Goulburn Valley FL - Part 2

[ECHUCABOY]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Yeah Stinger he was shouting something to the crowd, couldn't here what though. It was Josh Vick who played on him, he ran at Saad after the incidend and wrestled him which started a small melee. If it had happened 10 years ago I'm guessing Saad would not have seen the end of the game.
I know I wouldn't be happy if I was his team mate.

Well Vick MUST have been racist to him because Saad only carries on like that when he is racially villified...........................

 

[morphous]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

If you have 2 legs and at least one arm come down and have a kick with us at the Tatura Doggies. Great Facilities. Great social club. Great Coaches. Haven't got the best cattle on the park in the league but all clubs go through those cycles
So you could take your chance with us, one of the most successful clubs in the last 20 years or go to Shep Swans and live the dream about winning first flag since 1970. You won't even have to move to Shepp or Tat. Go to sunny Darwin and they will fly you in!

No need to take a shot at the Swans.

 

[ringo1]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Well Vick MUST have been racist to him because Saad only carries on like that when he is racially villified...........................

Sounds like the boy is losing the plot!

 

[No Heart]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Sounds like the boy is losing the plot!

I know he would not of got away with doing that with our former coach

 

[yeehaaaaaaaaaaaa]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Well, well well. Saad's arrogant behaviour comes to the for again. I was hauled over the fire for what i said about this last week (refer my previous posts). To the seymour supporters that told me i was racisist if they read my posts i wasn't...i was merely pointing out that being arrogant like Saad is, can only add fuel to the fire for situations to occur. Interesting to see that none of these Seymour people are saying very much about this incident. Time he took stock for his own actions and stop blaming people for their re-actions....I rest my case! ARROGANT!!!!!!!

 

[Rockman]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

While all on here are entitled to their own OPINION,and lets face it that's what all this crap about Saad really is,for those who know him personally like myself and many others know that ARROGANT is the last thing that Saad is. He has clearly been the most exciting player in the g.v for a number of years and for the amount of physical and verbaal abuse he has been subjected to in his 4 seasons in this league(often with no protection from the umpires) he could be forgiven for acting out occaisionly.

So in closing yeeeeeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh,mj42,echucaboy and anyone else like i said at the top, opinions are fine but don't label people if you don't KNOW them .

 

[Johnny Tapp]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

While all on here are entitled to their own OPINION,and lets face it that's what all this crap about Saad really is,for those who know him personally like myself and many others know that ARROGANT is the last thing that Saad is. He has clearly been the most exciting player in the g.v for a number of years and for the amount of physical and verbaal abuse he has been subjected to in his 4 seasons in this league(often with no protection from the umpires) he could be forgiven for acting out occaisionly.

So in closing yeeeeeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh,mj42,echucaboy and anyone else like i said at the top, opinions are fine but don't label people if you don't KNOW them .

Most people form opinions by what others say and do - same with earning respect...

 

[yeehaaaaaaaaaaaa]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Only going on what i see on the footy field...i can form an opinion any way i like, don't think it's in the rules to have to know them to form an opinion. Observations are enough in my book to form what opinion you like, so therefore mj42, yeeeeeeeehaaaaaa and Echuca boy can form an opinion, any way they like. Think their might be a few others that have an opinion on Saad that might be slipping...i won't talk for them, will let them form their own opinions!!!!!!

 

[MJ42]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

While all on here are entitled to their own OPINION,and lets face it that's what all this crap about Saad really is,for those who know him personally like myself and many others know that ARROGANT is the last thing that Saad is. He has clearly been the most exciting player in the g.v for a number of years and for the amount of physical and verbaal abuse he has been subjected to in his 4 seasons in this league(often with no protection from the umpires) he could be forgiven for acting out occaisionly.

So in closing yeeeeeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh,mj42,echucaboy and anyone else like i said at the top, opinions are fine but don't label people if you don't KNOW them .

Pretty sure I never said that Saad himself was arrogant, don't know the man as you said. What I did say that it was one of the most arrogant things I have seen on a footy field and I will stand by that. If anyone who was there and sore it and thinks otherwise than they have hidden agendas. If he continues to do those sort of things on the ground than people will form opinions whether you like them or not.
Lots of good players cop abuse, its how you handle that abuse that people remember.

 

[the eye]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Hi can anyone tell me who puts the best players in for each side on the GVFL website cause after witnessing a few of the games over the last couple of the weeks i have noticed that the best players listed on the website are different to the opinions of people who have witnessed the games.

 

[phantom 309]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Well, well well. Saad's arrogant behaviour comes to the for again. I was hauled over the fire for what i said about this last week (refer my previous posts). To the seymour supporters that told me i was racisist if they read my posts i wasn't...i was merely pointing out that being arrogant like Saad is, can only add fuel to the fire for situations to occur. Interesting to see that none of these Seymour people are saying very much about this incident. Time he took stock for his own actions and stop blaming people for their re-actions....I rest my case! ARROGANT!!!!!!!

Good try but this changes nothing in regard to events in Echuca, YOU PEOPLE USED RACIST COMMENTS its that simple. But i am sure you will still have trouble understanding that.

