GIANTS Dream Team/Supercoach questions thread

[Scully2Folau]

Article on Power's hamstring injury on the AFL website:

GREATER Western Sydney co-captain Luke Power will miss the rest of the NAB Cup and is in doubt for round one of the AFL season after injuring his hamstring at training.

"He won't play the rest of the NAB Cup, but we are hopeful he will be right to play against the Swans in round one."

Dylan Shiel and Adam Treloar are both around a fortnight away from returning to the side.

 

[54Dogs]

Cheers S2F, appreciated

 

[TheDonBomb]

Hi guys, how many on here will be putting Shiel and/or Treloar into their dreamteam/supercoach line up?

It's a tough one...

 

[bigrayohall20]

Will Giles be playing the majority of games in the ruck? Does he have the engine or will he be rested during the year.

Im considering playing him as a 2nd ruck if he can average 75+.

 

[Mountain Giant]

Will Giles be playing the majority of games in the ruck? Does he have the engine or will he be rested during the year.

Im considering playing him as a 2nd ruck if he can average 75+.

He will be the ruckman when Brogan is not. Don't know if he will be in the 22 when Brogan is though. He probably won't play enough as the only ruckman unless Brogan gets injured.

 

[Impromptu]

Article on Power's hamstring injury on the AFL website:

Cheers Scully2Folau

Was quietly monitoring Power but my decision has been made for me.

Went to the pub on the weekend to watch GWS v Hawks and must say very impressed with J.Cameron even though fantasy points didn't show it.

 

[bigrayohall20]

I splurged a bit and got Coniglio in instead of either of these two. I think if they have missed so much football already they will struggle to make the team this season with all the competition there is.



He will be the ruckman when Brogan is not. Don't know if he will be in the 22 when Brogan is though. He probably won't play enough as the only ruckman unless Brogan gets injured.

Cheers. Think i might stick with him as 3rd or 4th ruck.

 

[Skystyler]

is Townsend in the mix for round 1, do you think? How did he look on the weekend?

 

[HereIam86]

Darley what is going on with him.

 

[Griff19]

Can anyone give some info on Curtley Hampton.... How has he been traveling???

 

[soreplums]

Can someone rank these guys in order from better option to worse option. All from GWS:

Shiel
Smith
Kennedy

At the moment I have all three- leaning towards playing one of Smith and Kennedy in the mid and the other in the foward line purely because of DPP. Would there be much of a difference in job security and price between the three?

 

[dlanod]

I'd say:

Smith
Kennedy
Shiel

Shiel's been out so is a huge concern there for me. Smith has looked pretty good.

 

[Mountain Giant]

This article pretty much sums up my thoughts on the team:

http://www.smh.com.au/afl/greater-western-sydney-giants/fantastic-picks-gws-20120316-1v91b.html

I would say Coniglio, Smith and Hampton are pushing to be automatic inclusions. I can't see why these guys and Coniglio in particular would miss any games.

I tend to think the non-senior players (apart from Patton) that missed the pre-season probably won't have a major impact on this year depending on their NEAFL form.

 

[ZAAHAARAKIS!!!!!]

will hoskins-elliott??
anyone got the lowdown on him?

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Darley and Kennedy thanks

 

[Scully2Folau]

will hoskins-elliott??
anyone got the lowdown on him?

Had a great game yesterday by the sounds of it, should be in the side next week pending scans on his hand.

 

[Yoda_]

Re: 2012 Supercoach

Hi guys, just wanted to know your thoughts on Sam Darley, Tim Mohr, Adam Kennedy & Devon Smith for supercoach this year?

Thanks guys

 

[LandOfTheGiants]

Re: 2012 Supercoach

Hi guys, just wanted to know your thoughts on Sam Darley, Tim Mohr, Adam Kennedy & Devon Smith for supercoach this year?

Thanks guys

I'd be leaning toward Kennedy out of the 4. I rate this kid.

 

[CRAWF 08]

Re: 2012 Supercoach

hi , i know i'm entering a world of a bit of an unknown here but hopefully some of you ppl can shed some light on the situation for me ... hopefully

Mohr , Bugg , Treloar ... any thoughts in regards to starting 22 / scoring pot / job security would be much appreciated ..

thanks in advance

 

[LandOfTheGiants]

Re: 2012 Supercoach

hi , i know i'm entering a world of a bit of an unknown here but hopefully some of you ppl can shed some light on the situation for me ... hopefully

Mohr , Bugg , Treloar ... any thoughts in regards to starting 22 / scoring pot / job security would be much appreciated ..

thanks in advance

Mohr will play a bit of football and will probably be better suited to SC.

Bugg is a quality kid and should play regularly and average between 60-70.

Treloar will probably miss the first couple of rounds with a hamstring i think, but when he plays get him in.

 

[ZAAHAARAKIS!!!!!]

Had a great game yesterday by the sounds of it, should be in the side next week pending scans on his hand.

thanks mate. im locking him in the midfield instead of coniglio, bit of a unique option and hes slightly better value

 

[Jade]

G'day Sheedy boys and girls.


I'm putting together an SC league, and I'm hoping to get one rep from each team - just for fun, but it should be a pretty competitive league. Any of you interested?

 

[EyeloveRichmond]

Hi all Giant supporters. Re: Supercoach, i'm really tossing up between Darley & Bugg in my backline. Anyone in the know who have watched either of them a bit, know who would be a better selection? Who is likely to get more games and score higher? Thanks very much. Good luck for the season.

 

[timmeh]

thoughts on josh bruce?

 

[bigrayohall20]

Is Adam Tomlinson looking like he will play most games????