Chris Masten biting allegation

Remove this Banner Ad

I cannot wait for the BF/ WCE melt down when masten gets more weeks than silvagni now that Cripps has been shown to not be seriously injured !! ;)
 
hoss said:
Kindergarten teachers lie too. Masten knows he bit him and Suban knows he got bitten. I'm not the one here saying Silvagni 'accidently' hit Cripps. You may be desensitised to biting, as you say you see plenty in your class, but you are being blinded by your team loyalty and supporting a filthy dog act.
Click to expand...
Saying what I believe is not lying. It is my opinion and I state that it is what I think. You think Suban was bitten, i think he wasn't and why I think he wasn't. I have not stooped to saying derogatory things about you so I would prefer it if you did not keep attacking me on a personal basis.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

hoss said:
Kindergarten teachers lie too. Masten knows he bit him and Suban knows he got bitten. I'm not the one here saying Silvagni 'accidently' hit Cripps. You may be desensitised to biting, as you say you see plenty in your class, but you are being blinded by your team loyalty and supporting a filthy dog act.
Click to expand...
you're being blinded by your tears. enjoy the finals :thumbsu:
 
raffrox said:
Congratulations on your work. Very valuable to society and I thank you for it.

Pretty much counts for zero in this situation though. Suban was VERY confident that there was a bite. You don't show an ump your arm up close straight away if there is nothing to show. If there was no evidence it would have been thrown out. Simple.

That's one thing we do know for a fact. There's enough there for it to go straight to the tribunal.

No expert west coast witnesses or JFK freeze frames are going to persuade me otherwise. Id suggest the tribunal are busy blokes and wouldn't waste their time if there wasn't some kind of evidence.
Click to expand...
Going to be interesting to see how they adjudicate this if there is no clear vision. It goes straight to tribunal because there is no grading system for that is what I understand.
I am just not convinced he did bite.
 
hoss said:
Kindergarten teachers lie too. Masten knows he bit him and Suban knows he got bitten. I'm not the one here saying Silvagni 'accidently' hit Cripps. You may be desensitised to biting, as you say you see plenty in your class, but you are being blinded by your team loyalty and supporting a filthy dog act.
Click to expand...
You can't make conclusive statements without conclusive evidence.
 
Oxirane said:
If there are teeth marks, how do you distinguish if they are from Masten's jaw biting down, or from the force of Suban pushing his forearm into Masten's mouth/teeth.
Click to expand...

If there are no lower jaw bite marks, then he wasn't bitten. To bite you use both upper and lower jaws. If it's only upper jaw marks, then Suban pushed his arm into Masten's mouth/mouthguard. I thought it was interesting that the marks on Suban's arm didn't look red...as a fresh bite mark would.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Perception is a big thing for the AFL, I think they will want to send a message with this one....like they
did with Lake's choke hold last year.
What will be interesting does Suban"s throw him under the bus in his statement?
Don't think he can back pedal after how adamant he pleaded to the ump. about being bitten.
 
Bunnie said:
I work in Kindergarten. I see plenty of bites. That is not an intentional bite with a mouthguard. That is a scratch done with something quite sharp like fingernails or boot studs or an arm being pushed against something sharp. So unless Masto is part of some pseudo neo vampire cult that files their bottom teeth to points and has a mishappen triangular shaped jaw then I would say time to lawyer up as verdict should be not bitten.
Click to expand...

Just when you think that the West Coast posters attempts to defend heir boy can't get any more ridiculous we get this one. Is there any chance whatsoever that Suban is capable of recognising when he has been bitten? With all due respect to kindergarten employees I'm not sure their experiences in the workplace qualify them to make definitive statements about what an intentional bite from a fully grown man should look like. Full points for the effort but your statement is completely laughable.
 
andrew coombs said:
Just when you think that the West Coast posters attempts to defend heir boy can't get any more ridiculous we get this one. Is there any chance whatsoever that Suban is capable of recognising when he has been bitten? With all due respect to kindergarten employees I'm not sure their experiences in the workplace qualify them to make definitive statements about what an intentional bite from a fully grown man should look like. Full points for the effort but your statement is completely laughable.
Click to expand...
You're right, he 100% intentionally bit him, without a shred of doubt, give him 10 weeks.
 
Bunnie said:
I work in Kindergarten. I see plenty of bites. That is not an intentional bite with a mouthguard. That is a scratch done with something quite sharp like fingernails or boot studs or an arm being pushed against something sharp. So unless Masto is part of some pseudo neo vampire cult that files their bottom teeth to points and has a mishappen triangular shaped jaw then I would say time to lawyer up as verdict should be not bitten.
Click to expand...
And it's not even red? It looks like and old scar tbh.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Chris Masten biting allegation

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top