Herald Sun Super Coach 2007

[Hawkmad]

Trade Help:

Franklin for Chapman or Reiwoldt

Doesn't really matter either 1 is going to be a plus for your side.
The only way I could choose is toss of a coin. best of luck.

 

[footyfan_25]

Anyone know how the League fnals work?

Who get's the double chance, is it top 2 or 4?

Is it 1 v 4, 2 v 3, 5 v 8, 6 v 7?

 

[motorvinnie]

is Franklin going to drop any more? PLEASE DONT DO A BRENNAN!

 

[Brahma Bull]

Can some also explain how the finals work and are you allowed to make any trades during then?

 

[duckboy]

Finals are exactly the same as the AFL finals. Top 4 get double chance. You can trade during finals.

 

[borgy]

Trade Help:

Franklin for Chapman or Reiwoldt

When Chappy gets fully fit he should average more than Roo but only just. Roo would be the safer option though IMO.

BTW, i have them both

 

[Delidio]

worth upgrading travis cloke?
if so, brown or lucas?

worth upgrading jesse smith?
if so, mundy or johncock?

 

[D.Harris#4]

worth upgrading travis cloke?
if so, brown or lucas?

worth upgrading jesse smith?
if so, mundy or johncock?

Travis Cloke to J Brown, he hasnt hit any real form this year but ive got a feeling this week against the Bulldogs and the hole Aker thing i reckon he is in for 150+. I've already made him captain. just my opinion

 

[sblack]

should i either trade out cassisi for cash and upgrade a forward and play gibbs on the field or upgrade cassisi directly to someone like kirk?

if i did upgrade a forward it would be to Bj or steve thompson or maybe ROK

 

[duckboy]

worth upgrading travis cloke?
if so, brown or lucas?

worth upgrading jesse smith?
if so, mundy or johncock?

I wouldn't upgrade Smith yet, unless it was to an elite player.

 

[Impromptu]

B: C.Cornes, Carrazzo, McPhee, B. Harris, Polak, Clement, Bizzell (J. Smith, McMahon)
C: Kerr, Stanton, Foley, Notting, Priddis, N. Lappin (B. Harvey, Pettard)
R: McIntosh, Darcy (Griffen, Wood)
F: Pavlich, Riewoldt, Lucas, Lloyd, J. Brown, Fevola, B. Johnson (N. Ablett, Shultz)

1. Who should be the first bench for BACKS and CENTRES, as second one is obvious? Some have said Notting but he is in good form.
2. Who should be captain?
3. Yes I know I stuffed up with the rucks..
4. Clement has been 'test' with injuries for the last 3 weeks!!!! Anyone have an idea when he is actually back.

FYI - I wouldn't upgrade J Smith yet.

 

[footyfan_25]

When Chappy gets fully fit he should average more than Roo but only just. Roo would be the safer option though IMO.

BTW, i have them both

Interested in your thoughts as to why Roo is the safer option?

I believe he is more likely to get injured and as I said before the big men can be shut down more easily.

 

[SJ]

Best cash cow forward option for downgrade as a ninth forward?

 

[inwhiterooms]

With this forward line who would u upgrade Davey to?

Pavlich, Johnson, O'Keefe, G Ablett, Fevola, Robert Murphy, Davey.

I have 58,600 in the bank and am downgrading petterd who is my second bench player for my mids behind hadley to leave me with $512,500 to spend..

Thinking Steve Johnson or even Barry Hall?

 

[Barry_Dawson]

Best cash cow forward option for downgrade as a ninth forward?

I'm thinking one of the two Port boys, Westhoff or Gray.

Westhoff played key forward and kicked three i think, but looks very skinny/raw

Gray has got pretty big wraps on him over at the Port boards, but there is a query about his fitness.

Dunno who will play more games.

 

[duckboy]

With this forward line who would u upgrade Davey to?

Pavlich, Johnson, O'Keefe, G Ablett, Fevola, Robert Murphy, Davey.

