I played against this last year - will see if I can dig something up.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Got a Random Question? Ask it Here. (Part 2)
- Thread starter SAINTS 4 07 FLAG
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I played against this last year - will see if I can dig something up.
O alright thanks... guess the little soccer kicks are quite subjective to whoever is in charge in recording the stats then.
Champion data, yes very much so. It's the same with tackles.
Stubz
Club Legend
When a ruckmen grabs the ball out of the ruck does this count as a hit-out to them.
(I think the answer is no, but I'm not 100%)
(I think the answer is no, but I'm not 100%)
- May 22, 2006
- 2,688
- 3,000
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I wouldn't have thought so, but his disposal by hand or foot would of course count. Otherwise it's usually a free kick against.
My question is: Is Robbie Warnock likely to return to the Blues line-up this year?
Jacobs has looked alright. I am thinking about cashing in the $80K based on his current price. There are a few $94,500 rucks sitting on 2 games, but the extra $17,000 is tempting by going to a $77K noob.
Dunn - Well Done
Cancelled
- Banned
- #809
Jacobs and Kruezer look pretty settled.
The ruck tap is interesitng. Because i have seen Sandi try and grab the ball from the ruck but spill it, does this count as a point??
The ruck tap is interesitng. Because i have seen Sandi try and grab the ball from the ruck but spill it, does this count as a point??
is your 4th ruckman currently playing?
i would advice against just picking a random if he isnt....
if you dint mind spending 95,800 get skipper should play all year barring injury
Quick question.
I want to downgrade Nason to a 77k noob backman. Got cover in the backs from hunt so just want the cash and I can't see Nason improving his price too much from here.
Don't care who, but would prefer one who may in the future play some games.
Who out of:
Dare, Carter, Strijk, Tuohy, Crameri, Johnston, Hooper, Mccaigue and Weston could possibly play this year?
Cheers in advance.
I want to downgrade Nason to a 77k noob backman. Got cover in the backs from hunt so just want the cash and I can't see Nason improving his price too much from here.
Don't care who, but would prefer one who may in the future play some games.
Who out of:
Dare, Carter, Strijk, Tuohy, Crameri, Johnston, Hooper, Mccaigue and Weston could possibly play this year?
Cheers in advance.
Dunn - Well Done
Cancelled
- Banned
- #812
Answer in bold
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Strijk. I would have thought the rest are no chance.
Weston is MPP though so he could be useful depending on what you have in your forwards.
Anyone know who Patrick is? He is taking DT on SEN.
Top 100 atm.
Says he knows TD. Be interested to know if he is anyone from this board.
EDIT: His team name is JabJabUppercutJab IIRC.
Top 100 atm.
Says he knows TD. Be interested to know if he is anyone from this board.
EDIT: His team name is JabJabUppercutJab IIRC.
Knows_footy
Debutant
Not sure if there is already a thread for this.....
Who does everyone think are the Top 7 Backs? that is top averaging backs that will obviously play more than 15 odd games.
My opinion changes every week with Lake thrown in this week as a potential top averaging back by the end of the year. Hodge Goddard are absolute locks but who make up the other 5 positions?
Who does everyone think are the Top 7 Backs? that is top averaging backs that will obviously play more than 15 odd games.
My opinion changes every week with Lake thrown in this week as a potential top averaging back by the end of the year. Hodge Goddard are absolute locks but who make up the other 5 positions?
Dont know who he is but the only two top 100 teams i can see with the name patrick are is the guy coming 6th with the team name South Framantle. There is also a guy sitting in 36th who only goes by the name of Pat with the team name JabJabUppercutJab lol. Dont know if either of the teams names ring a bell for anyone tho
I suppose its a matter of opinion atm who the best 7 back are as its yet to be proven.
But mine would be
Hodge, Goddard, Gilbert, Carazzo, Enright, Gilbee, H Shaw
Its the last 2 that you could throw a whole bunch of names through, Lake, Malceski, Scotland to name a few.. Lake has the ability to post big scores but can also have duds where as the others are probably more consistent...
Just my opinion though.
But mine would be
Hodge, Goddard, Gilbert, Carazzo, Enright, Gilbee, H Shaw
Its the last 2 that you could throw a whole bunch of names through, Lake, Malceski, Scotland to name a few.. Lake has the ability to post big scores but can also have duds where as the others are probably more consistent...
