Rumour GFC 2024 Player Trading, Drafting FA, Rumours and Wish lists Pt 3

[Cataholic]

You are asking too early.

You need to wait for more rumours.
And then they will say either


a) I haven't heard much, but thats not my mail at all. He still wants out but the deal may be too difficult (der)
b) we are still into him no matter what anyone says
c) there were some land purchases on the weekend. I wonder who that was? Hint, hint.


In effect, committing to zero but keeping up the charade that they know stuff.

They seem to have had fairly good info so far?

That will sound odd given I can't verify what they've been saying, but they all seem to be hearing the same thing more or less, and whilst it's going to sound even sillier, what they've had to say so far has had a 'ring of truth' to it imo.

 

[Strange Cat]

I never insult you.
You cant just do something like that. The AFL would be all over it.

If he's worth that much of a risk to the club. Just give the dogs 2 first rounders. Give Smith 600k. And move on.

You can and it has been done before

 

[Strange Cat]

Cap is going up. Dollars won't be the issue. The "doesn't want to play for them" is the issue

I don’t know a lot of the existing contracts are pretty locked in at this time of the year …I can’t see too many clubs with that kind of cap space being able to make a quick move like that it’s hurts them in the long run.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

A gold digger is my bet.

Oil actually

 

[cats_09]

I never insult you.
You cant just do something like that. The AFL would be all over it.

If he's worth that much of a risk to the club. Just give the dogs 2 first rounders. Give Smith 600k. And move on.

Secret Bulldogs supporter?

What exactly makes Smith worth 2 x first round picks?

• his 2023 season wasn't that good
• he hasn't played for 12 months due to an ACL
• highest finish in the B&F is 7th, last achieved in 2021 and no top 10 finish since then

1 x first round pick seems pretty on the money

 

[Tony Barber]

You can and it has been done before

It was done before with buddy. Agree. But the AFL switched everything after that.

i.e. we cant give petracca a 50 year contract with 4 mil in the first year.

 

[Tony Barber]

Secret Bulldogs supporter?

What exactly makes Smith worth 2 x first round picks?

• his 2023 wasn't that good
• he hasn't played for 12 months due to an ACL
• highest finish in the B&F is 7th, last achieved in 2021 and no top 10 finish since then

1 x first round pick seems pretty on the money

No I made that up. I honestly dont know what smith is worth.
But if people start talking about shady deals then it becomes stupid.

Hence I said 2 round 1 picks and we move on and dont be shady. Thats all.

 

[Stan The Caddy]

Oil actually

Liquid gold then? At least that's what one wise man calls it.

 

[Hamingja]

But you can refuse to be interviewed. Which would probably deter another club picking him up.

Or do a medical which isn't ideal for someone coming off an ACL when you are matching 4 million over 5 years or whatever Smith's asking price would be. You'd be trusting Geelong blindly if you picked him, which for that sort of investment would be crazy.

Anyway he won't go to the draft. It will get done for pick 17 and a pick swap, Geelong's 2nd or future 2nd for Bulldogs 3rd or future 3rd. Something like that.

 

[Tony Barber]

Secret Bulldogs supporter?

What exactly makes Smith worth 2 x first round picks?

• his 2023 wasn't that good
• he hasn't played for 12 months due to an ACL
• highest finish in the B&F is 7th, last achieved in 2021 and no top 10 finish since then

1 x first round pick seems pretty on the money

And secret dogs supporter. lol
All I can tell you about the dogs is that Goggin was grateful to be given the job there. He was completely pissed off with Geelong.
So much that his offspring actually hate Geelong. So there you go.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

I don’t know a lot of the existing contracts are pretty locked in at this time of the year …I can’t see too many clubs with that kind of cap space being able to make a quick move like that it’s hurts them in the long run.

There's enough clubs where the cap is opening faster than they have indexed contracts and/or players to spend it on. When the offer first hit the media it was reported as a contract any club could afford. I'd be very surprised if there wasn't 5 or so clubs that could easily afford the contract. I'd be even more surprised if any draft him

 

[Strange Cat]

It was done before with buddy. Agree. But the AFL switched everything after that.

i.e. we cant give petracca a 50 year contract with 4 mil in the first year.

The AFL was all over that because of the COLA abuse not the actual contract in itself

It can be done

 

[Biscut]

Every single Dogs fan I know would rather see him go to the draft than get unders for him. We may lose this time but not long term. We don’t want to be pushed around by wealthy clubs anymore. He hasn’t even got to free agency and we feel we are being screwed by the AFL and the wealthy clubs who are also throughout the media. He is a young gun with 10 years left in the game. But he is an extremely immature narcissist easily lead by money and fame, not necessarily football history.

God I hope you’re right. That way we’ll get him for our second rounder and Oliver or a top 20 draft prospect. Delicious!

 

[D BRIDGE]

But you can refuse to be interviewed. Which would probably deter another club picking him up.

And you can always "do your knee again" the day of the draft.

Sheesh we might snag him for #38.

 

[Kitcat]

But you can refuse to be interviewed. Which would probably deter another club picking him up.

Exactly. How many large companies would employ someone on reputation without interviewing them? Particularly if they haven't performed very well in their last year or two at their former employer, haven't worked for a year, want high money for quite a few years, have had publicised 'issues' and have said they want to work for another company?

Actually, probably our banks, supermarkets, political parties, national airline and unions.

 

[Boxhead_31]

Secret Bulldogs supporter?

What exactly makes Smith worth 2 x first round picks?

• his 2023 wasn't that good
• he hasn't played for 12 months due to an ACL
• highest finish in the B&F is 7th, last achieved in 2021 and no top 10 finish since then

1 x first round pick seems pretty on the money

But he is a 4 time all 22 under 22 member

 

[Boxhead_31]

Dee’s doing this knowing they have a F1 coming back in return for Oliver perhaps?

 

[Kobe Gryant]

Dee’s doing this knowing they have a F1 coming back in return for Oliver perhaps?

Logic says yes.

Unfortunately, the Dees don't seem to use logic.

 

[D BRIDGE]

Dee’s doing this knowing they have a F1 coming back in return for Oliver perhaps?

Dees have forward traded in a current F1 a few times... It's a strat they use more than every other team.

 

[Lana]

View attachment 2140035

That isn't the real trade whisperer, check the twitter handle

 

[CatToTheFuture]

That isn't the real trade whisperer, check the twitter handle

I'll have to check if I'm recalling this correctly but I think he got hacked and lost his original account

 

[Lana]

I'll have to check if I'm recalling this correctly but I think he got hacked and lost his original account

That's what this imposter wants you to think, the real trade whisperer went underground until the heat died down, some were getting too close for comfort in identifying his real identity.

 

[Sticksman]

But you can refuse to be interviewed. Which would probably deter another club picking him up.

The player can also refuse a medical.

 

[Hamingja]

Dees have forward traded in a current F1 a few times... It's a strat they use more than every other team.

Why do the Bombers do that deal? Melbourne might be a cultural cesspit but I mean it will be pretty hard for them to finish lower next year, I can't see Richmond, WC or North finishing ahead of them, so best case they trade 9 this year for 4 next year but Bombers holding all the risk on Melbourne potentially bouncing and playing finals and ending up with a terrible pick.

If you are a shit team like the Bombers you kind of want to improve NOW, not push your pick into next year.

 

[Tony Barber]

So it's
We receive Oliver and pick 9.
Give pick 40 and we take his salary 100%

I think we might be paying overs?
Am I doing this right?