Goulburn Valley FL 2024

Remove this Banner Ad

The Roar Is Back said:
What I quoted is fact and yes I think the GVL has slipped in nearly every facet since becoming administered by afl vic / aflgm . Maybe this is clouded due to my respect for many people who were previously involved ?

I’d like to see the alledged comment re Tonny being in the top 2 .
Click to expand...
If only they done what the picola league done maybe just maybe they’d be as good as the pdfl
 

Log in to remove this ad.

far canal club said:
If only they done what the picola league done maybe just maybe they’d be as good as the pdfl
Click to expand...
Nice attempt to spin the topic around . 😂

Maybe if they did what O&M did ( self administration) they’d still have the previously paid asset ( Dunkirk ), plentiful cash reserves and have continual growing interest .

All bait has been swallowed , next topic …………….
 
Last edited:
Bad luck yesterday Tongue man. Now the dust has relatively settled, what’s the wash up from your tigers? How will they stack up next year?

Been a terrific year from your boys mate and I have thoroughly enjoyed the back and forth banter. Kudos on a great year.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Yepyep said:
Umpire was not 20 mtrs away. He was 3 mtrs away. Footage confirms this as well. He’s gone. High contact, intentional and maybe medium contact at best. 1-2 weeks.
Click to expand...

Semantics…..
Umpire came over after the scuffle started.
He was a some distance away in the preceding act of play that resulted in Smith getting the free kick that was reversed.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
innercircle said:
Semantics…..
Umpire came over after the scuffle started.
He was a some distance away in the preceding act of play that resulted in Smith getting the free kick that was reversed.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Can anyone point out what minute mark it was?

Remember it was early days, and would like to have another look without watching from the start.
 
innercircle said:
Semantics…..
Umpire came over after the scuffle started.
He was a some distance away in the preceding act of play that resulted in Smith getting the free kick that was reversed.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Clutching at straws. It wasn’t a scuffle it was a direct punch to the head while both players were on the ground. Smith was leaning over the top of him and drove a right fist into his head. Umpire was about 3-5 metres away and paid the free kick and reported him straight away. Umpire even mimicked the action Smith did when he blew the whistle. If he gets off this then it will truly demonstrate the influence the Shepparton football league has over the rest of the competition. High contact, intentional and medium force. 1-2 weeks with an early plea. Saw this from my seat about 15 mtrs in front of me with an absolute clear view of it. The fact the vision isn’t totally clear makes it worse for smith as he had nothing to defend as you can see the action on the footage of him throwing the punch but can’t see it land. The umpire will say it landed as he was so close he could see it, as i could in the grandstand. Ask Jack McHale from Echuca what it’s like to miss a GF…he took it on the chin and owned it. This is much the same although not as much force as Jacks. Clearly intentional though. Guess we will watch with interest.
 
Yepyep said:
Clutching at straws. It wasn’t a scuffle it was a direct punch to the head while both players were on the ground. Smith was leaning over the top of him and drove a right fist into his head. Umpire was about 3-5 metres away and paid the free kick and reported him straight away. Umpire even mimicked the action Smith did when he blew the whistle. If he gets off this then it will truly demonstrate the influence the Shepparton football league has over the rest of the competition. High contact, intentional and medium force. 1-2 weeks with an early plea. Saw this from my seat about 15 mtrs in front of me with an absolute clear view of it. The fact the vision isn’t totally clear makes it worse for smith as he had nothing to defend as you can see the action on the footage of him throwing the punch but can’t see it land. The umpire will say it landed as he was so close he could see it, as i could in the grandstand. Ask Jack McHale from Echuca what it’s like to miss a GF…he took it on the chin and owned it. This is much the same although not as much force as Jacks. Clearly intentional though. Guess we will watch with interest.
Click to expand...
my belief is he will be offered or has been offered 2
 
thermos said:
Bad luck yesterday Tongue man. Now the dust has relatively settled, what’s the wash up from your tigers? How will they stack up next year?

