Opinion Favourite players from all clubs.

[Wally Carter]

Adelaide - Pass
Brisbane - Pass
Carlton - Brock McLean
Collingwood - Pass
Essendon - Pass
Fremantle - Pass
Geelong - Joel Sellwood
Hawthorn - Pass
Melbourne - Pass
North Melbourne - Jack Ziebell
Port Adelaide - Pass
Richmond - Trent Cotchin
St Kilda - Lenny Hayes
Sydney - Pass
West Coast - Daniel Kerr
Western Bulldogs - Brad Johnson

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Adelaide - Jason Porplyzia
Brisbane - Simon Black
Carlton - Marc Murphy/Andrew Walker
Collingwood - Darren Jolly
Essendon - Alwyn Davey
Fremantle - Luke McPharlin
Geelong - Cam Mooney
Hawthorn - Campbell Brown
Melbourne - Nathan Jones
North Melbourne - Drew Petrie
Port Adelaide - Stephen Salopek
Richmond - Brett Deledio
St Kilda - Brendan Goddard
Sydney - Tadgh Kennelly
West Coast - Josh Kennedy
Western Bulldogs - Brad Johnson

 

[RedFeather]

Adelaide - McLeod
Brisbane - Black
Carlton - Judd
Collingwood - Medhurst
Essendon - Monfries
Fremantle - Pavlich
Geelong - Ablett
Hawthorn - Franklin
Melbourne - Scully
North Melbourne - Harvey
Port Adelaide - Chad Cornes
Richmond - Deledio
St. Kilda - Dal Santo
Sydney - Kirk
West Coast - LeCras
Bulldogs - Akermanis

 

[Jilly]

Adelaide: Kurt Tippett (With Bernard and Porps tied for second )
Brisbane: Jack Redden (Friend of a friend)
Carlton: ... Bryce Gibbs?
Collingwood: Not Anthony <_<
Essendon: Not sure... maybe Zaharakis? great name and goal v Collingwood
Fremantle: Pav or VB
Geelong: Gary Ablett
Hawthorn: Brad Sewell
Melbourne: Jack Trengove (... poor boy)
North: Jack Ziebell
Port: Travis Boak
Richmond: It was Richo, haven't given much thought about his successor.
St Kilda: Leigh Montagna
Sydney: Brett Kirk
West Coast: Mark LeCras
Western Bulldogs: Adam Cooney

 

[Bombers36]

Crows - Birdman
Lions - Black
Blues - Mclean
Pies - Presti
Bombers - Watson
Dockers - McPhee
Cats - Mooney
Hawks - Hodge
Demons - Miller
Kangaroos - Petrie
Power - Motlop
Tigers - Cuz
Saints - Lovett
Swans - Kenelly
Eagles - Naitanui
Bulldogs - Eagleton

 

[CarnTheTiges]

Adelaide: N.Van Berlo
Brisbane: P.Hanley Irish And from the county I lived in
Carlton: No
Collingwood: No
Essendon: D.Zaharakis He has a better surname then anyone else who's start with Z
Fremantle: J.Van Berlo
Geelong: Ryan Gamble Don't know why
Hawthorn: Was Dew now uhh Franklin
Melbourne: Trengrove Or Scully
North: B.Harvey
Port: R.Gray
Richmond: The Cotch Or Dusty
St Kilda: Nick Dal Santo
Sydney:No
West Coast: M.LeCras
Western Bulldogs: D.Giansiracusa

 

[Almighty tigers]

Adelaide: N.Van Berlo
Brisbane: S. Black
Carlton: M. Murphy
Collingwood: L. Ball
Essendon: Alwyn Davey
Fremantle: A. Sandilands
Geelong: J. Selwood
Hawthorn: L. Hodge
Melbourne: L. jurrah
North: A. Swallow
Port: D. Motlop
Richmond: Post, Deledio, Hislop, Martin, Griffiths, Riewoldt, Cotchin the list goes on
St Kilda: Nick Dal Santo
Sydney: Adam Goodes and Brett Kirk
West Coast: Josh Kennedy
Western Bulldogs: D. Cross

