Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[beaver fever]

How are people planning to spread their salary cap. At the moment my spread is :

3 players 500,000 +
8 players 400,000-500,00
7 players 300,00-400,000
2 players 200,00-300,000
Rest < 200,000

Most money averaged accross midfield as I believe that is where you get highest consistent scores from. How are others spending their caps?

Shouldn't that be a reason to spend less money there. More buck for your money so to say.

 

[dazy]

wat do u guys think. who should i get?
vanberlo (whos numbers will fly this year)
luke ball
brock mclean
andrew embly
marc murphy
dale thomas

 

[foxy_dal]

wat do u guys think. who should i get?
vanberlo (whos numbers will fly this year)
luke ball
brock mclean
andrew embly
marc murphy
dale thomas

just don't get luke ball, still partly injured i rekon, otherwise its a toss up

 

[dazy]

just don't get luke ball, still partly injured i rekon, otherwise its a toss up

yeah i rekon to caue he aint playing round 1 in nab cup so i think van berlo cause he is the cheapest and his number will sky rocket this year

 

[dazy]

who u guys rekon dale thomas or brendon fevola

 

[Athomas]

wat do u guys think. who should i get?
vanberlo (whos numbers will fly this year)
luke ball
brock mclean
andrew embly
marc murphy
dale thomas

Embley annoys me now, injury prone.
Forget about Ball and Mclean.

Van Berlo, Murphy and Thomas would all be ok. Tough choice. I'd go murphy with slight bias though

 

[Sackman]

wat do u guys think. who should i get?
vanberlo (whos numbers will fly this year)
luke ball
brock mclean
andrew embly
marc murphy
dale thomas

Marc Murphy would be my pick, had Thomas last year and was disappointed. He seems to be a better dreamteam player than supercoach. Clangers hurt him. Will be keeping my eye on Vanberlo though.

 

[dazy]

yeah i am going to take a risk and c how van berlo goes

 

[lion_gooner]

should i go for andrew welsh and have rookie reserves or ellis and have better reserves?

 

[Athomas]

should i go for andrew welsh and have rookie reserves or ellis and have better reserves?

Neither, any other options?

 

[David Villa]

should i go for andrew welsh and have rookie reserves or ellis and have better reserves?

Yeah definitely dude. Andrew Welsh is a freak SCer.

 

[chris88]

Just wondering people's thoughts on a couple of players for Supercoach:

A choice between Daniel Gilmore or Byron Schamer
A choice between Marty Mattner or A. Everitt
Bench player - Rhys Palmer or Chris Masten
Bench player 2 - Tim Callan or Rhys Palmer
Will John Meesen get a good look in this year as backup to Jeff White
Is Alwyn Davey a good get at the price ($350,000) or are there better at slightly cheaper or slightly more expensive.

Thanks so much!!

 

[Biggie]

yeah i am going to take a risk and c how van berlo goes

Had him last season and VB was OK without being spectacular.

 

[nan_11]

Hi,
My brother is starting a fanatsy footy competition with some mates. THe difference to sc and dt is that each team only has 20 players and each player can only be drafted once. The draft is this sunday. So Im wondering if any1 has any tips on who should draft. Any players that would make it into the top 50 100 players that wouldnt have been high scorers last year, also is there a realistic possibilty of any rookies scoring highly this year???
Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated, Cheers

 

[PAFCsince1870]

wat do u guys think. who should i get?
vanberlo (whos numbers will fly this year)
luke ball
brock mclean
andrew embly
marc murphy
dale thomas

all those players are risks.

ball, mclean, and embley have been injury prone the last few years..

van berlo may still play as a tagger this year.

i like murphy the most out of that lot.

 

[dazy]

I Thought Supercoach Was Starting Today

 

[nick_savo]

I Thought Supercoach Was Starting Today

What gave you that idea?

 

[dazy]

What gave you that idea?

there was a mention before

 

[nick_savo]

Well I e-mailed the Herald Sun and they told me that it is the 18th but I still find that hard to believe as it is still like 5 weeks till round 1 or something.....

 

[Athomas]

Well I e-mailed the Herald Sun and they told me that it is the 18th but I still find that hard to believe as it is still like 5 weeks till round 1 or something.....

4 weeks from Monday. But yeh is hard to believe. I hope your right.

 

[Biggie]

Well I e-mailed the Herald Sun and they told me that it is the 18th but I still find that hard to believe as it is still like 5 weeks till round 1 or something.....

18th?

Brilliant.

I start holidays then, plenty of time to change the side around.

 

[JDizzle]

What do you think? Only my second year so looking to improve!

J. Bowden
H. Shaw
Birchall
Johncock
Hurn
Nickoski
Ellis

K. Cornes
Cross
T. Johnson
N. Stevens
S. Butler
C. Dempsey

Cox
Simmonds

Reiwoldt
Pavlich
J. Brown
Delidio
M. Morton
Porplyzia

Reserves

David Myres
Levi Greenwood

Rhys Palmer
Beau Muston

Matthew Kreuzer
John Meeson

Marlon Motlop
Patrick Veszpremi

 

[dazy]

What do you think? Only my second year so looking to improve!

J. Bowden
H. Shaw
Birchall
Johncock
Hurn
Nickoski
Ellis

K. Cornes
Cross
T. Johnson
N. Stevens
S. Butler
C. Dempsey

Cox
Simmonds

Reiwoldt
Pavlich
J. Brown
Delidio
M. Morton
Porplyzia

Reserves

David Myres
Levi Greenwood

Rhys Palmer
Beau Muston

Matthew Kreuzer
John Meeson

Marlon Motlop
Patrick Veszpremi

yeah i rekon that is a pretty good team

 

[Ricketts]

What do you think? Only my second year so looking to improve!

J. Bowden
H. Shaw
Birchall
Johncock
Hurn
Nickoski
Ellis

K. Cornes
Cross
T. Johnson
N. Stevens
S. Butler
C. Dempsey

Cox
Simmonds

Reiwoldt
Pavlich
J. Brown
Delidio
M. Morton
Porplyzia

Reserves

David Myres
Levi Greenwood

Rhys Palmer
Beau Muston

Matthew Kreuzer
John Meeson

Marlon Motlop
Patrick Veszpremi

You have zero Geelong players, there's one glaring error.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

You're also short one forward player on the ground.