- Banned
- #251
What happened with Masala & MTL?
When I initially checked the scores it looked like 103-102 victory to Masala. Now a draw.
When I initially checked the scores it looked like 103-102 victory to Masala. Now a draw.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
D4 D4 2017
- Thread starter Over The Post
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I saw a draw at first. Then checked later and it was a one point win. So perhaps a live score error?
white knuckler
Draftee
- Jun 8, 2016
- 4
- 4
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Scoreboard and goal umpires had masala winning by a point at full time, time keepers had t as a draw. I believe the result is going to be decided by the league but would of thought goal umpires scorecards would win out if there was no discrepancy
table tennis
Bigfooty class clown
Dont count on it
I would have thought two goal umpires agreeing would outweigh timekeepers? Seems logical doesn't it?
white knuckler
Draftee
- Jun 8, 2016
- 4
- 4
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
That's what I would of thought. I wasn't there so can't 100% confirm this but from what Ive heard goal umpires both agreed masala was up by a point at the end
HighwayStar
Rookie
Yes. Both Goal Umpires scorecards agreed on a 1 point win to Masala, both Timekeepers scorecards agreed on a draw. The 1 point discrepancy was identified at 3/4 time. Scoreboard and Live Score reflected the Goal Umpires scorecards. Officiating Field Umpires said that the Timekeepers scorecards take precedence - but they have referred the matter to VAFA for review.
HighwayStar
Rookie
Some Clubs dropping down to Clubbies are put in Club XVIII (1) whilst others are put in Club XVIII (2). Would love to know how the decision is made.
Scoobiesnack
Team Captain
So the opinions of the two people in charge of waving the flags and actually watching the game and following the footy, are held in less regard to a couple of crackers drinking tea and talking shit 3kms away from the goal posts.
Yeah fair enough.
Yeah fair enough.
Over The Post
🐍Bless The OOBs🐍
- Nov 17, 2007
- 19,699
- 26,263
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
Ophidian Old Boys
- Thread starter
- #260
So beautifully put.
Was the game videoed by either side? Fast forwarding through the third quarter and recording scores as they happened should show any error.
Neddy Flanders
Debutant
Bizzare..So beautifully put.
Was the game videoed by either side? Fast forwarding through the third quarter and recording scores as they happened should show any error.
Not sure all teams would have access to recording games or do it week in week out.
Lets hope common sense prevails here
Over The Post
🐍Bless The OOBs🐍
- Nov 17, 2007
- 19,699
- 26,263
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Ophidian Old Boys
- Thread starter
- #262
Even from under 9s there's usually someone with a video camera standing on the sidelines. Even unofficial parent / club video would suffice. Obviously if its not available then so be it.
Goal umpires have priority over scorers. Simple as that. It is their obligation to confirm scores at every break & at games end. My experience has Goalies are god!
Over The Post
🐍Bless The OOBs🐍
- Nov 17, 2007
- 19,699
- 26,263
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Ophidian Old Boys
- Thread starter
- #264
Not quite. I had one semifinal where us goalies differed by one point, neither of us agreed with the scoreboard (which was taken down before we waved it off), and when we finally got one timekeepers scorecard it had the final score agreeing with me but had been crossed out and one point deducted, making it agree with my partner. The other timekeeper had shot through and taken his card with him. It was easiest to just alter mine and be done with it. Then the coach wants to know why our scorecards differed from both team managers notes (which were the same as mine). I still get a headache thinking about it.
The timekeepers in this instant watched all of the game within 50 mtrs of the goals at either end as Masala's ground is only the size of a postage stamp. It appeared that one of the Goal umpires missed signalling a point during the 3rd quarter and didn't wave his flags. The Goal umpires are only human and also volunteers.
I've time kept for some 12 years at away games and have not missed a beat except on this occasion where both Time Keepers agreed it was a draw and advised the Senior Umpire accordingly to seek clarification.
I've time kept for some 12 years at away games and have not missed a beat except on this occasion where both Time Keepers agreed it was a draw and advised the Senior Umpire accordingly to seek clarification.
Well done Fangstar. Volunteers are life blood of our clubs.
table tennis
Bigfooty class clown
What was the outcome? Still a draw?
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
When in the year would teams not be able to accept new players? I'm moving back to Melbourne next week and wouldn't mind having a run around.
I think the answer is today.
Neddy Flanders
Debutant
Aquinas by plenty
NB by plenty
Cobras
EPS
NB by plenty
Cobras
EPS
white knuckler
Draftee
- Jun 8, 2016
- 4
- 4
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Aquinis
Nb
Manningham
Masala
Nb
Manningham
Masala
Scoobiesnack
Team Captain
Notice Shane McLaren still playing well.
How many BnFs has this bloke won.
He'd have to have won the last 3 on the trot.
How many BnFs has this bloke won.
He'd have to have won the last 3 on the trot.
Neddy Flanders
Debutant
Elsternwick over Masala - 35
NB comfortably
Aquinas by plenty
EPS by 5 goals
NB comfortably
Aquinas by plenty
EPS by 5 goals
HighwayStar
Rookie
Yep, the draw stands.
table tennis
Bigfooty class clown
Results from Masala v Elsternwick?
- Status