 

[demon48]

Adelaide - Graham Johncock. Don't know which is greater - his skills or his name.
Brisbane - Brendan Fevola. We need characters like him in our game. A dying breed. Woo! I've got a stiffy!
Carlton - Simon Wiggins. Pretty sure he is still on the list. Everytime he gets the ball, I think of the classic Derek and Clive line "Don't you look at Wiggins doing that". And I fancy his Mrs. Looks good in that diving cossie.
Collingwood - Much as I hate them, I quite like Steele Sidebottom. Brilliant name!
Essendon - Alwyn Davey. Cause I like the Daveys.
Fremantle - Tim Ruffles. Like the name.
Geelong - Cameron Ling. Great player and character, is always prepared to have a laugh at his own expense.
Hawthorn - Cyril Rioli. Because he's delicious.
Melbourne - Liam Jurrah. Will be a superstar in the next couple of years.
North Melbourne - Ben Warren. Can't think of anyone else I like at North. He has great hair. Although Simon Buckley could take his place as my favourite.
Port Adelaide - Justin Westhoff. Cause nobody hassles the Hoff.
Richmond - Jordan McMahon. I Jordan. Kicks great goals from 50 metres out. Got us an extra pick. Awesome mo as well.
St Kilda - Brendan Goddard. Great backman and a local boy.
Sydney - Adam Goodes. Lives up to the name.
West Coast - Dean Cox. I big Cox!......that didn't come out right.
Western Bulldogs - Barry Hall. A dying breed, like Fevola. A one-man highlights reel.
Gold Coast - Josh Toy. Awesome name!

Has now been replaced by Simon Buckley.
Max Gawwwwwn equal 1st with Jurrah.

 

[thedog]

Adelaide Crows- Bernie Vince (1st cousin)
Brisbane Lions- Matt Maguire
Carlton Blues- Kane Lucas
Collingwood Magpies- Brad Dick
Essendon Bombers- Michael Hurley
Fremantle Dockers- Nat Fyfe (strong mates)
Geelong Cats- Mitch Duncan
Hawthorn Hawks- Cyril Rioli
Melbourne Dees- Jack Trengove
North Melbourne- Ben Cunnington
Port Adealide Power- NO ONE
Richmond Tigers- Matthew Richardson (even though retired still the best ever in the world)
Saint Kilda Saints- Nick Winmar
Sydney Swans- Trent Dennis-Lane
West Coast- Koby Stevens
Western Bulldogs- Shaun Higgins

 

[roostersgal4eva]

Adelaide - Porps
Brisbane - Michael Rischitelli followed by Dan Rich, Simon Black & Brenden Fevola
Carlton - Brice Gibbs
Collingwood - none
Essendon - cant think
Fremantle - Aaron Sandiliands
Geelong - Jeol Selwood
Hawthorn - Cyril Rioli
Melbourne - Liam Jurrah, Aaron Davey & Mark Jamar
Kangaroos - Brett Harvey
Port Adelaide - Kane Cornes
Richmond - was Richo so id have to get back to you
St Kilda - Lenny Hayes
Sydney - Tadgh Kennelly & Brett Kirk
Eagles - Josh Kennedy
Bulldogs - Daniel Giansiracusa

 

[Tulip]

Adelaide-Bernie Vince
Brisbane-Jonathan Brown
Carlton-Brock McLean
Collingwood-Simon Prestigiacomo/Darren Jolly
Essendon-Dustin Fletcher
Fremantle-Matthew Pavlich
Geelong-Jimmy Bartel
Hawthorn-Jarryd Roughead
Melbourne-Luke Tapscott, Brent Moloney, Liam Jurrah, James Frawley, Jack Watts, Jordan Gysberts, Tom Scully, James Strauss
North Melbourne-Ben Cunnington
Port Adelaide-John Butcher
St Kilda-Nick Riewoldt
Sydney-Gary Rohan
West Coast-Brad Sheppard (love the sisters )
Western Bulldogs-Barry Hall, Jason Ackermanis