I have 58,600 in the bank and am downgrading petterd who is my second bench player for my mids behind hadley to leave me with $512,500 to spend..

Thinking Steve Johnson or even Barry Hall?

I still think Steve Johnson's a bit risky. Especially for the price. Hall will fall further in price yet. Grab him in two weeks, not now. On the other hand Davey may fall too, but not that much. I'm not a massive fan, but what about Lucas?

 

[inwhiterooms]

I still think Steve Johnson's a bit risky. Especially for the price. Hall will fall further in price yet. Grab him in two weeks, not now. On the other hand Davey may fall too, but not that much. I'm not a massive fan, but what about Lucas?

yeah i'm not a fan either, j.brown a safe option?

 

[duckboy]

He'd have to be I think. Especially for the price he's at.

 

[hotdish]

My team, thoughts? Yes, i've used up most of my trades. Ranked 5000.

Backs: C.Cornes, McPhee,Milburn, Carazzo, Birchall,Kossie, J.Smith [mcMahon/Hansen]

Centres: K.Cornes,West,Kerr,Hasleby,Ball,Lappin [Petterd,Hadley]

Rucks: Jolly, Hudson [Cloke,Warnock]

Fowards: G.Ablett,Pav, B.Johnson,Lucas,O'Keefe, Riewoldt,P.Chapman [N.Brown, Westhoff]

Gonna upgrade Hudson-Simmonds later, and Kossie-H.Shaw, leaving a few trades for the finals and injuries.

 

[footyfan_25]

My team, thoughts? Yes, i've used up most of my trades. Ranked 5000.

Backs: C.Cornes, McPhee,Milburn, Carazzo, Birchall,Kossie, J.Smith [mcMahon/Hansen]

Centres: K.Cornes,West,Kerr,Hasleby,Ball,Lappin [Petterd,Hadley]

Rucks: Jolly, Hudson [Cloke,Warnock]

Fowards: G.Ablett,Pav, B.Johnson,Lucas,O'Keefe, Riewoldt,P.Chapman [N.Brown, Westhoff]

Gonna upgrade Hudson-Simmonds later, and Kossie-H.Shaw, leaving a few trades for the finals and injuries.

Have you kept N.Brown on your bench the whole time (assuming that is N.Brown from Richmond?)

Your patience could be rewarded in a couple of weeks time if it is, however would have cost you alot of points in the 1st half of the season.

 

[foxy_dal]

who would u guys trade first out of bock and davey, keeping break evens in mind. both will be gone within 2 weeks.

 

[SJ]

I'm thinking one of the two Port boys, Westhoff or Gray.

Westhoff played key forward and kicked three i think, but looks very skinny/raw

Gray has got pretty big wraps on him over at the Port boards, but there is a query about his fitness.

Dunno who will play more games.

Cheers.

Anyone else with an opinion?

 

[inside_player]

Possible trades:

200k in the bank.
trade 1 week
Out: Rob Murphy, Boyle
In: cornes, rookie

trade 2nd week
Out: ben Johnson
In: Bartel

cances of cornes staying at his current price?
chances of bartel dropping a little more?
chances of rob murphy returing to form?
chances of ben johnson picking up his act?


atm this trade is just off the mark at -800. do you think i would get the oppertinity to pick up these two guns in 3 trades? and when should i do so.

 

[G-Mo77]

Cloke out J. Brown in. That's pretty much a done deal there

I'm looking to unload Bock or Jordan McMahon just for cash, Frawley will likely be the pick will he continue to get a game at Melbourne? Any other rookies out there worthy of selection in the backline?

 

[Big Member]

Decided to hold off on the Murphy for Judd trade given their respective break evens of approximately 30 and 157. Will keep it up my sleave and push the button over the next few rounds, depending on how the go.

Heath Shaw helped make that decision because this week's league opponent has him and I don't, so fingers crossed he doesn't play as expected...