Opinion Favourite players from all clubs.

[SammyFish25]

St Kilda - Jason Trianidis

Loving it

 

[Hoppers Xing]

Adelaide - Goodwin
Brisbane - Brown
Carlton - Murphy
Collingwood - Harry O
Essendon - Mark Williams
Fremantle - Pavlich/Sandilands
Geelong - Enright
Hawthorn - Rioli
Melbourne - Davey
Kangaroos - McMahon
Port Adelaide - D. Motlop
Richmond - Deledio
St Kilda - Montagna
Sydney - Goodes
West Coast - Lynch
Western Bulldogs - Boyd

 

[Soul_Pie]

Adelaide - Porps
Brisbane - Dan Rich
Carlton - Gibbs
Collingwood- Pendles
Essendon - Hurley
Freo - Pav
Geelong - Yablett
Hawthorn - Buddy
Melbourne - Sylvia
Kangas - Petrie
Port Adelaide - Boak
Richmond - Cousins
St Kilda - Hayes
Sydney - O'Keefe
West Coast - LeCras
Western Bulldogs - Higgins

 

[Blue Girl 4 life]

Adelaide - Taylor Walker
Brisbane - Jed Adcock
Carlton - Bryce Gibbs
Collingwood -Dont really have any favourites
Essendon - Michael Hurley
Freo - Rhys Palmer
Geelong - Joel Selwood
Hawthorn - Liam Shiels
Melbourne - Jack Grimes
Kangas - Ed Lower/ Robbie Tarrant
Port Adelaide - Hamish Hartlett
Richmond - Trent Cotchin
St Kilda - Zac Dawson
Sydney - Kieran Jack
West Coast - Josh Kennedy
Western Bulldogs - Callan Ward

 

[Daitro]

Adelaide - Bernie Vince
Brisbane - Jared Brennan
Carlton - Marc Murphy
Collingwood - Dayne Beams
Essendon - Brent Prismall
Freo - Greg Broughton
Geelong - Jimmy Bartel
Hawthorn - Cyril Rioli
Melbourne - Brad Green
Kangas - Andrew Swallow
Port Adelaide - Travis Boak
Richmond - Brett Deledio
St Kilda - Nick dal Santo
Sydney - Ryan O'Keefe
West Coast - Andrew Embley
Western Bulldogs - Shaun Higgins

 

[darsh!]

Adelaide - Burton
Brisbane - Daniel Rich
Carlton - Gibbs
Collingwood - Dane Swan
Essendon - Brent Prismall
Fremantle - Greg Broughton
Geelong - Gary Ablett jnr
Hawthorn - LanceFranklin
Melbourne - Frank Grimes
North Melbourne- Andrew Swallow
Port Adelaide - Travis Boak
Richmond - Trent Cotchin
St Kilda - Lenny Hayes
Sydney - Adam Goodes
West Coast - Nick Natanui
Western Bulldogs - Shaun Higgins

 

[Swampfox]

Favourite to watch

Adelaide:
Past - Nigel Smart
Present - Brett Burton

Brisbane/Fitzroy
Past - Michael Voss - Garry Wilson
Present - Jonathan Brown

Carlton:
Past - Bruce Doull
Present - Marc Murphy

Collingwood:
Past - Barry Price
Present - Scott Pendelbury

Essendon:
Past - Ian Shelton
Present - Alwyn Davey

Fremantle:
Past - Peter Bell
Present - Rhys Palmer

Geelong:
Past - Paul Vinar
Present - Steve Johnson

Hawthorn:
Past - Peter Knights
Present - Cyril Rioli

Melbourne:
Past - Hassa Mann
Present - Liam Jurrah

North Melbourne:
Past - Peter Steward
Present - Jack Ziebell

Port Adelaide:
Past - Gavin Wanganeen
Present - Travis Boak

Richmond:
Past - Royce Hart
Present - Trent Cotchin

St Kilda:
Past - Verdun Howell
Present - Lenny Hayes

Sydney:
Past - John Rantall
Present - Brett Kirk

West Coast:
Past - Peter Matera
Present - Dean Cox

Western Bulldogs:
Past - Ted Whitten
Present - Brad Johnson

 

