Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008: Part 2

[Clunk]

I'll make it short:

LLOYD OR J.BROWN OR DELEDIO and WHY?

Brown

Why.... consistent....in form......can bag huge scores.....he's in my team so he has keep doing well

 

[deasend]

Lloydy is in great form, potentially some massive scores as he has the potential to boot bags of 7 and 8.

Browny and Deledio are consistent, browny very rarely scores less than a 100. Lids has a tough run home from memory.

I'd go browny, but hey.

I wish all my players finished the season with Lids "tough run home".

He finishes with 3 games at the MCG against:
Hawthorn (136 in rnd 6)
Freo (109 in rnd 4)
Melbourne (138 in rnd 12)

The worry with Brownie is you play Sydney in the grand final (he scored 24 against them in round 3).

I think for the rest of the season they will score about the same, but come grand final week I'd rather have Lids against Melbourne than Brownie against the Swans.

Lids is 70k cheaper to boot. He'd be my man if I had your choice.

 

[MrChristo]

I wish all my players finished the season with Lids "tough run home".

He finishes with 3 games at the MCG against:
Hawthorn (136 in rnd 6)
Freo (109 in rnd 4)
Melbourne (138 in rnd 12)

The worry with Brownie is you play Sydney in the grand final (he scored 24 against them in round 3).

I think for the rest of the season they will score about the same, but come grand final week I'd rather have Lids against Melbourne than Brownie against the Swans.

Lids is 70k cheaper to boot. He'd be my man if I had your choice.

x 2.

Brown plays Hawthorn this week too...allow the fewest Inside 50's in the AFL...might have limite opertunities...at a ground where he's never played.

 

[sens]

Who should I get for Shaw:

 

[boppin]

i would wait this week and get Dasher next week. Otherwise Newman been pretty good

 

[sens]

i would wait this week and get Dasher next week. Otherwise Newman been pretty good

I only have 500k to use and Milburn's worth a bit over that.

 

[boppin]

Newman it is then

 

[OneEyedHawk]

FFS, now I'm wondering whether or not I should trade Shaw this week, or wait until next week. Have only 2 trades left (and Simmonds & Cox)

PROs: Really need a win this week. The guy I'm playing is pretty good, and it will be touch and go. If I lose I play probably the guy I'd least like to play overall next week.

CONS: Have already got coverage (Proud- 85 last week), Fisher, the likely replacement, then has the next 2 weeks (provided I win) to cop an injury and I'll be stuffed.

What should I do???

 

[Walesy]

FFS, now I'm wondering whether or not I should trade Shaw this week, or wait until next week. Have only 2 trades left (and Simmonds & Cox)

PROs: Really need a win this week. The guy I'm playing is pretty good, and it will be touch and go. If I lose I play probably the guy I'd least like to play overall next week.

CONS: Have already got coverage (Proud- 85 last week), Fisher, the likely replacement, then has the next 2 weeks (provided I win) to cop an injury and I'll be stuffed.

What should I do???

If you've got coverage, don't trade!

Covering Zero's is what you want to do. There's still plenty of weeks left.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

If you've got coverage, don't trade!

Covering Zero's is what you want to do. There's still plenty of weeks left.

Cheers mate, you just saved me from potentially a massive and costly error.

 

[hellfire]

BAH!

What's everyone doing with Goodes-daddy?

 

[Parasite]

Cheers mate, you just saved me from potentially a massive and costly error.

Or he just dumped you into a rematch with a guy you will probably lose against

 

[Biggie]

Or he just dumped you into a rematch with a guy you will probably lose against

Thats my line of thiking tbh.

 

[sblack]

Bradshaw or Bock?

Or Kennelly, Fletcher or some other defender under 434k...wish I could get PBurgs

 

[Biggie]

Yukky choice.

Bradshaw.

 

[Hawkmad]

Last 2 trades which option do I go for.

Option 1 - Deleido & Gilbee

Option 2 - Richo & Pratt/Godard/Mcleod

Option 3 Riewoldt & Mcleod

Any Thoughts

 

[hellfire]

Any Thoughts

Option 3 for me. But option 1 is close.

 

[Biggie]

Reiwoldt and Mcleod.

Deledio and Gilbee.

In that order.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Bradshaw or Bock?

Or Kennelly, Fletcher or some other defender under 435k

Bradshaw. As I said in another thread, take out the game he got injured and scored 9, and his average goes up to 99. Form since returning has been good too.

Or he just dumped you into a rematch with a guy you will probably lose against

Thats my line of thiking tbh.

Anyone else with thoughts on this excruciating decision???

FFS, now I'm wondering whether or not I should trade Shaw this week, or wait until next week. Have only 2 trades left (and Simmonds & Cox)

PROs: Really need a win this week. The guy I'm playing is pretty good, and it will be touch and go. If I lose I play probably the guy I'd least like to play overall next week.

CONS: Have already got coverage (Proud- 85 last week), Fisher, the likely replacement, then has the next 2 weeks (provided I win) to cop an injury and I'll be stuffed.

What should I do???

 

[Biggie]

Cox will play out the year.

Simmonds well you're stuck with him now.

Trade in Fisher.

Live on the edge.

 

[hellfire]

I'm in the same position, and I'm leaning towards making the trade this week. I'd rather make sure that I get the week off.

 

[hellfire]

**** it.

I'm living life on the edge too.

OUT: Shaw, Goodes.
IN: Newman, Hodge.

I still have Chapman, but I reckon he will be back for the GF.

 

[Parasite]

**** it.

I'm living life on the edge too.

OUT: Shaw, Goodes.
IN: Newman, Hodge.

I still have Chapman, but I reckon he will be back for the GF.

Of course he will.

 

[hellfire]

Of course he will.

Good.

I haven't heard anything on him, so I was just living in hope.

 

[Biggie]

Nice trades hellfire.

Hodge is averaging 124 since his comeback.

Newman doesnt need many touches to score 100.

Good luck.