GDFL 2009 Season - Part 2

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
T

theknowledge

Debutant
Apr 13, 2008
95
0
Williamstown
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
St Marys, East Geelong
I said it had started not they were ignoring it.

Did some sums Seniors would look like
TEAM % PTS
East Geelong 154.66% 52
Thomson 147.79% 52
Bell Post Hill 156.98% 48
Werribee Centrals 135.48% 44
Corio 107.30% 36
Inverleigh 100.29% 36
North Geelong 115.62% 28
Belmont Lions 87.65% 28
Bannockburn 89.65% 24
Winchelsea 82.23% 16
Anakie 61.25% 12
Geelong West SC 38.78% 8



Reserves
TEAM % PTS
Corio 254.86% 60
Werribee Centrals 200.13% 56
East Geelong 215.81% 48
Bell Post Hill 162.40% 44
North Geelong 113.72% 32
Belmont Lions 92.86% 32
Thomson 73.74% 32
Bannockburn 106.12% 28
Anakie 80.86% 24
Geelong West SC 52.65% 12
Winchelsea 35.27% 12
Inverleigh 31.84% 4


Buddah said:
Inverleigh should investigate it the rules are quite simple if the player isnt registered with your club he cant play and if does you lose your points. It affects both seniors and reserves and every club has every write to have this investigated, there no excuses for letting this happen.
In saying all this everyone knows its true and did happen but i bet the league will sweep it under the table and if they do they better be carefull because all a club has to do is get the vcfl to look into it and that would look 10 times worse than being honest now, then having the truth coming out during or after finals when its all to late.
Click to expand...
 
Re: GDFL 2009 Season

Buddah said:
Inverleigh should investigate it the rules are quite simple if the player isnt registered with your club he cant play and if does you lose your points. It affects both seniors and reserves and every club has every write to have this investigated, there no excuses for letting this happen.
In saying all this everyone knows its true and did happen but i bet the league will sweep it under the table and if they do they better be carefull because all a club has to do is get the vcfl to look into it and that would look 10 times worse than being honest now, then having the truth coming out during or after finals when its all to late.
Click to expand...

Remember the stuff up last year you guys had with Mick Turner Buddah? He played the first few senior games without actually getting a clearance and this was due to a league stuff up/clerical error from the GDFL/Football Geelong and was not Corio's fault. My understanding is the same thing happened here as the new electronic system only goes back 1 year and Bannock were told a clearance was not needed. As a result paper work was submitted to register him. At the end of the day I understand Bannock acted in good faith and submitted the paperwork advised by the GDFL/Football Geelong. Would be hugely suprised if they were punished for a league mistake but who knows.
 
Re: GDFL 2009 Season

Would be interesting to see the actual registration/clearance form, as I understand, there is a section that must be filled out asking what clubs the player has played for previously, and when he last played for those clubs. If he had filled in that section and stated that he had played elsewhere in the last 24 months, then it is bannocks mistake as all clubs know that a clearance is required in that case. If he did not fill in that section, the player is at fault, either way whoever handles bannocks registrations/clearances is at fault, to say it was submitted and went through is not good enough.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: GDFL 2009 Season

pleaser said:
Would be interesting to see the actual registration/clearance form, as I understand, there is a section that must be filled out asking what clubs the player has played for previously, and when he last played for those clubs. If he had filled in that section and stated that he had played elsewhere in the last 24 months, then it is bannocks mistake as all clubs know that a clearance is required in that case. If he did not fill in that section, the player is at fault, either way whoever handles bannocks registrations/clearances is at fault, to say it was submitted and went through is not good enough.
Click to expand...

Correct indeed.

But if the player did not put that on the clearance, the fact that the VCFL only had one years worth of records online when two was required makes them partially culpable as well.
 
Re: GDFL 2009 Season

theknowledge said:
Correct indeed.

But if the player did not put that on the clearance, the fact that the VCFL only had one years worth of records online when two was required makes them partially culpable as well.
Click to expand...

Its still the clubs responsibility to ensure the paper work is filled out and submitted correctly, otherwise all clubs could submit paperwork with ommisions and if found out just say ops it was a mistake.
 
Re: GDFL 2009 Season

pleaser said:
Its still the clubs responsibility to ensure the paper work is filled out and submitted correctly, otherwise all clubs could submit paperwork with ommisions and if found out just say ops it was a mistake.
Click to expand...

