I've got a slightly different take on this.Dogs game.
Draper, Walters, Emmett, I agree with everyone they're not playing well enough.
We need to persist with Fyfe and Darcy.
We are every chance of playing finals this season, and if we are, Fyfe in form will be massive. I think managing him during the season can help achieve that
The second point is that Brodie at the very least is a very handy plug and play replacement if Fyfe is not available. But leaving him to whither away in the WAFL is not the ideal strategy for keep him prepped. Half a dozen games during the season alongside our other midfielders is what I would aim for.
Related:
Simpson for Walters
Davies for Draper
Erasmus for Emmett