Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008: Part 2

[timbo3195]

IMO they won't drop Taylor, he, as a young player has been way too impressive to even consider it.

Now for my dilemma, which isn't so big

I have in my forward line:
L.Hill
J.Porplyzia
B.Hall
B.Burton
B.Johnson
C.Rioli
J.Brown
T.Cloke
J.Tippett

Obviously, Tippett will be on the bench, but who of the others?

Thoughts would be very much appreciated

 

[the_berger]

FINNALY mc namara gets a game

shame its against sydney

 

[Rhino5]

Geary out for Palmer. Bad due to its sideways nature??

 

[rizzo]

IMO they won't drop Taylor, he, as a young player has been way too impressive to even consider it.

That would be the case if we were shit. But Mackie needs to come in and Harry is the only option.

 

[SJ]

Ibbotson?

 

[sens]

Lucky Cox is named because Hampson got cut.

 

[Spartan]

Cox being under a cloud and Hampson out will force me into a sideways trade being Meeson out, Kreuzer in. Why the **** i got Meeson insted of West only my stupid brain knows.

I was going to do Dyson to Palmer but I'm seriously considering another sideways trade in Geary to Palmer. I see Geary becoming the next S.D.Thomspon (btw **** you Laidley) and I would rather piss him off now.

Sigh.

Stupid game.

 

[StEaLtH]

who to start on field...

rioli or n thompson?

 

[geelong_boy]

Spartan, your cursing of Laidley is giving me lots of laughs, please keep it up.

But yeah I agree with you, a fair few selection headaches this week.

 

[rizzo]

Cox being under a cloud and Hampson out will force me into a sideways trade being Meeson out, Kreuzer in. Why the **** i got Meeson insted of West only my stupid brain knows.

I was going to do Dyson to Palmer but I'm seriously considering another sideways trade in Geary to Palmer. I see Geary becoming the next S.D.Thomspon (btw **** you Laidley) and I would rather piss him off now.

Sigh.

Stupid game.

Is it really worth the trade though? I mean surely they would have put another ruck in if they thought he would miss?

 

[sens]

Yay. Spangher and McNamara to get a game.

 

[Athomas]

Some interesting outs...
1 trade this week.

Nicoski (amazed he even went up in price!) for Harry Taylor.

Now have to choose between N Brown, Taylor and Grundy (2 of them) to play.

Atm Brown and Taylor.

Glad about:
Cox (even though i'd say he will be a late withdrawal).
Porpz (Friend was convinced he wouldn't play..)
Gamble

Slightly mad about:
Geary - but have Bird or Houli to place on the field.
Hampson- But have west.

 

[Biggie]

Lucky Cox is named because Hampson got cut.

I wouldnt be too confident that he will play.

No trades for me this week, Jones gets a reprieve because of his good record v Norf.

Only needs 96 to b/e

 

[footyfan_25]

who to start on field...

rioli or n thompson?

Rioli ... Thompson was only good against us and that is because everyone is good against us

But then again he is playing Melbourne who are even worse.

Still would go Rioli

 

[benny1712]

thoughts on who you would keep in your side between Geary and Masten (yes, sidetrading for palmer)

 

[C-Dog]

would it be recomended to trade

sherman and nicoski
for
morton/t.tuck and Roughead

yes or no?

 

[Blackhawk03]

Facing a huge upcoming dilemna. Both of my centre rookies (Bird, J-Mac) are playing this week and Houli has imo been underperforming. I need to play one of the three and want the least amount of anger possible come monday. HELP!!!!!!!

 

[dannnie]

im in some serious trouble this week i got nicoski s.thompsom and l.hansen. should i trade any of these guys or just let it ride for ths week.

 

[lamaros]

Ride my luck with Cox? Or get another guy on the bench as emergency?

 

[SJ]

I've got some serious trouble with Nicoski, Proud, Pfeiffer and Thompson.

In retrospect, looks like there hasn't been much depth in the rookies down back this year, with a fair bit in the centre and forwardline.

That would be suiting you Walesy?

 

[the_berger]

this might sound like a stupid question but anyway

will jetta's price still go up this week even though he isnt going to play this week?

 

[foxy_dal]

this might sound like a stupid question but anyway

will jetta's price still go up this week even though he isnt going to play this week?

no. price changes only occur after games played.

 

[the_berger]

f*ck

i was hoping jetta would still go up because he only went up 30 odd grand

 

[beautime]

nathan jones for palmer

Is starting palmer to risky?

 

[jimbob7085]

i have used 6 trades! my team started first 2 rounds scoring 1750-1800 now its fixed to 2100's! how long should i w8 to trade again? Im think round six and tenish? then c wat happens after that! any help appreciated!