 

[phantom 309]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Pretty sure I never said that Saad himself was arrogant, don't know the man as you said. What I did say that it was one of the most arrogant things I have seen on a footy field and I will stand by that. If anyone who was there and sore it and thinks otherwise than they have hidden agendas. If he continues to do those sort of things on the ground than people will form opinions whether you like them or not.
Lots of good players cop abuse, its how you handle that abuse that people remember.

Many one eyed seymour supporters are with you on this have not spoken to one that was happy with what happened, and to what i have been told the coach has chatted to him and he will be well aware it is not exceptable.

 

[ringo1]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Good try but this changes nothing in regard to events in Echuca, YOU PEOPLE USED RACIST COMMENTS its that simple. But i am sure you will still have trouble understanding that.

Once again you cannot label the whole club-thats a joke! As I've seen before-anyone can pay their money at the gate and not even be associated with a club. To label people as racists as a whole is pretty rough. I wasn't there but like any club I'm sure that there are many fine people associated with the echuca football Club and they are being tarnished with the racism brush

 

[trevor_byers]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Does anyone know how many players from Mooroopna and Mansfield have played AFL?

I know Blake Campbell played for Carlton back in 2002, but how many more are there?

Cheers guys

 

[Rockman]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Does anyone know how many players from Mooroopna and Mansfield have played AFL?

I know Blake Campbell played for Carlton back in 2002, but how many more are there?

Cheers guys

I'm pretty sure Craig Flint from Mansfield was on Carltons rookie list but don't know if he played a senior game and maybe Mooroopna's Brad Campbell played one or two afl games i think but i'm not to sure if he did or for whom. That would take care of the current crop but of course past players for each club would look like this

MANSFIELD:
Trent Hotton
Cam Hotton
Darren Hulme -all carlton
Craig Kelly - Collingwood
David Mench - Geelong

MOOROOPNA:
Derek Hall - Geelong
Gary Foulds - Essendon

Any help on anyone that i've missed

 

[TuskenRaider]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

I think he just wants to know current players who have played AFL.

Brad Campbell was at Melbourne and I'm pretty sure he played at least one senior game.

 

[Rockman]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

I think he just wants to know current players who have played AFL.

Brad Campbell was at Melbourne and I'm pretty sure he played at least one senior game.

Was just covering all bases matey. I was thinking Melbourne as the club for Brad Campbell but just wasn't sure, good work tuskenraider .

 

[FTW_]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

I'm pretty sure Craig Flint from Mansfield was on Carltons rookie list but don't know if he played a senior game and maybe Mooroopna's Brad Campbell played one or two afl games i think but i'm not to sure if he did or for whom. That would take care of the current crop but of course past players for each club would look like this

MANSFIELD:
Trent Hotton
Cam Hotton
Darren Hulme -all carlton
Craig Kelly - Collingwood
David Mench - Geelong

MOOROOPNA:
Derek Hall - Geelong
Gary Foulds - Essendon

Any help on anyone that i've missed

Flinty was on Carlton's rookie list in 06, then was elevated to the senior list in 07 but never played a senior game.
For Mansfield's past players there's also Andrew Tranquilli (Collingwood) and Brendan Hehir (Geelong rookie).

 

[Tatsean]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

No need to take a shot at the Swans.

Don't worry Morphous, just stating the facts. He wanted to know whether to play with Tat or a Shep side. Tatura Bulldogs is the best team in Tat at the moment and Swans are the best GV team in Shep. That's why I didn't mention United or Bears. Maybe I should have mentioned Rumba if he wanted the best team and facilities in Shep.

 

[cellar dweller]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Does anyone know how many players from Mooroopna and Mansfield have played AFL?

I know Blake Campbell played for Carlton back in 2002, but how many more are there?

Cheers guys

Looking to improve your radio station by researching on big footy?
Thought you were supposed to be a media guru??
Your improving with every post in my eyes!

 

[hank1]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Theres more than that.
Interesting that you would miss an AFL premiership player in your list of two.

Chris Smith last Mooroopna Premiership coach (Fitzroy)

 

[morphous]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Don't worry Morphous, just stating the facts. He wanted to know whether to play with Tat or a Shep side. Tatura Bulldogs is the best team in Tat at the moment and Swans are the best GV team in Shep. That's why I didn't mention United or Bears. Maybe I should have mentioned Rumba if he wanted the best team and facilities in Shep.

haha

 

[lion's_roar]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

No current player on Mansfield's list has played a senior AFL game.

Brad Campbell played 1 game for Melbourne in 1994, while Blake played 11 games for Carlton, (8 in 2002 and 3 in 2003), for just 1 win. A one point victory over the Tigers

Yeah i'm bored at work, so had time to check the stats (finalsiren.com)

 

[Rockman]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Theres more than that.
Interesting that you would miss an AFL premiership player in your list of two.

I did ask for any help with anyone that i may have missed at the end of my post sunshine but it was quite a long post, maybe too long for you . Maybe you could part with his name c.d ?

 

[Manbearpig]

Re: Official GVFL Thread (part 2)

Should say one thing then anouther in the same post. I would understand if you had a change of mind in what you post but not if it occurs in the same post.

S Clayton Euroa for starters would be the obviouse one!!

Didn't know S Clayton Euroa plays for Mansfield or Mooroopna.

Rockman, are you after guys who were from these clubs originally, like Josh Fraser, or just playing there now?