- Banned
- #1
Its possible Fraser and Didak will be offered to Richmond so Collingwood can gain pick 2 and Collingwood will offer that to the Eagles along with other picks etc for Judd .Source : ask officials at Collingwood .
Fraser and Didak off to Richmond for 2008 ?
- Thread starter strategy
- Start date
- Tagged users None
yeah right.
Why would richmond want Didak when we already have Browny and Pettifer up forward??
- Aug 11, 2006
- 8,123
- 3,071
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
**** off!!!
Smash`N`Grab
Club Legend
- Sep 16, 2006
- 1,147
- 4
- AFL Club
- Richmond
As if
Close thread
Close thread
- Banned
- #11
Cause he's better
yes it makes you wonder .................
wonder why people would believe this, when eroding the already thin ruck stocks would be more counter productive than getting Judd would be productive.
Cause he's better
He is better then Pettifer but he isnt as good as Browny.
- Banned
- #15
Brown is a money chaser, and not to mention his career is only going downhill from now.
Didak is at his peak.
So yes he is better.
Pendelbury for pick 2 and you have a deal
Sorry but what has Fraser proven...that he's a girl?
peternorth
Moderator
- May 6, 2005
- 131,090
- 78,947
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Moderator
- #18
me too. no deal
ClarkeM
Wonders 🏆🏆🏆🏆
- Mar 14, 2007
- 56,866
- 57,157
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Thats not even a rumour!
PHX
Quarterback Style
Nooooo. Keep pick 2 thanks.
- Apr 12, 2004
- 679
- 1
- Banned
- #21
rumour is the tiges have decided to reject fraser and didak for 2. collingwood will have to come up with better. i think pendlebury for 2 is about right, especially since it will mean collingwood get judd.
I don’t know where some of these come from. I am not personally against trading Fraser but I think Collingwood are. Either way Collingwood are already short a ruckman or two and trading Fraser would only make the ruck deficiency worse and lead to a need to get two good ruckmen onto the list. Didak is Collingwood’s best player. He won his second final for us on Friday night. If we trade Didak we will be making a bad mistake and the administration will have their got their priorities wrong. Trading Didak is a huge step backwards in winning premierships.
I reckon Didak showed he wanted to play for Collingwood on Friday night. He was injured and doubtful play and came out in the second half and brained ‘em.
As for Richmond trading pick 2, why would they facilitate a Judd deal for anyone else when they would be the beneficiaries of a deal falling through? Pick 2 to Richmond means an almost guaranteed quality player and a remote chance at a free Judd. Seriously, if Miller lets pick 2 go the chook poo should dumped on his front door step and he should be immersed in it until he stops breathing.
I reckon Didak showed he wanted to play for Collingwood on Friday night. He was injured and doubtful play and came out in the second half and brained ‘em.
As for Richmond trading pick 2, why would they facilitate a Judd deal for anyone else when they would be the beneficiaries of a deal falling through? Pick 2 to Richmond means an almost guaranteed quality player and a remote chance at a free Judd. Seriously, if Miller lets pick 2 go the chook poo should dumped on his front door step and he should be immersed in it until he stops breathing.
- Aug 11, 2006
- 8,123
- 3,071
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
**** off
Fraser = top 3 most important player at collingwood
Didak = match winner recovering from knee reco going back to his best, won us the game last week
**** off
Fraser = top 3 most important player at collingwood
Didak = match winner recovering from knee reco going back to his best, won us the game last week
**** off
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #25
If Didak was to be traded, he would have a say in where he goes. His preference is Adelaide so I doubt he would agree. Having said that is he out of contract? If he went in the PSD he would be picked up by the Tigers anyway.
Anyway, let's continue to explore this. Pies secure Pick 2, they couple it with Pick 14-17. They are still a very good player short of the Eagles expectations. Maybe a Rusling at the least. This is based on Carlton supporters suggestions that #3, #20 and Kennedy, a KPP taken at #4 two years ago, being scoffed at. Wouldn't take a gun but would take a solid player with a few years left or a developing player likely to make it.
Would the Pies give up Pick 14-17, Fraser, Didak and Rusling to get Judd?
Anyway, let's continue to explore this. Pies secure Pick 2, they couple it with Pick 14-17. They are still a very good player short of the Eagles expectations. Maybe a Rusling at the least. This is based on Carlton supporters suggestions that #3, #20 and Kennedy, a KPP taken at #4 two years ago, being scoffed at. Wouldn't take a gun but would take a solid player with a few years left or a developing player likely to make it.
Would the Pies give up Pick 14-17, Fraser, Didak and Rusling to get Judd?
