Banter Geelong V Richmond - GO!

[Wosh]

In the interests of keeping your back and forth shite fights out of match threads so normal people can talk.

Keep it clean and above the shorts
Off topic rubbish clogging up match threads will be moved here, knock yourselves out.

 

[Lunchtime]

I feel like there were solid reasons they were a $1.50ish favourite to our $2.60ish

Forget what the actual odds ended up at before the bounce

No because the odds meant nothing in the scheme of things. They crumbled. They turned to water. They aren't a tough team.

 

[Footy Smarts]

Best thing that can happen now for Geelong haters is for Hawkins to come back. Their structure was awful with him playing and not contributing and he dragged down Cameron. As soon as Hawkins got injured Geelongs revival started. But now he's back and ready to play will Chris Scott have the grapefruits to do whats best for the team and leave him out

Amazing how quickly the narrative changes from "they'll never be able to replace Hawkins" to "they'll never have the courage to leave out Hawkins".

 

[CatToTheFuture]

No because the odds meant nothing in the scheme of things. They crumbled. They turned to water. They aren't a tough team.

Yeah, but we were not expected to win that. I feel like it's a bit of Monday morning quarterbacking to say we were always going to win.

 

[Lunchtime]

Yeah, but we were not expected to win that. I feel like it's a bit of Monday morning quarterbacking to say we were always going to win.

Well those with any commonsense know that Port turn to water.

 

[BigPond101]

You know why the China experiment failed? We didn't give them any Geelong - let that be a lesson learned. Geelong at 35% maximum power would dominate the Chinese market.

The Chinese word for Geelong is 实力雄厚的地产 ( Shílì xiónghòu dì dìchǎn ) which also means real estate power

 

[Strange Cat]

Geelong have the most significant advantage in the the comp.

Get to play 7 or 8 games at their boutique ground against non-Vic and lower drawing local clubs. Get to play their 'bigger' home games at the MCG in front of large crowds - great training ground for finals.

They literally have the perfect mix. The kind of fixturing other clubs could only dream of.

Have been gifted money hand-over-fist, while community sports clubs struggle and die after begging for funding to improve infrastructure. I play at a club in a major regional town who still gave clubrooms with SHARED SHOWERS (which are falling apart and dangerous). Lovely getting nude with the opposition after a hard fought and tense clash.

No doubt Geelong have done plenty right, but they have been set up to a point where it is near impossible to fail.

How many home games did we win again this year? Hardly the advantage you’re making it out to be and take away the home wins most years and we still make the finals

Imagine sooking about a team getting home games which is less than any other side that gets 11 home games while the cats get 9

Lots of sour grapes

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Well those with any commonsense know that Port turn to water.

Well they would have made a lot of money on their sports betting account then

 

[Foxx]

That you have NFI how “easy” it is to sustain a successful period

Whatever it takes right?

Yeah I do. Operate a club in a small city bubble where almost the entire population are your clubs supporters.

 

[Strange Cat]

Yeah I do. Operate a club in a small city bubble where almost the entire population are your clubs supporters.

So why aren’t Power/Adel a powerhouse ? Or eagles and Freo?

Like I said NFI

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Yeah I do. Operate a club in a small city bubble where almost the entire population are your clubs supporters.

So you anticipate Tasmania will be the most dominant team of the afl on an ongoing basis from 2030?

 

[Foxx]

So why aren’t Power/Adel a powerhouse ? Or eagles and Freo?

Like I said NFI

Duh. Because they are massive areas with broad supporter bases. Ain't no cultural bubble there like Geelong have.

 

[Strange Cat]

Duh. Because they are massive areas with broad supporter bases.

lol ok champ if you say so

Delusional

 

[Foxx]

So you anticipate Tasmania will be the most dominant team of the afl on an ongoing basis from 2030?

Depends if almost all their population support the club like Geelongs do.

 

[Strange Cat]

Depends if almost all their population support the club like Geelongs do.

20 years of not winning a final must make you look for any stupid reasons to why a club is successful

 

[Foxx]

20 years of not winning a final must make you look for any stupid reasons to why a club is successful

You should be happy and embrace your advantage.

 

[boncer34]

So why aren’t Power/Adel a powerhouse ? Or eagles and Freo?

Like I said NFI

Did you just point to cities with almost 5 times and 8 times the population of Geelong and claim they are also small cities?

 

[Strange Cat]

You should be happy and embrace your advantage.

Yes our 9 home games per year is such an unfair advantage …do you realise how stupid that sounds ?

 

[Strange Cat]

Did you just point to cities with almost 5 times the population of Geelong and claim they are also small cities?

How the **** can a population influence a club win/loss record

Really?

 

[Demonic Ascent]

On SEN last night they said Cats have made 13 Prelims in 18 years

Extend that back to 2004 and it's 14 Prelims in 21 years. That is an astounding level of consistency

 

[boncer34]

How the **** can a population influence a club win/loss record

Really?

Please just answer my question.

 

[Strange Cat]

Please just answer my question.

Well Tassie should be the next powerhouse going by that absurd logic

 

[Foxx]

Yes our 9 home games per year is such an unfair advantage …do you realise how stupid that sounds ?

Who said anything about homes games? You did. And then mentioned how stupid it sounds.

 

[boncer34]

Well Tassie should be the next powerhouse going by that absurd logic

Still haven't answered my question.

 

[caloschwaby]

Geelong is in a marginal electorate

Not that its important to this discussion, but for the electorate of Geelong Labor have a 30%+ hold on TPP I feel that's the opposite of marginal haha

 

[Strange Cat]

Still haven't answered my question.

Whatever makes you happy