Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[SJ]

PM me a jpeg of your team ?

No idea about Johncock.

Why would you want that?

 

[Athomas]

Why would you want that?

hahaaa to see what your thinking for the year

Judd being Captain - Effect his SC prospects?

 

[SJ]

Also thoughts on Rischitelli - I took a chance with him last year, and although didn't disappoint, didn't quite reach the heights hoped. Played 22 games last year after 18 in 2006. 2008 break out year perhaps?

 

[SJ]

hahaaa to see what your thinking for the year

Judd being Captain - Effect his SC prospects?

All I'm thinking is 'will Johncock be a good buy?'!

 

[RAW TALENT]

Des Headland Could He Have A Season Like He Did For Brisbane The Year Before He Went To Freo

 

[Bubba_5]

Alright guys. I'm a 1st time supercoacher and would really appreciate some feedback on my team.

Back
H. Shaw
B.Goddard
L.Gilbee
G.Birchall
A.Walker
M.Mattner
D.Pfeiffer

S.D. Thompson
S.Selwood

Centre
C.Judd
D.Cross
A.Cooney
T.Johnstone
N.Stevens
R.Palmer

B.Ebert
C.Bird

Ruck
D.Cox
T.Simmonds

S.Hampson
M.Gardiner

Forward
J.Brown
S.Lucas
B.Deledio
T.Cloke
B.Hall
A.Didak
S.Dew

M.Motlop
L.Hansen

leftover = $34,000

In particular I was wondering if I have taken to many risks? I was also wondering if it would be worth downgrading Mattner to Ellis and upgrading Lucas to Reiwolt and Cooney to Hayes

Yea that looks like a very nice team. A couple of weakpoints in Palmer and Dew, but heaps of superstar to back that up. I would opt for Muston over Ebert looking at the NAB cup matches but Bird is a really nice choice, you're one of the few people I've seen with him in their team but he had a great NAB cup match with I think 17 touches and 95 SC points so scores well and is already showing potential to rack them up. I think there are better options than Dew.

 

[dazy]

is coughlan playing round 1 and will he play as good as he did before he was injured.also thoughts on sam butler will he play round 1.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

is coughlan playing round 1.

I believe the teams are out a few days before the first game not a few weeks!

 

[Colin D'Cops]

Des Headland Could He Have A Season Like He Did For Brisbane The Year Before He Went To Freo

Did you get my PM regarding the Total Domination BFL Raw Talent ??

 

[swansfan51]

Never played Supercoach before, gave this a crack:

Backs

C Cornes
Fisher
Newman
Waite
McMahon
Mattner
Hansen

Pfeiffer
Greenwood

Centres

Cross
Pendlebury
Nash
Reilly
Schammer
Prismall

Palmer
Bird

Rucks

Cox
Simmonds

Gardiner
Hampson

Forwards

Brown
S Johnson
Deledio
Mooney
Hooper
Porplyzia
Thompson

Sellar
Valenti

Any suggestions? That's my first ever crack so I'm sure it has big holes.

 

[bloods01]

Yea that looks like a very nice team. A couple of weakpoints in Palmer and Dew, but heaps of superstar to back that up. I would opt for Muston over Ebert looking at the NAB cup matches but Bird is a really nice choice, you're one of the few people I've seen with him in their team but he had a great NAB cup match with I think 17 touches and 95 SC points so scores well and is already showing potential to rack them up. I think there are better options than Dew.[/quote]

Would you like to share them? Please don't say Hawkins or Thompson. At around $280,000 there is very little on offer.

 

[JDizzle]

Is Gilmore a possible starting player??

was is just a once off that he played so well?

 

[RAW TALENT]

Did you get my PM regarding the Total Domination BFL Raw Talent ??

yeh whats BFL ill join though if its dream team!!

 

[Colin D'Cops]

yeh whats BFL ill join though if its dream team!!

Big Footy League....Confirm your interests in the appropriate thread Raw Talent, and you'll be guarenteed a spot...

 

[TheMailman]

Yea that looks like a very nice team. A couple of weakpoints in Palmer and Dew, but heaps of superstar to back that up. I would opt for Muston over Ebert looking at the NAB cup matches but Bird is a really nice choice, you're one of the few people I've seen with him in their team but he had a great NAB cup match with I think 17 touches and 95 SC points so scores well and is already showing potential to rack them up. I think there are better options than Dew.[/quote]

Would you like to share them? Please don't say Hawkins or Thompson. At around $280,000 there is very little on offer.

