Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
what do u guys think who should i get out of alan didak or angus monfires and who out of david mundy or martin mattner + cash
cheers guys
 
prob didak just, not quite as up and down as monfries and will spend time in the mid as now has recovered from his inj last year. with the other decision, its a toss of the coin. i like mundy, even tho i couldn't fit him in my team, but if you need the cash in another area, mattner will also prove a handy acquisition. its a toss of the coin for that choice
 
prob didak just, not quite as up and down as monfries and will spend time in the mid as now has recovered from his inj last year. with the other decision, its a toss of the coin. i like mundy, even tho i couldn't fit him in my team, but if you need the cash in another area, mattner will also prove a handy acquisition. its a toss of the coin for that choice
thank you for ur help
 

Log in to remove this ad.

hey guys another Question that is killing me who would u get out of wood and simmonds
 
1. Cooney, Pendlebury + 10k in bank
2. Cross, Griffen + 85k in bank
3. Priddis, Pendlebury + 11k in bank
4. Cross, Nathan Jones + 17k in bank
5. Cross, Embley + 12k in bank

Any thoughts?

I'm split between #2 and 4

Anyone thinking pendlbury could become $550+ this year?
 
1. Cooney, Pendlebury + 10k in bank
2. Cross, Griffen + 85k in bank
3. Priddis, Pendlebury + 11k in bank
4. Cross, Nathan Jones + 17k in bank
5. Cross, Embley + 12k in bank

Any thoughts?

I'm split between #2 and 4

Anyone thinking pendlbury could become $550+ this year?
Awesome player and all massive amount of talent BUT he will get the no.1 tag this year. With his Dal Santo like skills and goal kicking ability opposition has to stop this quality going forward. Im gonna see the first few round see how he travels At his price there are safer bets that are cheaper and wont get the attention like Murphy, Pearce, Johnstone, Selwood and Embley (Barring Injury)
 
hey guys another Question that is killing me who would u get out of wood and simmonds

i would go simmonds primarily because he is the #1 ruckman while wood is behind fraser, but if u want to be different i reckon wood would be alright (will avg bout 50) and can make u money. but 2 years ago, i jumped on simmonds when he was dirt cheap and he did not let me down. i was one of the few coaches that had him and it did me a great deal of good
 
Thats it !..i've seen enough...i;m getting on the Cooney train.

Its time...his train depart in 3 days.

well i am the train driver for the cooney train and anyone who does not board before the thurs lock out will have to wait for the next week and waste of a trade imo
 
At the moment my backline is Cornes, Proud, GIlbee, Shaw, Mcmahon, Gram, Mattner with Pfeiffer as the emg.
Do you think there are better available at a similar price than Gram and Mcmahon?
Also, thoughts on Salopek?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

i rate salopek highly
barring injury will become a top midfielder and supercaoch point scorer is consistent has the ability to have big games
 
1. Cooney, Pendlebury + 10k in bank
2. Cross, Griffen + 85k in bank
3. Priddis, Pendlebury + 11k in bank
4. Cross, Nathan Jones + 17k in bank
5. Cross, Embley + 12k in bank

Any thoughts?

I'm split between #2 and 4

Anyone thinking pendlbury could become $550+ this year?
uve gotta either go 1 or 4
 
hey guys just wondering on your thoughts of this team

backs
shaw, johncok, m.johnson, birchall, lovett-murray, mattner, nicoski (urquhart, proud)

midfield
k.cornes, swan, salopek, jones, griffen, stevens (ebert, bird)

rucks
lade, simmonds (hampson, graham)

forwards
brown, lucas, fevola, kosi, headland, porplyzia, hansen (rioli, tippett)

what are your thoughts on that team??????
also do you think this forward setup is better
brown, b.johnson, lucas, hall, r.murphy, porplyzia, hansen
 
hey guys just wondering on your thoughts of this team

backs
shaw, johncok, m.johnson, birchall, lovett-murray, mattner, nicoski (urquhart, proud)

midfield
k.cornes, swan, salopek, jones, griffen, stevens (ebert, bird)

rucks
lade, simmonds (hampson, graham)

forwards
brown, lucas, fevola, kosi, headland, porplyzia, hansen (rioli, tippett)

what are your thoughts on that team??????
also do you think this forward setup is better
brown, b.johnson, lucas, hall, r.murphy, porplyzia, hansen

Second forward option is better, however murphy is a bit of a worry.

urquhart may start round 1 but will find it tough to keep his spot. better options out there, like U.Jabroni.
 
Hey

What are your thoughts on HOULI vs DYSON vs Ed BARLOW?

Or pay the extra cash and get SCHAMMER?

Or pay even more and get Nathan JONES , PEARCE or REILLY? and have no money left over.

thanks in advance
 
barlow mayb i very good buy,
schammer will either do what he keeps doin or have a break out season in haselbys spot
nathan jones would be the one i would pick in those 3 if ya have 2
another bloke i liek is brett peake, will be given oppportunity and if he has a full season will be a good buy
it depends on who u want to upgrage with the extra cash whats ya side like
 
the side is good , solid all round, nearly cracked top 200 last yr so aiming for big things this season, barlow i havent seen enough of, is he a geniune starting 18 player for the swans?

would nathan jones be the best value of a player around the 400k mark?
 
i reckon if hes named on the field for the first game u should be right, if not id go for peake or schammer
yeah i reckon he is the best around that mark along with embley(if he has a good year)
what you think of my side (posted at the top of the page)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top