Crankyhawk
Hall of Famer
They did finish 12 so a soft draw was kind of expected
Geelong to go undefeated for the rest of 2024??
- Thread starter Havoc
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Nah, that would be you making Geelong posts 24/7 ever since that infamous Geelong/Carlton game. You are still screeching "we should've smashed them", hence your pathetic deathriding routine. All while pretending to block me and reading every single message.He's been melting for 4 weeks straight now
Dangerfield was on target for coaches votes the 3rd time of his 4 games before the Carlton hammy. That's not really a drop off. He dropped off between 2019 and 2021 and has been about the same since.
Holmes has picked up coaches votes in 7 of 9 games and looked good when moved to midfield last night (a move made too late).
Conway, Dangerfield, Holmes, Bruhn, Bowes and Parfitt will probably end up our best midfield mix in the latter half of the year. If Bruhn, Bowes and Parfitt find their round 1-7 form, that will make us competitive enough.
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,740
- 13,217
- AFL Club
- Carlton
The way supporters act doesn’t discount the fact that teams perform worse as a result of injuries
Or when their individuals perform worse. Or when the opposition are simply better.
"Oh but our injuries" is the single weakest excuse of the lot, after blaming the umpires.
Control the controllables. Or as supporters, focus on the controllables. Anything else and you are a dweeb that probably uses all manners of cop outs for your own deficiencies in life as well.
One good thing about Geelong losing......we get to catch up with a whole bunch of old friends on Bigfooty who we hadn't seen from Rounds 1-7.
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,740
- 13,217
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Ignoring legitimate reasons for your performance (injuries) makes no sense either. You start seeing problems with the side/list that you already have answers for. The problem is they are out injured.
I'm not saying personnel has zero impact. I'm saying using it as a shield and the number one focus (especially on the main board to neutral supporters) is boring, repetitive and a cop out.
There was so much in Geelong's hands the past 3 weeks that they failed to deliver on with players more than capable. Stewart, Cameron, C.Guthrie, Duncan, Stanley, Tuohy, Rohan, Kolo, Bowes, O'Connor, Parfitt and J.Henry don't get a free pass for their past month's decline simply because various combinations of players are missing each week. Bruhn came back and had 11 possessions and that had NOTHING to do with Dangerfield missing.
Our defence was only missing a kid in his 3rd year of AFL games and they collectively had near career-worst games. Imagine me trying to blame the absentee list for that. Nope, not happening. I told Carlton supporters to look at the lack of cop outs when Geelong lost. And we are seeing it.
- Oct 25, 2001
- 14,910
- 12,519
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- IOM Gyms, Preston Nth End
Obviously the OP is a backfire, but really all Geelong are guilty of is banking their victories early. Poor form and injury has hit but its the right time of year if its going to happen, you don't want this slump in August.
Plenty of quality and most of all a good coach should see them in the finals. It'll be a great gauge of Scott's (yes and his assistants but I think a lot of it is him) quality to see where they finish, if he gets them top 4 you'd have to say he's the best current coach (which is my opinion).
Plenty of quality and most of all a good coach should see them in the finals. It'll be a great gauge of Scott's (yes and his assistants but I think a lot of it is him) quality to see where they finish, if he gets them top 4 you'd have to say he's the best current coach (which is my opinion).
- Mar 25, 2019
- 14,391
- 29,456
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Correct. Apparently pointing that out is the equivalent of regicide to Meowman.
To most supporters it's not an excuse anyway, it's a reason. It doesn't detract from the fact that a team has lost or that they're playing bad footy, but it's still a reason to be optimistic towards to future once those players hopefully return.
"Not an excuse, it's a reason" - even a little too on the nose for a politician to get away with.
Reply directly anyway, you coward. You are still reading and responding to every single exchange I am having with other supporters anyway.
No need to shy away big fella.
And yes you have cried relentlessly about injuries, umpiring and "best team lost/should've smashed them" for 4 straight weeks now. I will continue to point this incessant whinging out and you will continue to get annoyed about it, or stop.
- Dec 20, 2023
- 5,861
- 4,834
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #662
I have to say are you just completely oblivious as to the reason why you guys finished 12th last year. Every other Cats supporter seems to know except for you.
- Jun 3, 2019
- 2,783
- 4,758
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- are jealous, Geelong is living #RentFree
The OP isn't a Geelong supporter. He was mocking us and trying to say reasons "x, y and z" were the only way Geelong hadn't lost a game early.
Majority of cats fans had/have us around the 6th-12th mark. Absolutely no one had us finishing 1st or undefeated (expect Damo Barrett) and that was a completely cooked take.
People need to stop speaking on behalf of Geelong supporters. We can manage just fine.
