Discussion Coronavirus

[Verdun]

Good idea for a discussion. We need line ups for reference tho to discuss match ups

yep fair point ....will try and track down and put up as a post

 

[saintsrfreak]

Jeez it was nice when we could kick the footy

 

[MUFKilda]

Can't get pasta for love nor money, which is a big inconvenience for us vegetarians.

 

[Mowman]

Can't get pasta for love nor money, which is a big inconvenience for us vegetarians.

Can't get pasta here at the minute, i have a nice leg of lamb for the spit tomorrow

 

[plugger66]

2009 side with 2005 coach

That meant we wouldn’t have made the finals. I’m just going by one was the most wanted coach. The other wasn’t wanted at all. Imagine 2005 with Lyon. It wind the flag by some margin

 

[MUFKilda]

That meant we wouldn’t have made the finals. I’m just going by one was the most wanted coach. The other wasn’t wanted at all. Imagine 2005 with Lyon. It wind the flag by some margin

Same with the 1985 team with Richo coaching

 

[Enclosed_Animal]

2009 side with 2005 coach

If Lyon was coaching in 05, Roo, Ball, Fish, Dal and BJ would have all been too young and / or inexperienced to get a game.

We would have still been running out with Loewe, Burke, Tony Delaney, Tim Elliott and Wells Eicke - while Roo kicked 10 in the seconds each week.

GT actually built that team. Lyon inherited the best list St.Kilda has ever put together

 

[plugger66]

Same with the 1985 team with Richo coaching

Yep. Certainly wouldn’t have lost our first 3 games by 100 points or more.

 

[MUFKilda]

Yep. Certainly wouldn’t have lost our first 3 games by 100 points or more.

Who was the coach back in that dark period?

 

[gringo2011]

Honestly haven't felt the same about footy since he retired. Club lost its soul that day. Still trying to find it.

We really need some heroes. We have some good players but no champion. We always had someone in my time, it feels weird not having someone with all our hopes pinned to them. Stuv was probably closest. Now we are in transition.

 

[plugger66]

Who was the coach back in that dark period?

Gellie. He was a bit wobbly as a coach. Worst record of any saints coach over 10 games. Not his fault though. We didn’t have enough money to even pay the players.

 

[George]

Who was the coach back in that dark period?

You should read this in your spare time

Russell is our #1 club historian. I have this at home, fantastic read about our history (up until the book was released in the mid 90's).

Heroes With Halos St Kilda's on Hundred Greatest by Russell Holmes for sale online | eBay

Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Heroes With Halos St Kilda's on Hundred Greatest by Russell Holmes at the best online prices at eBay!

www.ebay.com.au

Our Grand Final side of 1913, by the way!

 

[triggering bro]

Who was the coach back in that dark period?

Alan Richardson is the worst coach in our entire history. Give him our 05 or 09 list & we are bottom 4.

 

[bergholt]

Sydney is the most densely populated city in Aus and NSW is massive. It will always be worse there.

What?

Sydney's population density is 423/sq km.
Melbourne's is 531/sq km.

Total populations, Victoria is 6.6m while NSW is 8.1m. So it's 20% bigger.

 

[plugger66]

Alan Richardson is the worst coach in our entire history. Give him our 05 or 09 list & we are bottom 4.

You are obviously younger than 15. Watters was clearly worse for a start. Nearly distorted the club. And gellie made richo look like Clarkson.

 

[MUFKilda]

Amid reports of panic buying, incredible CCTV footage released from the toilet paper aisle of a supermarket in the Melbourne area.

 

[bergholt]

Taking into account population, this is the current situation.

NSW worst because of cruise ships. Apart from that, almost certainly these figures are just luck, rather than anything about the management of the disease.

But we'll know more in a couple of months.

 

[Mowman]

Alan Richardson is the worst coach in our entire history. Give him our 05 or 09 list & we are bottom 4.

Not just our history

 

[triggering bro]

You are obviously younger than 15. Watters was clearly worse for a start. Nearly distorted the club. And gellie made richo look like Clarkson.

I would take The Wisp or Golfing Blight over Richo. Even Neeld TBH.

 

[BrutThough]

I would take The Wisp or Golfing Blight over Richo. Even Neeld TBH.

so you just irrationally hate the guy

 

[plugger66]

I would take The Wisp or Golfing Blight over Richo. Even Neeld TBH.

Well that just shows you haven’t watched a lot of footy pre richo. That’s ok. We aren’t all as old and experienced about footy as myself. I actually thought you were older than 15.

 

[Mowman]

I would take The Wisp or Golfing Blight over Richo. Even Neeld TBH.

Never has anyone been so far out of the depth
what a waste of 6 years

 

[triggering bro]

Well that just shows you haven’t watched a lot of footy pre richo. That’s ok. We aren’t all as old and experienced about footy as myself. I actually thought you were older than 15.

How does it feel to know you’ve been arguing with a 15 year old all this time? Bully

 

[plugger66]

so you just irrationally hate the guy

It’s funny hoe irrational people can be over a coach. Maybe they should look back into the lists before they decide to write rubbish.

 

[triggering bro]

so you just irrationally hate the guy

The serious guy has entered the chat