Herald Sun Super Coach 2007

[borgy]

Very true, maybe I should just go with Lucas or just wait another week.

Worth juming on Kerr this week or wait another?

Im putting Kerr capatin this week. He would be fresh as a daisy

 

[borgy]

Im flicking Alwyn Davey.

Heres who im looking at with the money in the bank left over:
Lucas $15,900
Hall $16,900
Aker $74,900
Richo $96,300

 

[lion_gooner]

was 313th last week now 226th

still want to finish top 100 at least

NO chance of me winning it 1200 odd behind way to far behind

traded edwards for mitch clark

hope to downgrade davey to whoever is better out of westhoff or gray so i can then trade cox for a really good forward then my team will be complete

 

[Chrisrocks53]

How many trades left?

ROUND 2OUT Brown ($338,000)IN Medhurst ($307,400)
ROUND 3OUT Robertson ($365,300) IN Ablett ($212,000)
ROUND 4 OUT Davey ($129,400)IN Hawkins ($90,200)
ROUND 5 OUT Hille ($325,500) IN McIntosh ($313,600)

OUT Whelan ($387,200)IN Goddard ($528,800)
ROUND 6 OUT Medhurst ($313,800) IN Davey ($246,900)
ROUND 8OUT Goddard ($473,300) IN McPhee ($447,300)

OUT Gibbs ($275,300) IN Hasleby ($422,400)
ROUND 10 OUT Campbell ($254,200)IN Gray ($90,200)


there my trades so far, medhurst was a mistake from the start.

and 11 trades to go

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Is super coach the same as DT in that you win something if you are the club highest scorer?

 

[inwhiterooms]

i just had a call from the herald sun which answered my questions. in reference to trading (if you're asking me) it depends on your goals. i.e at the start of the year i aimed to peak at about round 15 (i peaked early) and give myself 6/7 chances to win a round so therefore i have only 4 trades left atm. i base trading on who i'm bringing in (before who i need out) and their price relative to their points. again it depends on your goals, i sacrificed scores early to peak mid year.

post yout team? i'm using the same theory as you, trying to get my team set as soon as possible, theres only one player now in my team who i want to upgrade and thats alwyn davey.

Thinking of downgrading heath shaw to a player of quality then upgrading davey to chapman or steve johnson.

 

[borgy]

Is super coach the same as DT in that you win something if you are the club highest scorer?

Leading the dogs are we? I might go check my ranking now come to think of it...

 

[borgy]

Holy shit im comming 45th in the dogs! My aim was top 50 in that so im rapt! How are you sitting HBG?

 

[leononski]

i have....

c.cornes
macca
fletcher(ess)
waters
mCphalin
birchall
smith
a.walker
ellis

judd
rodan
foley
priddis
murphy
fletcher(wc)
thomas
pettard

ryder
hudson
ackland
griffin

g.ablett
pav
bj
fev
buddy
al.davey
n.ablett
krakouer
t.hawkins

11 trades and $166,000 in the bank
way out of the race (6114th)

where should (or who) improve?

cheers.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Leading the dogs are we? I might go check my ranking now come to think of it...

Nah not leading.
I have been closish.
The weekly winner in DT gets a sherrin was hoping it wasnt the same in SC because I scored 2340 a man down and would have probably gone very close to getting it if there was one.

Going to have to pay more attention to SC. Ranking is getting better by the week. Still a long way off thew pace at 2200 though...

 

[motorvinnie]

o'keefe is it time to get him now? need to trade someone for monfries and i have 469,000 to spend

 

[borgy]

o'keefe is it time to get him now? need to trade someone for monfries and i have 469,000 to spend

I have had him since the start of the season and is a shadow of his last years form. Inconsistant to say the least. If you do get him you will have to persevere until the Swans start winning and that is normally around the second half of the season so now would probably be the time to get him. Although he has been playing bad at no time have i considered trading him.

 

[Big Member]

I have had him since the start of the season and is a shadow of his last years form. Inconsistant to say the least. If you do get him you will have to persevere until the Swans start winning and that is normally around the second half of the season so now would probably be the time to get him. Although he has been playing bad at no time have i considered trading him.

He's averaging 96.6 despite a couple of circa 50 point games. 50% of his games have been above 100. 80% have been above 80. He's dropped off from last year's heights of a 107.9 average, but I would expect he'll finish the season averaging close to 100 and be priced at around $500,000.

I thought he was overpriced when I took him at about $550,000 before Round 1 and always expected him to average less than last season. There simply weren't any better value options considering I already had the most comparable one in Gablett. ROK's meeting my expectations.

 

[Headless]

Who should I trade out first?

N. Ablett
A. Monfries
Al. Davey
L. Franklin

Cheers in advance.