 

[Tulip]

Richmond-Was Richo, now Trent Cotchin

 

[mfc150]

Adelaide - Bernie VINCE
Brisbane - Jonothan BROWN
Carlton - Marc MURPHY
Collingwood - Harry OBRIEN
Essendon - Michael HURLEY
Fremantle - Matthew PAVLICH
Geelong - Paul CHAPMAN
Hawthorn - Luke HODGE
Melbourne - Nathan JONES
Kangaroos - Jack ZIEBELL
Port Adelaide - Nah can't do it
Richmond - Jayden POST
St Kilda - Lenny Hayes
Sydney - Brett KIRK
Eagles - Shannon HURN
Bulldogs - Callan WARD

Fave of all time: Glenn ARCHER

 

[daz79]

adelaide - N. Bock
brisbane - J Brown
carlton - J Waite
collingwood - D Beames
essendon - M Hurley
fremantle - C Tarrant
geelong - J Bartel
hawthorn - C Bateman
melbourne - J Grimmes/ C Sylvia
north - D Petrie
port adelaide - J Butcher (he will be a star)
richmond - B Cousins
st kilda - B Goddard
sydney - K Jack
west coast - NicNat
western bulldogs B Johnson

 

[Muse]

Adelaide - Bernie Vince
Brisbane - Mitch Clark
Carlton - Eddie Betts
Collingwood - Harry O'Brien/Nick Maxwell
Essendon - Brent Prismall
Fremantle - Rhys Palmer
Geelong - Joel Selwood
Hawthorn - Cyril Rioli
Melbourne - Liam Jurrah
North Melbourne - MacIntosh
Port Adelaide - Travy Boak
Richmond - Benny Cousins
St. Kilda - Lenny Hayes
Sydney - Brett Kirk
Bulldogs - Callan Ward
West Coast - Daniel Kerr

 

[james Dean]

Adelaide - Can't really think of any, probably Dangerfield if anyone
Brisbane - Fev
Carlton - Murphy
Collingwood - Leon Neon
Essendon - None really, maybe Davey
Freo - Stephen Hill (will be the best player from the 08 draft)
Geelong - Stevie J
Hawks - Buddy
Kangaroos - Boomer
Melbourne - Jurrah
Port - Salopek (had to choose someone)
Richmond - Deledio
St K - Riewoldt
Sydney - Goodes
West Coast - NicNat
Doggies - AKA

 

[Alpha Male]

Adelaide: Simon Goodwin. As amazing as his career as been I feel he is kinda under-rated in Vic. Has played deep forward, half back and midfield with supreme class. Would be rated with Kouta, Grant, West etc just under Hird/Buckley/Voss.

Brisbane: Daniel Rich. The opposite end of the scale. I have never been as excited by a first year player as I was with Rich in 2009. Every time he got the pill in space you just knew it was going down Brown's throat. He is a gun and I expect him to be the next captain of the Lions.

Carlton: Chris Judd. At his best he is the number 1 player in the game. It's sad to see him struggling in the young Carlton midfield but hopefully with the added maturity of Gibbs, Murphy, Simpson, Carrazzo and McLean, Juddy will be able to get back to his absolute best.

Collingwood: Luke Ball. Yes he turned his back on the Saints but I love the way he plays. Hard, tough and selfless. I have seen this guy wrapped up so many times I've lost count. The Pies have got themselves a serious player here. He won't carry them to a flag alone but he will do everything his battered body allows.

