SwansProudly
Moderator
- Sep 5, 2016
- 9,453
- 26,554
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Sydney Swans AFLW
- Moderator
- #133
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Couple of really visible mistakes and he looked rusty but he really is strong in the air.I know it’s the solemn sworn duty of Bigfooty to find a whipping boy, but I actually thought Francis has a fairly good game.
He spent time down the race.One slight concern:
After the game all the players wander over and hand out footies to the Swans fans.
As they came over, Melican was walking like an 80 year old in need of a Zimmer frame.
Didn’t appear to be a hammy or anything - he just looked like a bloke that was banged up and really, really sore.
My assessment exactly. Hard to gauge our performance ie. Freo emotionally affected (and rightly so) yet winning in Perth is a tough ask. Overall bag the pts and move on to Carlton, whose mids and forward line I think will cause us a shit ton of trouble. If we can somehow strangle Cripps and that number 18 chap who has drunk too much koolaid, and put up a solid W, the lid will be truly off for me.Just got home from the game.
I must admit, I saw it a bit different to most.
I didn’t see “manic Sydney pressure” as the press has reported. Instead, I saw a Freo side playing an aggressive running game that troubled us - but it did enable us to punish them on turnover.
And if it wasn’t for their wonky goal kicking, the score would have been very close at half time. It was not a dominant performance by Sydney.
Main positive for me - I’m now a JJ convert. He ran with Clarke, as well as spending some time on Young and O’Meara. And whoever he played on struggled.
The only question - can he offer more than a negating role? If he can - he’s going to be a real asset for plenty of years.
And Warner looked incredibly good when he played forward.
I found it curious that Sydney clearly saw Young and Clarke as the key men to contain - not Serong.
Overall, a solid win, but not a dominant win.
Yep. Woeful. Other Passengers: Papley, Roberts (amazing kick yet got schooled on several occasions when defending - can’t have that in your game). The rest of the team was really good in my view.God I hope TMac is back next week, Francis was a complete liability last night. Running 40m off his man to try and impact the contest, miss the ball, and then be woefully out of position
I must have been watching something else. I thought he was awful.I know it’s the solemn sworn duty of Bigfooty to find a whipping boy, but I actually thought Francis has a fairly good game.
he had a few hard collisions/contest, one I thought may have ended his night at the timeOne slight concern:
After the game all the players wander over and hand out footies to the Swans fans.
As they came over, Melican was walking like an 80 year old in need of a Zimmer frame.
Didn’t appear to be a hammy or anything - he just looked like a bloke that was banged up and really, really sore.
Even harder to win the week after coming back. Especially over a side that barely gets out of inner city Melbourne. The trip to Sydney must give them nose bleeds lolAlways tough to win over in Perth. Anyone who says they wouldn't have taken an 8 goal win before the opening bounce has rocks in their head.
As a part of the forward structure he is already a weapon. I think our forward line is very strong. They kick over 60% of our scores which is high. Only Carlton have higher but through only two forwards. Stop those two, crunch Crips, end of story.Amartey showed a bit tonight. If he puts all his tools together he can be an absolute weapon.
What I found startling was just how much ground our players covered, and how quickly they bounced up from being involved in a tackle. I know this is summarised as “work-rate”, but it’s really impressive to see in real life. I supposed I expected our smaller players to bounce around quickly, but to see Hayden MacLean be involved in a tackle, then to be in a position to receive the next kick was impressive.
I think it’s becoming more & more apparent that the team was probably affected by illness that week.Felt it was only missing one game this year too, which we lost.
I have always been a fan. I knew what he could do from watching his junior tapes. While games in finals. In the U18's he kicked 9 goals in a prelim to get his team, North, into the GF. They lost the GF by 1 point & he kicked 4 out of 7. Always dangerous. He has a natural knack of finding a goal. I think the Forwards Coach is allowing him off the leash more this year. I believe his development has been hampered by having to shut down defenders. He is a dangerous player if allowed to play his natural game.Yeah a few with egg on their face over Hayward. Absolute star.
I think it’s becoming more & more apparent that the team was probably affected by illness that week.
It’s the only plausible explanation.
I think you've hit the nail on the head regarding our forward line. Some like to point the finger at Amartey and Hayward because they're not taking 10 marks and kicking 4+ goals every week. If our main avenue to goal was these two, then sure, have a crack. But they are part of a unit that is kicking 100+ more often than not, with an even spread across the forward line. While we're on a roll, best to keep the consistency in our team.I have always been a fan. I knew what he could do from watching his junior tapes. While games in finals. In the U18's he kicked 9 goals in a prelim to get his team, North, into the GF. They lost the GF by 1 point & he kicked 4 out of 7. Always dangerous. He has a natural knack of finding a goal. I think the Forwards Coach is allowing him off the leash more this year. I believe his development has been hampered by having to shut down defenders. He is a dangerous player if allowed to play his natural game.
The thing is, we have so many dangerous forwards. If you clamp Wil down, then Amartey or McLean get off the leash by having the third tall. Amartey has shown on two occasions already he will destroy a third tall. Then they have to keep Paps, Wicks or the resting Adams, Heeney or Chad. That is effing hard.
Then there is the fact that our mids are kicking over 40% of scores. They hit the scoreboard. Lloydy, Maca, Gulden etc are very effing dangerous
On CPH2471 using BigFooty.com mobile app
Plenty of missed spoils, and then when he did spoil he kept hitting it to dumb areas.I know it’s the solemn sworn duty of Bigfooty to find a whipping boy, but I actually thought Francis has a fairly good game.