[Costanza_]

Adelaide - McLeod
Brisbane - Black
Carlton - Waite
Collingwood - Davis
Essendon - Watson
Fremantle - Sandliands
Geelong - Rooke
Hawthorn - Franklin
Melbourne - Davey
North Melbourne - Ziebell
Port Adelaide - Motlop
Richmond - Cousins
St. Kilda - Riewoldt
Sydney - Kirk
West Coast - Cox
Western Bulldogs - Lake

 

[Swans120]

Adelaide: Brett Burton/Andrew McLeod
Brisbane: Jonathan Brown
Carlton: Chris Judd
Collingwood: Harry O'Brien
Essendon: Courtney Dempsey
Fremantle: Mathew Pavlich
Geelong: Corey Enright
Hawthorn: Lance Franklin/Shaun Burgoyne
Melbourne: Aaron Davey
North Melbourne: Drew Petrie
Port Adelaide: Daniel Motlop/David Rodan
Richmond: Brett Deledio
St. Kilda: Lenny Hayes
Sydney: Tadgh Kennelly/Adam Goodes/Jude Bolton
West Coast: Darren Glass, hate the lot of them, but i respect Glass the most
Western Bulldogs: Barry Hall

 

[The Purple Jesus]

Adelaide: Tyson Edwards: Mr Professional
Brisbane: Jonathan Brown: Awesome
Carlton: Chris Judd: Gun
Collingwood: Alan Didak: Freak
Essendon: Courtney Dempsey: when he develops physically could be a gun
Fremantle: Mathew Pavlich: Super Star and better player than he gets credit for. Has carried Freo for a long time
Geelong: Matthew Scarlett : Best Full Back since Chris Langford
Hawthorn: Luke Hodge: Love his attitude and hard at it ways
Melbourne: Jack Grimes: Love the way he goes about it
North Melbourne: Scott Thompson: Old fashioned Full Back and rarely beaten
Port Adelaide: Dean Brogan (absolute tosser), Josh Carr a close second
Richmond: Brett Deledio : Absolute star, if Richmond improve he could win a Brownlow
St. Kilda: Sam Fisher: Brilliant at CHB, absolute star
Sydney: Warwick Capper
West Coast: Daniel Kerr: Love the way he attacks the game, gun player when fit
Western Bulldogs: Shaun Higgins: one of the best young players in game, great to watch in full flight

 

[ArdentEagle]

Adelaide - Chris Knights & Patrick Dangerfield ( I love long kicking midfielders and Dangerfield does have a lot of Ricciuto/Jarman about him )
Brisbane - Simon Black ( A champion of the game )
Carlton - Marc Murphy & Aaron Joseph ( Murphy as a footballer and I like Joseph's mongrel qualitys )
Collingwood - Alan Didak (Freak)
Essendon - Jobe Watson ( A footballers footballer )
Freo - Aaron Sandilands ( A freak and getting better )
Geelong - Gary Ablett Jr ( One of the best footballers I've ever seen )
Hawthorn - Cyril Rioli ( My absolute favourite - I wish WCE had him )
Melbourne - Aaron Davey ( Love his toe )
Kangas - Jack Ziebell ( Great young true footballer )
Port Adelaide - Kane Cornes ( Still very underrated IMO )
Richmond - Ben Cousins ( Always had a soft spot for him & Champion )
St Kilda - Lenny Hayes ( Again a real footballer )
Sydney - Adam Goodes ( Absolute champion of the game )
West Coast - Tom Swift ( I believe he'll be our next brownlow medallist )
Western Bulldogs - Brad Johnson ( His all time stats stack up against anyone )

 

[charmer]