Essendon: Paddy Ryder. This guy is a freak. He can play back, forward, ruck and rover all at an A grade level. I think the ruck is his best spot and I'd hope that he can keep his number one spot even with Hille coming back next year. Not afraid of flying for a big grab either!

Fremantle: Michael Johnson. Kind of a left field pick but I really like this guy. I think he has the potential to be as good as Sam Fisher andNathan Bock, playing at CHB but running off his opponent. Hopefully he gets a few more games in 2010.

Geelong: Paul Chapman. I rate this guy alot. One of the best half forwards in the game. He can just turn it on (see the 09 GF) and win games off his own boot. Reminds me alot of James Hird who I rank as the best I've ever seen. I wish he was playing at my club.

Hawthorn: Buddy Franklin. It's hard to go past a bloke who's kicked 100 goals in a season. Half of them were porbably on the run or around the corner too. As exciting a player as we have in the AFL he is one of those guys that neutral fans would pay to go and watch.

Melbourne: Cale Morton. Reminds me of Brendon GOddard when he was first playing. Still looking for a spot, trying to work out whether he should bulk up or stay trim... A very smooth moving player that I think will end up in the middle, just like Goddard.

North Melbourne: Aaron Edwards. He's from out in my area and I've spoken to him at a fair few poker games. He was picked up then delisted then destroyed the VFL then picked up again. Not the most talented bloke obviously but gee he gets everything out of himself.

Port Adelaide: Daniel Motlop. At his best I have him as one of the best 5-10 players in the game right now. He just can't seem to get it together for a full season. Does the rediculous things that we expect from players but he still manages to find ways of kicking goals no matter the situation. His performance against Essendon recently when he kicked 7 was mind blowing.

Richmond: Richard Tambling. Gotta cheer for the underdog. The poor guy was harshly judged because he was taken in front of Buddy but dammit I like him. He had to play under Terry Wallace and was used poorly before being given some freedom by Jade Rawlings. He can be a top line midfielder if given the chance and hopefully he can continue with his good form from the second half of 2009.

St. Kilda: Stevie Milne. I'm gonna get lynched here I know but Milne has been my favorite player ever since he started with the Saints. The best small forward in the game with an average of 2 goals per game. He has also kicked more goals in one game than any other current player with 11 vs. Brisbane. He is hated by opposition supporters and is a scape goat for Saints fans but through it all Milney just keeps kicking goals.

Sydney: Adam Goodes. The Mark 2 prototype player. Goodes has gone on where Kouta left off as one of the most versatile players in the comp. His move to CHF will be a good one for the Swans and he could possibly pick up another Brownlow in his twilight years. One of my favorite 5 players in the comp.

West Coast: Nic Nat. Like Rich, I was blown away by just how exciting this guy is. His last qtr against the Hawks last season was one of the most fun to watch in 2009 as we all screamed "NO, NO, NO, YES, NO, YES, YES, YEEESS!!" while watching him fumble recover, fumble again and then finish with a goal. He will have his face plastered everywhere inside 3 years.

Western Bulldogs: Mathew Boyd. Gets nowhere near enough credit for his work with Cooney, Griffen, Cross, Johnson and Acker getting the limelight. He was lucky to be picked up and has made the most of his chance getting into the AA team in 2009.

 

[up_the_bombers13]

Adelaide - Vince or Walker
Brisbane - Rich
Carlton - Carrazzo
Collingwood - John Anthony
Essendon - Watson
Fremantle - Hinkley
Geelong - Josh Hunt
Hawthorn - Hodge
Melbourne - Bell or Moloney
North - Anthony
Port - Gray
Richmond - Jackson
St Kilda - Montagna
Sydney - White
West Coast - Waters
Bulldogs - Harbrow

 

[WN123]

Adelaide - Vince
Brisbane - Fev
Carlton - Kruzer
Collingwood - Pendlebury
Essendon - Fletcher
Fremantle - Soloman
Geelong - Chapman
Hawthorn - Hodge
Melbourne - Jurrah
Kangaroos - Ziebell
Port Adelaide -
Richmond - Riewoldt
St Kilda - Riewoldt
Sydney - Kirk
Eagles - Naitanui
Bulldogs - Lake

