Dayne Beams or Mitch Robinson

[TBoyleSuperstar]

I'd take Beams. Love Robinson's attack on the footy, can play too, but Beams has stood up this year since Ball went down and has taken his game to a new level. Robbo hasn't been able to stand up to the same level (could possibly be Ratten's fault for not making him more of a midfielder). Beams has produced numbers consistantly that is in line with what A grade guns get. He, along with Sidebottom, is one of the reasons Collingwood is flying.

 

[2010premiership]

Good god when was this thread created? The week Robinson got a kick?

Beams has become top 10 elite

 

[the distributer]

Beams is on the way to becoming a star, only negative is he doesn't have a great finals record, but injurys are to blame for that IMO.

As for the question, Beams by a long way ATM.

 

[Adz2332]

If Port had the chance to take one... Beams by a long way

 

[Kipz]

Robbo would be lucky to pick mud out of Beamsy's boots after a training session

 

[Kramer1]

Think Beams is a gem...love the way he goes about his footy. Would rate him in the top 4-5 of his draft, and Robbo somewhere just outside the top ten so there is your answer.

Some of the commentary of Robinson on here is a bit over the top though...plenty of valid opportunitites to pot Carlton this year, no need to have a crack at the one bloke who is showing some spirit.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Robinson is an honest trier (one of the better honest triers going around, but an honest trier nonetheless) and Beams is a star. No contest. Bonus points to Beams for not looking like a character from Deliverance.

 

[Scott Emberton]

This made me laugh! Robinson is the most over rated player in the comp

 

[eaglespremiers]

Robinson is good but even in what he excels in (contested ball) he is not as good as Beams.
Enough said.

 

[dingoboy]

You would take beams over robinson any day of the week.

Who would want to look at that ugly bunsen burner all week?

 

[Jmac2225]

This made me laugh! Robinson is the most over rated player in the comp

Robinson is rated??

 

[Sin City]

You would take beams over robinson any day of the week.

Who would want to look at that ugly bunsen burner all week?

Fair to say neither of them will ever be asked to model for an oil painting.....

 

[raskolnikov]

Good god when was this thread created? The week Robinson got a kick?

Beams has become top 10 elite

Top 10 in the AFL? Lol.... no.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Well Robinson was the better player tonight.
But Beams was completely shut out of the game by Carrazzo.
Certainly doesn't change my opinion but Robinson shouldn't be sneered at.

 

[Blueboiiz]

Who would want to look at that ugly bunsen burner all week?

Did lol

 

[benbanjo]

Beams for mine.... but i like the way Robinson throws himself at everything!

 

[Natho]

Beams. Robinson has a real crack but isn't polished. Beams has had to stand up all year and is doing a good job.

 

[Pie in the Sky]

Well Robinson was the better player tonight.
But Beams was completely shut out of the game by Carrazzo.
Certainly doesn't change my opinion but Robinson shouldn't be sneered at.

Yeah Robinson is a bit underrated I'd say, but Beams has been in red hot form, was due for a quiet one and got beaten by a very good tagger.

 

[juniortiger03]

I don't understand this thread it is easily Dayne Beams.
Mitch Robinson tries hard but could not be better then beams

 

[HeCanGetAndGo]

Robinson is hard at it but he lacks any real AFL talent and reminds me of Slim Shady. Personally I would take Brock McLean over him, so Beams quite easily.

 

[bradles7]

Beams by a country mile

how?????? robinson has stepped up and is one of the most useful players at the club

 

[bradles7]

ro

Beams quite easily. Robinson cant kick to save himself he is a good serviceable player nothing more. He collected 34 disposals yesterday but so did Brock Mclean so its not saying a lot.

robinson is a beutiful kick

 

[Spitta09]

ro
robinson is a beutiful kick

His kicking is VFL standard

 

[bradles7]

His kicking is VFL standard

if he`s kickings vfl standed then why does he play afl

 

[Schulzenfest]

Wow. I'm guessing 'bradles7' means you're 7 years old, right?