Adelaide - Bernie Vince
Brisbane - Simon Black
Carlton - Jordan Russell
Collingwood - Ben Johnson
Essendon - David Hille
Freo - Chris Tarrant
Geelong - Andrew Mackie
Hawthorn - Jordan Lewis
Melbourne - Nathan Jones
NM - Drew Petrie
Port Adelaide - Steven Salopek
Richmond - Trent Cotchin
St. Kilda - Nick Dal Santo
Sydney - Rhyce Shaw
West Coast - Josh Kennedy
Western Bulldogs - Matthew Boyd

 

[cooper6]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Adelaide - A.Mcleod
Brisbane - Fev.
Carlton - C.Judd
Collingwood - S.Pendles
Essendon - M.Hurley
Freo - M.Johnson
Geelong - G.Ablett (just ahead of Selwood)
Hawthorn - Buddy (would have to be my favourite to watch - quite easily. i hope he lifts the bar next season)
Melbourne - L.Jurrah
NM - J.Ziebell
Port Adelaide - D.Rodan (ball of muscle, worked hard to become a footballer again when looked gone)
Richmond - Shattered I can't say Richo, was one of the best to watch, a great character. Replacement: Cousins
St. Kilda - Riewoldt
Sydney - T.Richards
West Coast - Cox
Western Bulldogs - Aker, one of my favourites to watch.

I love characters in the AFL, and hate that they are slowly disappearing. The best players to have watched in the past 10 years IMO have been Richo, Aker, Fev, Cousins, Hally, D.White, Mooney, Crawf, Gehrig...

 

[Miss_Hawk_Fan]

Adelaide - Andrew mccleod
Brisbane - Luke Power
Carlton - Marc Murphy
Collingwood - Dale Thomas
Essendon - Job watson
Freo - Luke Mcpharlin
Geelong - Joel Selwood
Hawthorn - The complete team
Melbourne - Brad Green
Kangas - Brady Rawlings
Port Adelaide - Travis Boak
Richmond - Brett delidio
St Kilda - Justin Koschice
Sydney - Ryan O'Keefe
West Coast - Andrew Embley
Western Bulldogs - Brad Johnson

 

[Butts_JZZ30]

Adelaide:
Past - Darren Jarman (one of the best natural/skillful footballers)
Present - Andrew McLeod (fortunate to have watched him play)

Brisbane/Fitzroy
Past - Michael Voss (excellent player, perfect Centre)
Present - Simon Black (has been one of the best for a decade)

Carlton:
Past - Anthony Koutifidies (dominant, versatile)
Present - Andrew Carrazzo (the less flamboyant of the Carlton midfield)

Collingwood:
Past - Barry Price
Present - Scott Pendelbury

Essendon:
Past - James Clements (tough, skillful, reliable)
Present - Harry O'Brien (can play tall or shot forwards very well)

Fremantle:
Past - Peter Bell (height wasn't an issue)
Present - Matthew Pavlich (I shudder where they would be without him)

Geelong:
Past - Garry Ablett Snr (do I need to comment?)
Present - Steve Johnson (creative, skillful, damaging)

Hawthorn:
Past - Shane Crawford (idiot, but a hard running good player)
Present - Chance Bateman (great to watch when in form)

Melbourne:
Past - David Neitz (everything you want for a capatin, versatile)
Present - Cameron Bruce (would be a star at a good club)

North Melbourne:
Past - Wayne Carey (total domination of the field)
Present - Micheal Firito (Underated, much needed)

Port Adelaide:
Past - Micheal Wilson (tough as nails, heart and soul)
Present - Warren Tredrea (fair, good team leader, strong mark)

Richmond:
Past - Matthew Richardson (deserved a stronger side around him)
Present - Trent Cotchin (will be a talented player)

St Kilda:
Past - Stewart Loewe (doesn't get credit he deserves good CHF)
Present - Lenny Hayes (hard tough, great clearance winner)

