball with honesty and your a thug.

Pull dirty, sly underhand cowardly acts and your a champion.

This is Vlads AFL.

thanks

 

[Gasometer]

Whole game is about to be replayed on FOXFOOTY at 10.30am

Interestingly I am keen to hear the commentary around this incident having been at the ground last night.

 

[eth-dog]

Intentional, severe (if he executed it correctly, didn't watch the game) impact, body contact.

8 activation points, resulting a level 5 offence which means 525 points, plus a carry-over of 25? points from the Rischitelli incident, plus 10% loading results in 605 demerit points, with 25% off with an early guilty plea means 453.75 points and a 4 game suspension

That, unfortunately, is the most games he can get the sniping son of a bitch

 

[AS211]

At least Hartlett was the player making the tackle and it was in play. Someone else tackled Adams and he was faced down with a Blues player lying over his back with no chance to move the ball on before Judd came in as the 3rd man.

Totally different incidents. Why did Hartell grab the arm? To lay a tackle.

Why did Judd grab the arm. pull it back and up and then twist it? To hurt him.

Sorry champ but Hartlett tried to wrench Fyfe's arm out of its socket.

To me, Judd is trying to lock his arm so he cant handball.

Dumbshit thing to do but if he wanted to hurt him he could have peel him open like a can of baked beans.

 

[MaddAdam]

good to see other players sticking their head out on this. although they will probably get fined as well.

piss weak act by Judd. WCE fans will always have a spot for Judd but his dogact history while being at Carlton is pretty poor.

hope he gets 4 weeks.

They'll struggle to fine Harro given he has retired but entirely agree it is great to see people calling this for the weak act it is.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Intentional, severe (if he executed it correctly, didn't watch the game) impact, body contact.

8 activation points, resulting a level 5 offence which means 525 points, plus a carry-over of 25? points from the Rischitelli incident, plus 10% loading results in 605 demerit points, with 25% off with an early guilty plea means 453.75 points and a 4 game suspension

That, unfortunately, is the most games he can get the sniping son of a bitch

It wasnt severe impact.

Nice of you to do the maths but next time watch the incident first.

 

[eth-dog]

It wasnt severe impact.

Nice of you to do the maths but next time watch the incident first.

If he executed it correctly Adams is out for 2 months. I don't know, I've seen the incident, but not the game. Did Adams come back? What was the impact? High?

 

[Frodo]

I'm no Judd lover but he did no wrong in this instance.
This picture shows clearly that the ball was trapped under Adams right midriff.
Judd was simply trying to lift the player off the ball so his team mate could extract the ball.

 

[H2F]

Most bizarre thing I have ever seen ...

I'm fairly forgiving but I'm struggling to wrap my head around this.

The only thing that is lucid for me is that is was Carlton who offended.

 

[JimmyDE]

I can't believe he got away with elbowing Pav what a joke, surely he has to be suspended this time.

 

[Demonheart]

I'm no Judd lover but he did no wrong in this instance.
This picture shows clearly that the ball was trapped under Adams right midriff.
Judd was simply trying to lift the player off the ball so his team mate could extract the ball.

Really, to me that angle makes it look worse. The north player is on the ground with another Carlton player on his back, he clearly is unable to defend himself. Judd pulls his arm back at an angle that can only cause damage.

Terrible and disgusting act.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I'm no Judd lover but he did no wrong in this instance.
This picture shows clearly that the ball was trapped under Adams right midriff.
Judd was simply trying to lift the player off the ball so his team mate could extract the ball.

There was no teammate within five metres of Judd though (not on the "ball" side of Adams) , apart from the player tackling Adams.

Exactly who was going to extract the ball and why did Judd deem it neccessary to lift the arm so high?

That argument wont fly.

 

[Chadwiko]

Interestingly I am keen to hear the commentary around this incident having been at the ground last night.

Prepare to be disgusted. They barely talked about it, and when they did, PRAISED JUDD FOR DOING IT "STEALTHILY"


I'm not even kidding.