Rumour GFC 2024 Player Trading, Drafting FA, Rumours and Wish lists Pt 3

[Munich]

Woohoo no Oliver.

Thank the lord.

 

[Munich]

Basically now in someone else's court ..

Who's Fed playing there?

 

[Catman]

Would love to see Oliver come out and request a trade after this, just to see Melbourne squirm.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

This was in the article about the Dogs driving a hard bargain for Smith. They're also claiming to drive a hard bargain for McRae.

To be honest pick 46 for Macrae seems pretty reasonable to me

 

[you pick one]

I'm not watching that.

What's the gist?
is that

Sorry Clayton we can't get it done this year stay calm start looking for a farm on the surf coast we will make it happen next year maybe play a bit dead next season too that will help in us paying unders to Melbourne wink wink nudge nudge O/K.

 

[Footy Smarts]

Would love to see Oliver come out and request a trade after this, just to see Melbourne squirm.

Genuine chance of happening. Wait for the stories leaked to the media about his mental health and the impact getting shopped around but not being allowed to leave has had on him.

You see that and we know it's still on. Melbourne will be under huge pressure not to keep $1.2m for 6 years locked up in a guy with major off-field issues, who's overweight and doesn't want to be there.

 

[calder_daddy]

Did we trade SDK for some magic beans?

why?

The one player who could fix our midfield woes even at 70%

 

[Schmegg]

Too much skin moisturiser?

He shone out in that little interview

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Ah I see.

I still don't think it's over yet. Clayton would be well within rights to push this further.

I think we would ask him not to. It has to be Melbourne driving it or i don't think it works

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Id like a quiz …. whats the outcome for BSmith ….


1… R1 pick

2...R1 pick ..plus pick or player

3… No deal done by close of trade period...

2 and it's a rd 2 pick

 

[BlakeyNoFlakey]

Personally, I think the Oliver thing is dead. He won't be leaving Melb.

As for Smith, I'm tipping we'll give them our first this year and a F2nd for next year

 

[CatToTheFuture]

I told ya Oliver needed to get blotto and do a nudie run at the Dees BNF.

Even that o don't think would do. He would need to break off windscreen wipers and glare at people wide eyed and make exaggerated chewing actions

 

[CatToTheFuture]

The one player who could fix our midfield woes even at 70%

Sometimes it's just not meant to be

 

[Catman]

Genuine chance of happening. Wait for the stories leaked to the media about his mental health and the impact getting shopped around but not being allowed to leave has had on him.

You see that and we know it's still on. Melbourne will be under huge pressure not to keep $1.2m for 6 years locked up in a guy with major off-field issues, who's overweight and doesn't want to be there.

Surely if it's as definitive as Melbourne claim, then surely an announcement from him or his management stating he's staying puts it all to bed quite quickly?

We won't be pushing anything, the ball is squarely in the Oliver camp's court.

 

[year of the cat]

Id like a quiz …. whats the outcome for BSmith ….


1… R1 pick

2...R1 pick ..plus pick or player

3… No deal done by close of trade period...

2. 17 plus change

 

[cats_09]

This was in the article about the Dogs driving a hard bargain for Smith. They're also claiming to drive a hard bargain for McRae.

Prior to Macrae nominating St Kilda as his preferred destination and when there was some chat amongst Geelong fans if we should chase him, I had a Geelong supporter telling me he was worth a first round pick - I tried explaining that no team is trading a first round pick for a 30yr who's been shifted the midfield and found himself in the VFL over the past two years

Bulldogs may want more, but he's not worth more than a 3rd round pick

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Surely if it's as definitive as Melbourne claim, then surely an announcement from him or his management stating he's staying puts it all to bed quite quickly?

We won't be pushing anything, the ball is squarely in the Oliver camp's court.

Don't expect he would do that. He just got handed a big leg up in the power dynamics of his relationship with MFC. He gains nothing making that statement even if he stays

 

[Hamingja]

Who's Fed playing there?

I would say it is supposed to be Tiafoe

 

[Cataholic]

Mackie said Melbourne's stance is 'all as he knows' but didn't Jumping Jack say Clayton reaffirmed his desire to move to the GFC to the club itself over the weekend?

 

[Hamingja]

Id like a quiz …. whats the outcome for BSmith ….


1… R1 pick

2...R1 pick ..plus pick or player

3… No deal done by close of trade period...

2 for sure

What about when we expect the trade to be announced

I will run with Wednesday 16th October 7.27pm.

Going to be along week and a bit.

 

[Gavin Excell]

 

[Catman]

Don't exist he would do that. He just got handed a big leg up in the power dynamics of his relationship with MFC. He gains nothing making that statement even if he stays

Good point. What are the odds we revisit this in 12 months time?

 

[Munich]

Yet nobody seems to want him and higher-ups at Footscary are glad to be rid of him.

Ummkay.

 

[cats_09]

Id like a quiz …. whats the outcome for BSmith ….


1… R1 pick

2...R1 pick ..plus pick or player

3… No deal done by close of trade period...

Option 2

2024 first round, with swap of later picks - just not sure if those will be 2024 or 2025 picks

 

[Jumping Jack]

Mackie said Melbourne's stance is 'all as he knows' but didn't Jumping Jack say Clayton reaffirmed his desire to move to the GFC to the club itself over the weekend?

Yeah that's what I was reliably told over the weekend.

I wouldn't read too much into what Mackie said - it was just a nice gently volley back across the net. Oliver chose to meet with the Cats -- he's the person in this whole situation that has a right to feel aggrieved -- MFC said they don't intend to trade Oliver. All that is just posturing in my opinion and the club telling their irate member base what they want to hear. This is not about what the club wants - if Oliver wants to leave then he'll leave no stone unturned (via his management) to make that happen. Does that mean he gets to Geelong - NO. But it doesn't mean we should believe everything coming from MFC either.

You can't tell me that Oliver still doesn't have a desire to leave - clearly he does. And until he comes out publicly and says categorically that he is staying - then I'll stick to my gut feel. And that is that there is still some stuff to play out.

All Mackie was doing was being polite and respecting that Oliver is still contracted. Doesn't mean squat (as we know).