Sydney:
Past - Paul Kelly (hard tough and effective)
Present - Tadhg Kehnelley (great to watch, raw talent and speed)

West Coast:
Past - Dean Kemp (one of the greats of the 90's)
Present - Mark LeCras (excellent example of a small forward)

Western Bulldogs:
Past - Chris Grant (superb at either end)
Present - Robert Murphy (clever player, good kick)

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Current:

Adelaide: Andrew McLeod
Brisbane: Simon Black
Carlton: Brad Fisher
Collingwood: Tarkyn Lockyer
Essendon: Cale Hooker
Fremantle: Nic Suban
Geelong: Joel Selwood
Hawthorn: Luke Hodge
Kangaroos: Leigh Harding
Melbourne: Brad Green
Port Adelaide: Robbie Gray
Richmond: Trent Cotchin
St Kilda: Jason Blake
Sydney: Craig Bolton
West Coast: Darren Glass
Western Bulldogs: Liam Picken


All Time

Adelaide: Andrew McLeod
Brisbane: Simon Black
Carlton: Jason Saddington
Collingwood: Tarkyn Lockyer
Essendon: James Hird
Fremantle: Adrian Fletcher
Geelong: Brenton Sanderson
Hawthorn: Dermott Brereton
Kangaroos: Wayne Schwass
Melbourne: Jim Stynes
Port Adelaide: Stuart Dew
Richmond: Matthew Richardson
St Kilda: Robert Harvey
Sydney: Paul Kelly
West Coast: Chris Mainwaring
Western Bulldogs: Luke Darcy

 

[jd2006]

Current:

Adelaide: Bernie Vince
Brisbane: Jed Adcock (no idea why just rate him pretty high, Browny very close 2nd)
Carlton: Kade Simpson
Collingwood: Scott Pendlebury
Essendon: Angus Monfries (always kills us yet Bombers supporters hate him??)
Fremantle: Hayden Ballantyne
Geelong: Joel Selwood
Hawthorn: Shaun Burgoyne (was my fav PA player and probably nudges out Sam Mitchell)
Kangaroos: Drew Petrie
Melbourne: Cameron Bruce / Jack Watts
Port Adelaide: Steven Salopek (really struggled to pick one now both Burgoynes are gone)
Richmond: Brett Deledio
St Kilda: Nick Dal Santo
Sydney: Ryan O'Keefe
West Coast: Daniel Kerr
Western Bulldogs: Shaun Higgns / Daniel Giansaricussa


All Time

Adelaide: Andrew McLeod
Brisbane: Jason Akermanis
Carlton: Anthony Koutoufides
Collingwood: Chad Morrison
Essendon: Andrew Lovett
Fremantle: Tony Modra (had to get in the list but couldn't nudge out McLeod)
Geelong: Ronnie Burns
Hawthorn: Shane Crawford
Kangaroos: Winston Abraham
Melbourne: Alan Jackovich
Port Adelaide: Stuart Dew
Richmond: Mark Mirenda
St Kilda: Nick Dal Santo
Sydney: Andrew Dunkley
West Coast: Peter Sumich
Western Bulldogs: Chris Grant

 

[Sin City]

Adelaide - Andrew McLeod
Brisbane - Simon Black
Carlton - Andrew Walker
Collingwood - Alan Didak
Essendon - Alwyn Davey
Freo - Matthew Pavlich
Geelong - Corey Enright
Hawthorn - Luke Hodge
Melbourne - Liam Jurrah
Kangaroos - Drew Petrie
Port Adelaide - Travis Boak
Richmond - Nathan Foley
St Kilda - Nick Riewoldt
Sydney - Lewis Jetta
West Coast - Nic Naitanui
Western Bulldogs - Brad Johnson

 

[fletchisgun]

