Edwards v Yeo

[SwiftNShuey]

Who had the best 2018? Yes started by an Eagles fan.. Interested in the general consensus.

 

[GodJokers]

Yeo comfortably for me, would of even had him above Higgins.

 

[Greggy]

Edwards was close to winning a Norm Smith in the only game that matters. The true test of a player and he passed with flying colours.

 

[Donakebab]

Edwards was close to winning a Norm Smith in the only game that matters. The true test of a player and he passed with flying colours.

It has absolutely zero relevance in this thread given the question asked was about the 2018 home and away season.

 

[Aussie_boy]

Edwards was close to winning a Norm Smith in the only game that matters. The true test of a player and he passed with flying colours.

Didn't realise the GF had already been played.

And Yeo comfortably, that's not to say Edwards didn't have a good season though.

 

[juss]

Think Yeo could have easily made the AA team

 

[2006_Eagles]

Think Yeo could have easily made the AA team

Should have been the first Eagle picked

 

[juss]

Should have been the first Eagle picked

Probably next year, for some odd reasons they always want a year or two of high standard before you get picked.

 

[2006_Eagles]

Probably next year, for some odd reasons they always want a year or two of high standard before you get picked.

He made it last year doe

 

[juss]

He made it last year doe

Whoops.

 

[2006_Eagles]

Whoops.

Thing is, he had a better year this year. AA guys have NFI

IMO it should be a fan voted thing like the NBA All Star Game

 

[juss]

Thing is, he had a better year this year. AA guys have NFI

IMO it should be a fan voted thing like the NBA All Star Game

Problem with fan votes is it becomes a popularity contest skewed by liked players from popular teams.

 

[2006_Eagles]

Problem with fan votes is it becomes a popularity contest skewed by liked players from popular teams.

Something needs to be done. To leave guys like Yeo and Dev Smith out and have guys like Edwards and Gray in the side just makes you get upset

I also disagree with the Gaff inclusion for a bunch of reasons

 

[juss]

Something needs to be done. To leave guys like Yeo and Dev Smith out and have guys like Edwards and Gray in the side just makes you get upset

I also disagree with the Gaff inclusion for a bunch of reasons

There wont be any method that gets universal agreement for all 22 players by every follower though, is a few disagreements in a 22 man team that bad? Yes I think those guys should have been in too, but I'm sure other people disagree with other selections.

 

[2006_Eagles]

There wont be any method that gets universal agreement for all 22 players by every follower though, is a few disagreements in a 22 man team that bad? Yes I think those guys should have been in too, but I'm sure other people disagree with other selections.

Is it fair to let 6 people in the country decide the whole team?

 

[juss]

Is it fair to let 6 people in the country decide the whole team?

How many would you suggest?
Also "fair" doesnt come into it, it's not unfair, that's the committee who has been selected to choose the side.

 

[Masqualero]

I think Yeo is the better player.

Edwards is a good player but there is a gap IMO.

 

[Mitchell54]

Yep came on late in the season. Was of my radar until the last quarter of the year.

Edward probably not the best selection but I wouldn’t of had Yeo either.

Edwards gets my choice but if finals were included then Yeo

 

[HTPunter]

Is it fair to let 6 people in the country decide the whole team?

Even in sports where national teams are actually playing it's still only picked by 3-6 people. Far out. How is it `not fair`.

 

[HTPunter]

The next Ashes squad should be picked by the fan base. Unfair to let 3 people out of the whole country pick the team