Been a terrific year from your boys mate and I have thoroughly enjoyed the back and forth banter. Kudos on a great year.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Click to expand...
Hey Thermos. Best to take the positives from the year as we finished 10th last year. And the Twos are in a GF. I am sure Ash and his recruiting team will be looking for some extra talent to allow them to close the gap on Shepparton and Echuca in 2025.
 
Passenger said:
Can anyone point out what minute mark it was?

Remember it was early days, and would
Click to expand...

Silver Tongue said:
Hey Thermos. Best to take the positives from the year as we finished 10th last year. And the Twos are in a GF. I am sure Ash and his recruiting team will be looking for some extra talent to allow them to close the gap on Shepparton and Echuca in 2025.
Click to expand...
Rochester punch well above their weight in this competition as a community and a club. After what they have been through it is a miracle that they are where they are. Atley seemed to be underdone on Sunday and seemed very proppy. Ash Watson is such a great person and I'm sure many will agree, one of the great on ballers of his time in the GV. Hopefully the can keep the momentum going with this list and have a real crack next year.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Yepyep said:
Clutching at straws. It wasn’t a scuffle it was a direct punch to the head while both players were on the ground. Smith was leaning over the top of him and drove a right fist into his head. Umpire was about 3-5 metres away and paid the free kick and reported him straight away. Umpire even mimicked the action Smith did when he blew the whistle. If he gets off this then it will truly demonstrate the influence the Shepparton football league has over the rest of the competition. High contact, intentional and medium force. 1-2 weeks with an early plea. Saw this from my seat about 15 mtrs in front of me with an absolute clear view of it. The fact the vision isn’t totally clear makes it worse for smith as he had nothing to defend as you can see the action on the footage of him throwing the punch but can’t see it land. The umpire will say it landed as he was so close he could see it, as i could in the grandstand. Ask Jack McHale from Echuca what it’s like to miss a GF…he took it on the chin and owned it. This is much the same although not as much force as Jacks. Clearly intentional though. Guess we will watch with interest.
Click to expand...
Sometimes this stuff can become a distraction for the opposition club. I hope it's not the case in this instance.
 
footylover44 said:
Luke smith has got offered 3 weeks and there gonna try take them on to play this weekend! Going to be interesting! 3 weeks is a lot to try get off!
Click to expand...
I know as a club your going to try but its not like he was offered 1 and it could be reduced.
He landed the punch. Do the crime, do the time. He got caught.
Shepp will need to find another player to come in as he will not be available IMO, and if he does get off that, then welcome to GV UFC next year.
 
thermos said:
Sitting on the couch playing a drinking game tonight. Every time McCarthy gets a vote I drink. I will be *ing paralysed by round 9. Round 18 stomached pumped and off to hospital I go. * it. I’m already pissed!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Click to expand...


I can’t see him getting up for you Thermos. Not with my man Big Red Shed Betson stealing all his votes. 1, 2 meowies finish I hope.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
thermos said:
Sitting on the couch playing a drinking game tonight. Every time McCarthy gets a vote I drink. I will be *ing paralysed by round 9. Round 18 stomached pumped and off to hospital I go. * it. I’m already pissed!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Click to expand...
Go you good thing!! Haha. I hope your man gets up!!
 
Just wondering if Rochy player number 47 was cited by the MRO also? He should get 4 weeks for smashing into smith front on, while smith had his head down. It was very dangerous and the kind of act that could have had dire consequences. Obviously why smith was so upset and remonstrated. He would put up with that weak crap every week getting targeted by cheap acts! We want our best players playing and umpires need to protect the player with the ball, not allow for them to be targeted by cheap shots.
 
wtf said:
Just wondering if Rochy player number 47 was cited by the MRO also? He should get 4 weeks for smashing into smith front on, while smith had his head down. It was very dangerous and the kind of act that could have had dire consequences. Obviously why smith was so upset and remonstrated. He would put up with that weak crap every week getting targeted by cheap acts! We want our best players playing and umpires need to protect the player with the ball, not allow for them to be targeted by cheap shots.
Click to expand...

Just on here for a reaction. Idiot.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Goulburn Valley FL 2024

Similar threads

Trent the flight Steward
Goulburn Valley FL 2023
124 125 126 127 128
Replies
3K
Views
300K
Long Run
L

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top