Adelaide- Simon Goodwin
Brisbane- Fevola
Carlton- houhlihan
Collingwood-All of them
Essendon- Hurley
Fremantle-Johnson
Geelong-Stokes
Hawthorn- Franklin
North- the rubber chicken
Melbourne- sylvia
Port- Carr
Richmond- cousins
saints- milne
West Coast-Selwood
WB- Barry

 

[Surkin]

Current:

Adelaide: Chris Knights
Brisbane: Daniel Rich
Carlton: Marc Murphy
Collingwood: Dale Thomas
Essendon: Courtney Dempsey
Fremantle: Hayden Ballantyne
Geelong: Andrew Mackie
Hawthorn: Lance Franklin
Kangaroos: N/A
Melbourne: Tom Scully
Port Adelaide: Robbie Gray
Richmond: Brett Deledio
St Kilda: Nick Riewoldt
Sydney: Lewis Jetta
West Coast: Daniel Kerr
Western Bulldogs: Shaun Higgns

 

[chigwidden]

Adelaide: Ben Rutten
Brisbane: Jono Brown
Carlton: Eddie Betts
Collingwood: Darren Jolly (He was my fave at the Swans, and I can't let go)
Essendon: Jobe Watson
Fremantle: Greg Broughten (Oh, it has already been Broughten!)
Geelong: Garry Ablett, Jr
Hawthorn: Lance Franklin
Kangaroos: Yeah, no.
Melbourne: Colin Sylvia
Port Adelaide: Dom Cassissi
Richmond: Robin Nahas
St Kilda: Stephen Milne
Sydney: Dan Hannebery
West Coast: Dean Cox (mostly because of the commentators' habit of calling him "Big Cox")
Western Bulldogs: Lindsay Gilbee

 

[Agetigers]

Adelaide: Kurt Tippett
Brisbane: Jono Brown
Carlton: Judd
Collingwood: Presti
Essendon: Melksham/Ryder
Fremantle: Super PAV
Geelong: Garry Ablett, Jr
Hawthorn: Hodge (Fav player)
Kangaroos: Basterzz
Melbourne: Brad Green
Port Adelaide: Travis Boak
Richmond: Reiwoldt (The Real one)
St Kilda: St Nick (I hope your cousin can be as good as you)
Sydney: Dan Hannebery/ Captain Kirk
West Coast: Shannon Hurn
Western Bulldogs: Shuany Higgins (another fav player)

 

[lukedarcy14]

Adelaide- Mcleod
Brisbane- Brown
Carlton- Judd
Collingwood- Didak
Essendon- Fletcher
Fremantle- Pav
Geelong- Pods
Hawks- Hodge
Melbourne- Jurruh
North-Petrie
Port- K.Cornes
Richmond- Cotchin
StKilda- Hayes
Sydney- Goodes
West Coast- Natinui or however you spell it
W.B- Cooooooney

 

[BluesKreuz]

Adelaide - Andrew McLeod
Brisbane - Simon Black
Carlton - Chris Judd
Collingwood - Harry O'Brien
Essendon - David Zaharakis
Fremantle - Greg Broughton
Geelong - Paul Chapman
Hawthorn - Shaun Burgoyne
Melbourne - Jack Grimes
North Melbourne - Brent Harvey
Port Adelaide - Travis Boak
Richmond - Brett Deledio
St Kilda - Nick Dal Santo
Sydney - Tadhg Kennelly / Adam Goodes
West Coast - Daniel Kerr
Western Bulldogs - Lindsay Gilbee / Adam Cooney

 

[Super Hans]

Adelaide- Mackay

Brisbane- Simon Black

Carlton- Murphy

Collingwood- Pendleburry

Essendon- Pears

Fremantle- Barlow

Geelong- Enright/Taylor

Hawthorn- Hodge/Sewell

Melbourne- Grimes

North Melbourne- Swallow

Port Adelaide- Gray

Richmond- Martin

St Kilda- Hayes/Gilbert

Sydney- J.Bolton/Malckeski

West Coast- LeCras

Western Bulldogs- Cross/Higgins