Just my opinion though.
Pumbi
Club Legend
Having Shaw in your 7, but not Scotland, is hurting my brain.
I'm glad you chucked on 'Just my Opinion'!
OK...not trading him this week because I have cows to harvest, but...
Gram - what to do?
His BE is over 170 and he has just had surgery, so will probably not return in sensational form even when he does return (official line is "over a month"). Will he get back to gun level this season? If it's unlikely, I reckon I'll trade him next week to avoid the inevitable price drop.
My only problem with doing it is I HATE trading sideways if there is a chance my gun could come back inside of 6 weeks and come back into form for the DT finals (especially when I have cover enough with Hunt and Webberley on my bench).
Does anyone know the type of injury it is and/or what state he is expected to return in (ie. gradual return to form or straight back on the gun-train)?
Gram - what to do?
His BE is over 170 and he has just had surgery, so will probably not return in sensational form even when he does return (official line is "over a month"). Will he get back to gun level this season? If it's unlikely, I reckon I'll trade him next week to avoid the inevitable price drop.
My only problem with doing it is I HATE trading sideways if there is a chance my gun could come back inside of 6 weeks and come back into form for the DT finals (especially when I have cover enough with Hunt and Webberley on my bench).
Does anyone know the type of injury it is and/or what state he is expected to return in (ie. gradual return to form or straight back on the gun-train)?
Knows_footy
Debutant
I have Hodge Goddard Carrazzo Enright already and I'm upgrading Keneally this week. I'm leaning towards picking up James Kelly ahead of Gilbert firstly because i have an obsession with Cats in my dreamteam (6 and counting), even when they struggle they will limp to 80 (downhill skiers if you like). I think a lot of people overlook JK because he was a midfielder (in DT) last year and therefore didn't pay attention to his scores much. He only averaged 85 last year which for a midfielder is pretty average however throw him in the backline and he's probably top 10 material. However this year i think he has grown a lot as a player and Geelong look as dominant a force as they were in their best years (08?). He has developed a tackling game averaging 6 tackles a game this year. He only needs to add probably 15-20 possessions (75 points) to get to 100 this year. In a team like Geelong he will amass stats with ease and while other players like Gilbert, Gilbee, Shaw, Scotland even perhaps Lake gradually gain more attention from opponents, Kelly will keep plotting along notching up solid 90/100's week in week out.
josh_eagles
Team Captain
I think the answer to this question is "no its only a FA" but i'll ask it anyway:
If a player tackles a player and his arm slides onto his neck (say), and its a high tackle, is it 4+(-3) = 1point? Or is it just -3?... I think its just -3 but it should be changed.
If a player tackles a player and his arm slides onto his neck (say), and its a high tackle, is it 4+(-3) = 1point? Or is it just -3?... I think its just -3 but it should be changed.
Knows_footy
Debutant
Spot on
- Banned
- #824
-3
A tackle only counts if it's effective. If the player is brought to ground but the ball doesn't result in a turnover/stoppage, the tackle won't count. The free kick means they're still in possession.
fletchisgun
Debutant
- Apr 12, 2010
- 96
- 170
- AFL Club
- Essendon
massive foward dilemma
got 15 trades left so i thought i may as well use 2 this week. my backline and midfield are solid but my foward line is unstable.
GIANSIRACUSA
O'KEEFE
JONO BROWN
ZIEBELL
MEDHURST
ROBBIE GRAY
GUMBLETON
PODSIADLY
ROCKLIFF
I thought ill first trade either rockliff, gumbleton,gray,medhurst or ziebell for henry playfair from the swans.(looking good)
ill then upgrade Brown to pavlich.
help me i dont know which one to get rid off
got 15 trades left so i thought i may as well use 2 this week. my backline and midfield are solid but my foward line is unstable.
GIANSIRACUSA
O'KEEFE
JONO BROWN
ZIEBELL
MEDHURST
ROBBIE GRAY
GUMBLETON
PODSIADLY
ROCKLIFF
I thought ill first trade either rockliff, gumbleton,gray,medhurst or ziebell for henry playfair from the swans.(looking good)
ill then upgrade Brown to pavlich.
help me i dont know which one to get rid off
- Status
Similar threads
- Sticky