The soft draw also extends to having a six day break to the Suns five day break after the Suns played in Darwin last week. Then what do you know... after playing in Darwin the Cats get a nine day break before having to face the Giants at home who get the standard week.
I will also state it's not a conspiracy but just an inequality in the draw that shouldn't happen.
Sure Carlton would be a great side if AFL games only went 20 minutes…
Gone from a premiership favourite to outside the 8, yeah it’s a bit if a free fall at the moment. Even the umpires are jumping off the sinking ship!
mcgarnacle
Norm Smith Medallist
- Dec 2, 2003
- 9,787
- 4,213
- AFL Club
- Sydney
I was howled down by Kobe Gryant when I suggested let's wait until Geelong play the likes of Collingwood, Greater Western Sydney, Melbourne, Sydney, Carlton, etc. As I wrote when the streak was 6 games in, Geelong had beaten teams outside the 8, bar Bulldogs at the time who were 8th. Then they defeated Carlton. Well done. Western Bulldogs and Carlton are now outside the 8. You can only defeat who you're fixtured to play, so can't blame Geelong, but they're showing that they're probably a 7th to 11th placed team for mine. Present teams in the 8 need to have their go at playing the bottom clubs now, and they'll pass the Cats. They're lucky they get to play a few of the spuds teams from earlier in the season again, and should make the finals.
In saying that, Geelong match up well v Sydney
In saying that, Geelong match up well v Sydney
We've beaten two teams who were top 8 when we played them (Bulldogs, Blues) and lost to two were top 8 when we played them (Demons, Port). GWS, Sydney, Carlton and Essendon are all coming up fairly soon. So I'd still wait until then to draw any massive conclusions.I was howled down by Kobe Gryant when I suggested let's wait until Geelong play the likes of Collingwood, Greater Western Sydney, Melbourne, Sydney, Carlton, etc. As I wrote when the streak was 6 games in, Geelong had beaten teams outside the 8, bar Bulldogs at the time who were 8th. Then they defeated Carlton. Well done. Western Bulldogs and Carlton are now outside the 8. You can only defeat who you're fixtured to play, so can't blame Geelong, but they're showing that they're probably a 7th to 11th placed team for mine. Present teams in the 8 need to have their go at playing the bottom clubs now, and they'll pass the Cats. They're lucky they get to play a few of the spuds teams from earlier in the season again, and should make the finals.
In saying that, Geelong match up well v Sydney
We've hit a big rut and needed to snatch one of the close Melbourne/Port games. Now GWS next week becomes a huge test of our character and quality. They have no issues winning down in Geelong, so a win would probably be the scalp we need or else the doubters will rightly be able to double down. It's a long old season but the bleeding has to stop.
- May 6, 2007
- 42,922
- 26,327
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
The young midfield depth is a problem that would be stressing out the list management team. Knevitt hasn't come on like they maybe hoped, ditto Clark (although he is super young and at least playing seniors), the rest of the kids are largely untried
Miers is getting a decent run through stoppages lately. 4, 3, 5 and 3 clearances against the Lions/Demons/Port/Suns in 4 recent games where he was in midfield more. He's in the Bolton mould more than a contested bull. If we pull the trigger on Mannagh, I expect this gradual midfield integration could become more evident.
We can't be far off pulling the trigger on Holmes, like the second half against Gold Coast. He's been great as a half back this season but is about our only current player who could develop into a Rozee/Butters type midfielder.
The other who we are just starting to trial through there here and there is Mullin. He's raw but is already coming on leaps and bounds compared to his first few games.
If he can put on more size you could see Dempsey switch from wing to stoppages. But we're probably talking more like 2026.
And then of course Bruhn, who was tracking nicely this season (compared to 12 months ago) until his shocker on Friday. Hopefully his tank is building and as retirements roll in his 63% odd game time shifts closer to the standard 80% of first line midfielders.
As soon as Blicavs isn't playing then Knevitt will be an automatic replacement, he just hasn't been given many opportunities at AFL level yet.
Then you mentioned Clark, who is getting rag dolled and will probably take a couple of years to come on.
So Holmes, Miers, Dempsey, Bruhn, Mullin, Knevitt and Clark is looking like our young midfield/wing core going forward.
Undoubtedly we need to get a mature bodied mid in through free agency to help lead this group. It could be a stop gap player (Macrae, Parker) or a longer term solution.
Most Cats fans have been screaming our **** off for Knevitt (and a few other younger mids) to get another opportunity.
- May 6, 2007
- 42,922
- 26,327
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
why are they not getting opportunity ?
I think there's been a large amount of trust and faith for the old guys to turn around their form lapses/decline.
But a lot of Cats fans feel that trust/faith is running out...