 

[smiths]

Adelaide-Porplyzia
Brisbane-Power
Carlton-Judd
Collingwood-Pendlebury
Essendon-Watson
Fremantle-Pavlich
Geelong-Enright
Hawthorn-Rioli
Melbourne-Trengove
North Melbourne-L. Anthony
Port Adelaide-Chad
Richmond- Cousins
St Kilda-Riewoldt
Sydney-Mcveigh
West Coast-Swift
Western Bulldogs-Boyd

 

[Lexington Steele]

Adelaide- Wayne Weidemann
Brisbane- Scott McIvor
Carlton- Tommy Alvin
Collingwood- Mark Orchard
Essendon- Bradley Plain
Fremantle- Gary Dhurkkay
Geelong- Spiro Malakellis
Hawthorn- Rayden Tallis
Melbourne- Brent Grgic
North Melbourne- Stuart Cochrane
Port Adelaide-David Brown
Richmond- Trevor Poole
St Kilda- Tim Pekin
Sydney-Jamie Lawson
West Coast- Brett 'Heady'
Western Bulldogs- Sedat Sir

 

[Rack Watts]

Adelaide - Jason Porplyzia
Brisbane - Justin Sherman
Carlton - Mitch Robinson
Collingwood - Steele Sidebottom
Essendon - David Hille
Fremantle - Dean Solomon
Footscray - Daniel Cross
Geelong - Steve Johnson
Hawthorn - Cyril Rioli
Melbourne - Aaron Davey
Kangaroos - Jack Ziebell
Port Adelaide - Travis Boak
Richmond - Trent Cotchin
St Kilda - Andrew Lovett
Sydney - Craig Boton
West Coast - Daniel Kerr

 

[_The_Magpie_Nut_]

Adelaide - Andrew Mcleod
Brisbane - Jono Brown
Carlton - Chris Judd
Collingwood - Alan Didak, Steele Sidebottom, Dane Swan
Essendon - Brett Stanton
Fremantle - Mathew Pavlich
Footscray - Daniel Cross
Geelong - Cameron Mooney
Hawthorn - Lance Franklin
Melbourne - Liam Jurrah
Kangaroos - Drew Petrie
Port Adelaide - Daniel Motlop
Richmond - Brett Deledio
St Kilda - Nick Reiwoldt
Sydney - Craig Boton
West Coast - Daniel Kerr

 

[SouthSwans]

Adelaide - David Mackay
Brisbane - Simon Black
Carlton - Marc Murphy
Collingwood - Leon Davis
Essendon - David Zaharakis
Fremantle - Luke McPharlin
Geelong - David Wojcinski
Hawthorn - Taylor Duryea
Melbourne - Ricky Petterd
North Melbourne - Jack Ziebell
Port Adelaide - Robbie Gray
Richmond - Alex Rance
St Kilda - Robert Eddy
Sydney - Taylor Gilchrist, Brett Kirk, Adam Goodes, Jarrad McVeigh
West Coast - Nic Naitanui
Western Bulldogs - Jason Akermanis

 

[Bartel]

Adelaide - Tyson Edwards
Brisbane - Simon Black
Carlton - Matthew Kreuzer
Collingwood - Scott Pendlebury
Essendon - Jobe Watson
Fremantle - Matthew Pavlich
Geelong - Paul Chapman
Hawthorn - Cyril Rioli
Melbourne - Liam Jurrah
North Melbourne - David Hale
Port Adelaide - Chad Cornes
Richmond - Matthew Richardson
St. Kilda - Lenny Hayes
Sydney - Brett Kirk
Bulldogs - Jason Akermanis
West Coast - Dean Cox


If that was 2 months ago I would fully agree with that