Heathcote DFL discussion 2024

[HDFLFan]

And has no doubt headed back out of the goodness of his heart for little financial gain... Anyone have any idea what is happening at the current premiers?

I heard that Mounts are not going to over pay the salary cap this year and will in fact do the decent thing and improve the facilities for visiting clubs and fill in the rabbit holes on the ground.

 

[NeonLeon81]

Is Grenfell the best FF playing in country Vic?

Not even close

 

[NeonLeon81]

Minogue at North Albury
Williams at Yarrawonga
Fergus Greene at Sandhurst

Just quickly off the top of my head but it’s all relative to the standard you are playing in I guess

He’s a gun and will be brilliant for Colbo

Mellington twice the footballer Grenfell is - he does it any opposition any comp year in year out.

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

Mellington twice the footballer Grenfell is - he does it any opposition any comp year in year out.

Maybe check how many goals he kicked at Benalla the last 2 years. Not sure he kicked many at caro Springs either.

 

[Stats101]

Maybe check how many goals he kicked at Benalla the last 2 years. Not sure he kicked many at caro Springs either.

Mellington
2019 kicked 130 off 20 games for Echuca United
2021 - 113 off 12 games for Violet Town
2022 - 92 off 13 games for Violet Town
2023 - 21 off 9 games for Banella
2024 - 93 off 9 games for Serpentine
449 Goals in 63 games from 2019-2024

Grenfell
2019 kicked 20 off 19 games for Tatura
2021 - 39 off 6 games for Marong
2022 - 154 off 18 games for Marong
2023 - 110 off 17 games for Marong
2024 - 89 off 20 games for Nyah
412 Goals off 80 games from 2019-2024
Grenfell has also kicked a few goals in the NT and had a few years in QLD over Covid and what not but didn’t add them in

 

[ROOTA#6]

Mellington twice the footballer Grenfell is - he does it any opposition any comp year in year out.

Mellington has been a superstar no doubt and if it was a pure football thing he’s probably in front…unfortunately Josh comes with enormous baggage.

Brando has not been a pure full forward for long so it’s hard to compare. Bloke is a gun ruckman also

 

[NeonLeon81]

Mellington
2019 kicked 130 off 20 games for Echuca United
2021 - 113 off 12 games for Violet Town
2022 - 92 off 13 games for Violet Town
2023 - 21 off 9 games for Banella
2024 - 93 off 9 games for Serpentine
449 Goals in 63 games from 2019-2024

Grenfell
2019 kicked 20 off 19 games for Tatura
2021 - 39 off 6 games for Marong
2022 - 154 off 18 games for Marong
2023 - 110 off 17 games for Marong
2024 - 89 off 20 games for Nyah
412 Goals off 80 games from 2019-2024
Grenfell has also kicked a few goals in the NT and had a few years in QLD over Covid and what not but didn’t add them in

imagine how many mellington would have kicked for marong if he played 22 23

 

[NeonLeon81]

Mellington has been a superstar no doubt and if it was a pure football thing he’s probably in front…unfortunately Josh comes with enormous baggage.

Brando has not been a pure full forward for long so it’s hard to compare. Bloke is a gun ruckman also

Would have loved to see him produce in GV or O&M to have that credibility on his resume like Mellington

 

[Silver Tongue]

Mellington
2019 kicked 130 off 20 games for Echuca United
2021 - 113 off 12 games for Violet Town
2022 - 92 off 13 games for Violet Town
2023 - 21 off 9 games for Banella
2024 - 93 off 9 games for Serpentine
449 Goals in 63 games from 2019-2024

Grenfell
2019 kicked 20 off 19 games for Tatura
2021 - 39 off 6 games for Marong
2022 - 154 off 18 games for Marong
2023 - 110 off 17 games for Marong
2024 - 89 off 20 games for Nyah
412 Goals off 80 games from 2019-2024
Grenfell has also kicked a few goals in the NT and had a few years in QLD over Covid and what not but didn’t add them in

Mellington kicked 95 for Benalla in the GV in 2015 prior to your statistics. Grenfell was at Seymour around the same period playing mainly in the ruck.

GV goals tell the story. Mellington is a far better FF. Also a far bigger flog

 

[ROOTA#6]

Mellington has been a superstar no doubt and if it was a pure football thing he’s probably in front…unfortunately Josh comes with enormous baggage

Mellington kicked 95 for Benalla in the GV in 2015 prior to your statistics. Grenfell was at Seymour around the same period playing mainly in the ruck.

GV goals tell the story. Mellington is a far better FF. Also a far bigger flog

Brando is also a lot younger

 

[NeonLeon81]

Mellington kicked 95 for Benalla in the GV in 2015 prior to your statistics. Grenfell was at Seymour around the same period playing mainly in the ruck.

GV goals tell the story. Mellington is a far better FF. Also a far bigger flog

Both fairly high up on the flog list. Not well liked by too many they play with

 

[NeonLeon81]

Mellington kicked 95 for Benalla in the GV in 2015 prior to your statistics. Grenfell was at Seymour around the same period playing mainly in the ruck.

GV goals tell the story. Mellington is a far better FF. Also a far bigger flog

100 odd for Albury too I believe in O&M

 

[ROOTA#6]

Both fairly high up on the flog list. Not well liked by too many they play with

Not many at Marong or Nyah have bad words about him. I didn’t play with him but I find him ok….many would say I’m a flog too so that may be why

 

[Silver Tongue]

Both fairly high up on the flog list. Not well liked by too many they play with

Not sure about Grenfell's body of work in this regard. Regularly changing clubs is of course a strong indicator.