-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008
- Thread starter borgy
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
eugene_tomas
Team Captain
shld i have riewoldt in my frwd line + rookie or burgoyne in my backline + rookie
its a tough
its a tough
ANY THOUGHTS ON THIS TEAM
1. Gilbee (DEF) 02. Gram (DEF) 03. Proud (DEF) B04. Nicoski (DEF) 05. Newman (DEF) 06. Johncock (DEF) 07. Kennelly (DEF) 08. Pfeiffer (DEF) B09. Shaw (DEF)
010. Burgoyne (MID) 011. Dal Santo (MID) 012. Stevens (MID) 013. Geary (MID) B014. Dyson (MID) 015. Veszpremi(MID)B 016. Palmer (MID) 017. Ablett (MID)
018. Kreuzer (RUC) B019. Hampson(RUC) B020. Simmonds (RUC)021. Cox (RUC)
022.C.Jones (FWD) 023. Pavlich (FWD) 024. Porplyzia (FWD) 025. Bradshaw (FWD) 026. Grant (FWD) 027. Rioli (FWD) B028. Tippett (FWD) 029. Hansen (FWD)B 030. Hall (FWD) 0ANY QUICK THOUGHTS ON THIS TEAM?
1. Gilbee (DEF) 02. Gram (DEF) 03. Proud (DEF) B04. Nicoski (DEF) 05. Newman (DEF) 06. Johncock (DEF) 07. Kennelly (DEF) 08. Pfeiffer (DEF) B09. Shaw (DEF)
010. Burgoyne (MID) 011. Dal Santo (MID) 012. Stevens (MID) 013. Geary (MID) B014. Dyson (MID) 015. Veszpremi(MID)B 016. Palmer (MID) 017. Ablett (MID)
018. Kreuzer (RUC) B019. Hampson(RUC) B020. Simmonds (RUC)021. Cox (RUC)
022.C.Jones (FWD) 023. Pavlich (FWD) 024. Porplyzia (FWD) 025. Bradshaw (FWD) 026. Grant (FWD) 027. Rioli (FWD) B028. Tippett (FWD) 029. Hansen (FWD)B 030. Hall (FWD) 0ANY QUICK THOUGHTS ON THIS TEAM?
eugene_tomas
Team Captain
jetta or lachlan hanson??
Question.
Ive got a choice between Travis Boak, Bryce Gibbs and Richard Hadley.
Who's the best choice?
Ive got a choice between Travis Boak, Bryce Gibbs and Richard Hadley.
Who's the best choice?
Johncock. He's good at sweeping up in the backline and passing effectively.
Chapman or Riewoldt.
Who should I choose and why?
Who should I choose and why?
SJ
Premium Platinum
Seconded. One of my last decisions. Both epic SuperCoachers yet both under fitness clouds.
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
If I had to choose between the two I would go Chapman, only just. Chapman is just far more consistent and can score well in SC even if he doesn't have a huge game possession wise.
However he appears a little more underdone that Roo and might have a little less game time than usual to start with.
However thinking long term I guess Chappy gets the nod.
eugene_tomas
Team Captain
i got both so cant really help
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
Hrm. If you twisted my arm I'd say Boak.
SJ
Premium Platinum
Either way, by mid-season I will have both in my 22, no question (barring injury).
Just hard to gauge the formlines/fitness of both. I'd rather have the one who won't lose the greater value and will score more (obviously).
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
You're the bomber so you tell me? It sounds like Jetta is a marginally more likely starter for round 1. I'd go Jetta but again only just. Hansen had a similiar start to the 2007 season and player the first 2 games before getting dropped so that makes me nervous.
SJ
Premium Platinum
Who was first picked then? And why?
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
Wasn't Chappy under an injury cloud last year pre-season as well and came out with some huge games?
If it was me I'd go Chappy. However Saints are starting the season agains some Riewoldt friendly opposition.
Flip a coin I say.
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
I rate Johnno highly and Kosi lowly.
You can't gio wrong with Chapman and Hall, however I would try and squeeze Johnno in if you can.
SJ
Premium Platinum
Yeah he was under an injury cloud the entire season and maintained a phenomenal average. Slightly different kettle of fish coming off a very lean preseason and surgery though this time. I've been flipping coins for a fortnight already!
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
Tough one eh. Well to be honest I can see Roo dropping more in value than Chappy. Only because I think Roo will hit the big numbers more often but he also tends to have the odd 60 point game and when you're worth that much it hurts your price.
- Status
Similar threads
