Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[Spartan]

6k Short!!!!!!!!!!!

Post ya team again and i'll see what I can do for ya.

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

thoughts ?

 

[eugene_tomas]

Who was first picked then? And why?

i had chapy in 1st becuase i just feel he is the better pick a midfielder in the frwdline if u get me can jag a few when forward to.. it was close but like i said i got both

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Ok So i downgraded Gilbee to S Fisher and used the cash to upgrade S johnson instead to Chapman

 

[Spartan]

thoughts ?

Good effort I guess. Wikes and Cartledge won't play, you're better off downgrading somewhere and getting players who are likely to start round 1 and keep playing.

I'm not a fan of Delidio. Backline is solid without being spectacular.

Nice even team though. Should bring in decent scores.

 

[Spartan]

Ok So i downgraded Gilbee to S Fisher and used the cash to upgrade S johnson instead to Chapman

I definately wouldn't downgrade Gilbee to S.Fisher.

 

[eugene_tomas]

im not liking sam fisher.. goddard gram etc go mcphee has a new role forwd will be running between both 50s u will have som spare cash aswell to pur somweh else. just my opinion

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Ok i downgraded kosi to aker, gilbee to milburn and s johnson to chapman and i got $200 left good move?

 

[eugene_tomas]

yes except the aker part.. see if u can do better for that value ther.. porplyzia?

 

[sdsdsdsd]

yes except the aker part.. see if u can do better for that value ther.. porplyzia?

already got porp, maybe didak?
another way i could do it is if i downgrade dalsanto or kornes

 

[eugene_tomas]

yeh dal santo wld surely com down becuase has had an average pre season by his stanards but for the price tho that is all.. didak cld be an option but yeh i think aker is over

 

[Lukey M]

yeh dal santo wld surely com down becuase has had an average pre season by his stanards but for the price tho that is all.. didak cld be an option but yeh i think aker is over

Aker has just come off the back of 3 BOG's through the preseason...

 

[Big Member]

Either way, by mid-season I will have both in my 22, no question (barring injury).

Just hard to gauge the formlines/fitness of both. I'd rather have the one who won't lose the greater value and will score more (obviously).

I'll aim to have both in my 22 by mid-season also (since they are the two best and most consistent forwards in SC, a rung above Pav because they have higher ceilings). But from the start I just can't justify $600k on players with limited preparations and injury clouds when there are cheaper or similarly priced safe bets.

If I had to chose 1 it would be Riewoldt simply because he always seems to play with some kind of niggling injury, so I suppose this season is no different.

Chapman's game requires near full fitness and I'm always wary about groin-related injuries, even if the surgery has supposedly fixed the problem.

 

[sen rulz]

233103
join this league

 

[sblack]

233103
join this league

goto the league section if u want people to join ur league

 

[inwhiterooms]

Anyone else stuck deciding on Barry Hall or Brett Burton?

 

[SJ]

I'll aim to have both in my 22 by mid-season also (since they are the two best and most consistent forwards in SC, a rung above Pav because they have higher ceilings). But from the start I just can't justify $600k on players with limited preparations and injury clouds when there are cheaper or similarly priced safe bets.

If I had to chose 1 it would be Riewoldt simply because he always seems to play with some kind of niggling injury, so I suppose this season is no different.

Chapman's game requires near full fitness and I'm always wary about groin-related injuries, even if the surgery has supposedly fixed the problem.

You and I have very similar thoughts.

 

[Spartan]

Ok i downgraded kosi to aker, gilbee to milburn and s johnson to chapman and i got $200 left good move?

Gilbee vs Milburn is tough but not bad.

Yeah good move I guess.

 

[Hawkthorn33]

Who is the best option out of these 3 players?

Dustin Fletcher, Peter Burgoyne or Darren Milburn!

Thanks in advance!

 

[Hawkthorn33]

Anyone else stuck deciding on Barry Hall or Brett Burton?

I've got both, but if you must only choose 1 then Barry is a must on potential alone!

 

[NewmanFoley08]

Please give me some feedback need some advice.

BACKS - P.Burgoyne Gilbee H.Shaw Newman Birchall Nicoski L.Hanson Emer -
Proud Pfeiffer

MIDFIELD - Goodes Hayes Cross Stevens Johnstone Houli Emer - Bird Palmer

RUCKS - Simmonds Leunberger Emer - Meeson Hampson

FORWARDS - J.Brown S.Johnson Deledio Hall Didak Porplyzia Jetta Emer - Tippet C.Rioli

Thoughts would be greatly appreciated Thankyou!

 

[eugene_tomas]

milburn

 

[Spartan]

Who is the best option out of these 3 players?

Dustin Fletcher, Peter Burgoyne or Darren Milburn!

Thanks in advance!

Mr Burns.

 

[NewmanFoley08]

Deledio Franklin or N.Brown???

 

[Biggie]

Deledio.

As to the Riewoldt v Chapman topic, Riewoldt for me.