 

[motorvinnie]

barry hall is he woth a punt as his real cheap as well.... ROK or Hall?

 

[Thursfieldness]

post yout team? i'm using the same theory as you, trying to get my team set as soon as possible, theres only one player now in my team who i want to upgrade and thats alwyn davey.

Thinking of downgrading heath shaw to a player of quality then upgrading davey to chapman or steve johnson.

Backs:
J. Bowden (capt)
L. Gilbee
D. Milburn
H. Shaw
A. McPhee
J. Koschitzke
C. Bizzell

A.Toovey
J. Smith

Centres:
C. Bruce
D. Swan
S. Goodwin
M. Priddis
N. Lappin
R. Hadley

D. Kerr
R. Petterd

Rucks:
J. White
D. Cox

P. Ryder
J. Griffen

Forwards:
C. Cornes
M. Pavlich
Br. Johnson
N. Riewoldt
L. Franklin
P. Chapman
W. Tredrea

T. Hawkins
J. Riewoldt

Still a few players to get rid of, Tredrea especially has been disappointing.

 

[borgy]

Who should I trade out first?

N. Ablett
A. Monfries
Al. Davey
L. Franklin

Cheers in advance.

I would trade Monfries out first. Davey, the first year player is getting more game time than him. Sheeds musnt have much faith in him.

barry hall is he woth a punt as his real cheap as well.... ROK or Hall?

IMO i would go Hall. Had a shocker last week but maybe hold off a couple of weeks before getting him to make the maximum profit on his low price. He is sure to continue his downward spiral. And also with Hall, he can be a possible captain unlike ROK.

 

[Stakerz]

Who should I trade out first?

N. Ablett
A. Monfries
Al. Davey
L. Franklin

Cheers in advance.

Ablett for sure.

 

[__DaVE]

considering i have 100,000 to spend who should i get rid of:
jess smith
koz
marc murphy
dale thomas
corey jones

thoughts?

 

[inwhiterooms]

who to get rid of considering i have 100k to spend- jess smith, kozi,
m murphy, dale thomas or corey jones????????

probably dale thomas, no real point in trading kozi and murphy as they are starting to string together 100+ games, therefore an upgrade wouldn't net u many more points.

Dale Thomas for sure mate, Barry Hall is dirt cheap if you're not already on. Or theres plenty more options...

 

[inwhiterooms]

Can someone rate my team and give opinions on potential upgrades.

Backs- H.Shaw, Adcock, Gilbee, Waters, Kozi, Smith, Chad Cornes

Mids - Judd, Cross, Kerr, S Black, Mitchell, Lappin

Rucks - Sandilands and Hudson

Forwards - Pavlich, B Johnson, G Ablett, Fevola, R O Keefe, Rob Murphy, Alwyn Davey.

Only real weak point i see is davey however with only 58K theres no real straight trade options, thoughts? other than that i think i've made a nice team..

 

[__DaVE]

Can someone rate my team and give opinions on potential upgrades.

Backs- H.Shaw, Adcock, Gilbee, Waters, Kozi, Smith, Chad Cornes

Mids - Judd, Cross, Kerr, S Black, Mitchell, Lappin

Rucks - Sandilands and Hudson

Forwards - Pavlich, B Johnson, G Ablett, Fevola, R O Keefe, Rob Murphy, Alwyn Davey.

Only real weak point i see is davey however with only 58K theres no real straight trade options, thoughts? other than that i think i've made a nice team..

what you need to do is trade out some sort of cash cow and upgrade hudson, do teh same for davey. and u do realise that rob murphy has been injured for the last however many weeks, he might need to go. then there is fev who is a potential high scorer who is in bad form, there are trade options for him but stick with him i reckon, other then that your team looks pretty good

 

[Stakerz]

My Team ; StakerzWarriorz Ranked about 600.

Chad Cornes
Heath Shaw
McPhee
McLeod
Gilbee
Kosi
Jesse Smith

Kerr
Judd
S.Black
Cornes
Pendles
Rodan

Sandilands
Cox

Brad Johnson
Pavlich
Hall
Riewoldt
NAblettLucas
A.Davey
Lucas

 

[hawker21]

Guys after a little advice up forward

Pavlich, B Johnson, Fevola, Hall, Reiwoldt, Franklin, Croad (Edwards, Hawkins)

Now the advice needed is on Franklin / Croad / Edwards


Want to upgrade one of them to say Lucas / ROK as my 6th player, then one becomes 7th and last a permanent bench all year.

Edwards has been a bit poor last couple after being great all year and thinking about him a the upgrade, Buddy 7th Forward and Croad bench.

Suggestions?

 

[footyfan_25]

Trade Help:

Franklin for Chapman or Reiwoldt