Get on dan bradshaw..with a gun midfield of adcock, lappin, black, power and tj sendin the ball down he's bound to get his fair share of ball inside 50..and if he has a season anywhere near wat he had in 06 where he averaged about 93 then hes well worth the risk.

 

[Athomas]

Yea that looks like a very nice team. A couple of weakpoints in Palmer and Dew, but heaps of superstar to back that up. I would opt for Muston over Ebert looking at the NAB cup matches but Bird is a really nice choice, you're one of the few people I've seen with him in their team but he had a great NAB cup match with I think 17 touches and 95 SC points so scores well and is already showing potential to rack them up. I think there are better options than Dew.[/quote]

Would you like to share them? Please don't say Hawkins or Thompson. At around $280,000 there is very little on offer.

What is wrong with Hawkins? Geelong will still dominate. And N Ablett is gone.

Only Lonergan to compete wit hahaha.

 

[Athomas]

Get on dan bradshaw..with a gun midfield of adcock, lappin, black, power and tj sendin the ball down he's bound to get his fair share of ball inside 50..and if he has a season anywhere near wat he had in 06 where he averaged about 93 then hes well worth the risk.

Are you another person who doesn't realise he won't play Round 1...?

 

[Biggie]

Is Gilmore a possible starting player??

was is just a once off that he played so well?

Warnock will come into the side and Gilmore will be reduced to an average SC player.

Thats if Warnock is healthy.

 

[Blackhawk03]

Thoughts on Salopek? Seriously impressive at the wkend but will not get the same tog with the cornes' n burgoynes 2 return. Worth a punt or look elswhere?

 

[Biggie]

Thoughts on S.Thonpson of Adelaide?

 

[SJ]

Thoughts on Salopek? Seriously impressive at the wkend but will not get the same tog with the cornes' n burgoynes 2 return. Worth a punt or look elswhere?

How much upside does he hold? I had him last year and improved slightly until being injured mid-way through the season. Scored consistently after coming back. What sort of improvement does 2008 hold?

 

[TheMailman]

Are you another person who doesn't realise he won't play Round 1...?

where have ya seen that he wont play round 1?..bounce down is still a month away..says he'll be ready for round 1 on the brissy site.

 

[bloods01]

Get on dan bradshaw..with a gun midfield of adcock, lappin, black, power and tj sendin the ball down he's bound to get his fair share of ball inside 50..and if he has a season anywhere near wat he had in 06 where he averaged about 93 then hes well worth the risk.

You relaise he's had a limited pre season. Long odds to play Round 1 also.

 

[Bubba_5]

Yea that looks like a very nice team. A couple of weakpoints in Palmer and Dew, but heaps of superstar to back that up. I would opt for Muston over Ebert looking at the NAB cup matches but Bird is a really nice choice, you're one of the few people I've seen with him in their team but he had a great NAB cup match with I think 17 touches and 95 SC points so scores well and is already showing potential to rack them up. I think there are better options than Dew.[/quote]

Would you like to share them? Please don't say Hawkins or Thompson. At around $280,000 there is very little on offer.

Y not Hawkins? He should get the CHF spot at Geelong now. Richard Douglas going into his third year as a top 20 draft pick. And if u bump up the cap a little u get to Nick Gill who may become a permanent key forward at Adelaide with Perrie and Welsh gone and Hentschel coming back from season ending injury. On the flipside you could go lower down to Jarrod Harbrow who will make the starting 22 as often as Dew and probably will get more of the ball as well.
You're right, there isn't all that much on offer around that mark, so a better idea is to not put yourself in the position of having to select a defender 300, 000- to put in your starting 22.

 

[Biggie]

where have ya seen that he wont play round 1?..bounce down is still a month away..says he'll be ready for round 1 on the brissy site.

Sorry no source, but I did hear Leigh Matthews on a Sports Central radio interview that happened perhaps 3-4 weeks ago, he said Bradshaw was behind in rehab and will struggle to make rnd 1. Possibly rnd 4-5.