Again pleaser don't disagree with what your saying but its all an online process now no paperwork gets transferred anywhere.
 
Re: GDFL 2009 Season

ExtendTheDukes said:
Remember the stuff up last year you guys had with Mick Turner Buddah? He played the first few senior games without actually getting a clearance and this was due to a league stuff up/clerical error from the GDFL/Football Geelong and was not Corio's fault. My understanding is the same thing happened here as the new electronic system only goes back 1 year and Bannock were told a clearance was not needed. As a result paper work was submitted to register him. At the end of the day I understand Bannock acted in good faith and submitted the paperwork advised by the GDFL/Football Geelong. Would be hugely suprised if they were punished for a league mistake but who knows.
Click to expand...

Thats correct but.
He was cleared correctly buy us his name is michael turner not mick so it was nth shores mistake from the previous years as they had him registered as mick turner nothing to do with us our paper work was all correct. We made sure of all this before he played a game for us, it just took alan moore a few weeks to put it in the system.
 
Re: GDFL 2009 Season

Its over VCFL have cleared the process undertaken. He has been considered a valid player all year
 
Re: GDFL 2009 Season

whoever said:
Does that mean everything will remain status quo and Bannock will keep all points, etc?
Click to expand...
Now that all this is cleared, does anyone want to have a crack at a team of the year and Grand Final teams with winner, i have tried earlier in the year but i am finding it hard without a lot of knowledge, although i have a few names i think should be in the team.

R.Closter (East)
C.Hyland (Thom)
J.Huybens (Inv)
D.Holzfeind (B.P.H)
S.Gallagher (Belm)
Z.Hickleton (Inv)
L.Mahoney (Belm)
S.Lewis (B.P.H)
A.Woods (Bann)
D.Perkins (Bann)
J.Mcloed (Thom)
A.Skrobalak (East)
L.Clifford (Corio)
B.O'Toole (Corio)
A.Burke (Werr)
S.Calbert (Werr)

By form i'd say East V Bell Post, I think Bell Post have the players that will step up in finals and may knock off East.
 
Skrobolak re-signed to coach East Geelong in 2010.

Good get for the eagles with plenty of clubs all over the state chasing his services.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Where are the smart guys that said Scroba was signed sealed and delivered to Bacchus March, do we still need to watch this space you clowns
 
Any B&F results or predictions?
B.KELLY winner at Winchelsea, J KRUGGER AND M KING runners up
Well done DANIEL (MADDOG) GRESKI winner of 2's B&F great result for a great bloke:thumbsu:
 
jetski said:
Any B&F results or predictions?
B.KELLY winner at Winchelsea, J KRUGGER AND M KING runners up
Well done DANIEL (MADDOG) GRESKI winner of 2's B&F great result for a great bloke:thumbsu:
Click to expand...
B+F nth geelong Braydee Watts 2nd Kayne Schwennsen 3rd Derek Fitzy well done wattsy first year of senior football :)
 
Bell Post Hill to def Thomson by 37 pts

Bannockburn to def Werribie by 80 pts elimination finals quite often end in a blow out
 
Randy Guy said:
Bannockburn to def Werribie by 80 pts elimination finals quite often end in a blow out
Click to expand...

i get that feeling too, but Werribee's intensity at times last week was fantastic. if they can put it together for 4 quarters they'll beat Banno.

something to keep in mind, Centrals best performance for the year IMO was when they destroyed North Geelong (who were 5-0) at North Geelong. Obviously this is where the game is this weekend.

result certainly not set in stone yet.

Thomson and Banno for me though.
 
david bain said:
he will not take the job. His brother is playing there at the moment but he is not keen on coaching yet. R the devils in the market 4 a new coach?
Click to expand...

We have spoke with ric and his keen to stay on as a player and he said aswell as us that it's time to get fresh ideas in, we must admit ric has been great about everything all he wants is for the club to be successfull and if it meens getting a new coach and maybe a couple of new players to top up our list that's what we will do. We have great depth obviously with our reserves and 3 or 4 under 18s ready to take the step next year.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

MortlockWatcher
  • Sticky
GFNL Discussion 2025
Replies
8
Views
4K
Magnets
M

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top