how many hawthorn players would get a game at geelong ?

[geelong_crazy26]

this IMO is geelongs best 22

B: milburn scarlett harley
HB: enright taylor mackie
C: selwood bartel corey
HF: rooke mooney chapman
F: johnson hawkins stokes
FOLL: ottens ablett ling

INT: blake kelly hunt wojinski

so the question is who from hawthorn would get a game at geelong and whos place would they take?

franklin can take hawkins spot
hodge cant take wojinskis spot
mitchel can take kellys spot

who else ? their is not 1 other player who would get a game at geelong form hawthorn

if you name a hawthorn player you have to say whos spot they will take

 

[Mcchawk]

Crazy haven't you already done this in a thread.

New material dude, this is boring

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Crazy haven't you already done this in a thread.

New material dude, this is boring

its appropriate because it shows the difference between the 2 sides

even tho geelong are 1st on the ladder and hawthorn are third their is a massive difference

 

[Spartan]

So Hodge and Mitchell sit on the bench?

 

[Mcchawk]

its appropriate because it shows the difference between the 2 sides

even tho geelong are 1st on the ladder and hawthorn are third their is a massive difference

Dude use the search function

 

[Beerfish]

In all honesty I'm not sure there would be any Hawk players (other than the ones you've already mentioned) that would even make it into the seconds at Geelong.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

So Hodge and Mitchell sit on the bench?

don't think you could get both on the ground , its debatable but to make it simple I just put them on the bench otherwise 2 moves would be needed instead of 1. 1 would probably start on the ground ,maybe both

 

[Eel_storm]

as if hodge wouldn't get a game at the expense of mackie, ling, milburn, bartel, i could go on . . .

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Dude use the search function

and dude how can you remember all the thread I have started , have you got a thing going for me or something ?

in all honesty I can remember very few of my past threads, I am too busy with the woman

 

[El_Scorcho]

Roughead is better than Mooney
A few Hawthorn defenders are better than Taylor
Rooke, Stokes, Mackie and Hunt are all very replaceable. With who would depend on matchups etc.

So that would be 9/22 at least.

While I don't have the time or inclination to go through Hawthorns list and pick the replacements, they are certainly there.

 

[Mcchawk]

and dude how can you remember all the thread I have started , have you got a thing going for me or something ?

in all honesty I can remember very few of my past threads, I am too busy with the woman

Because you are by far the worst poster on Big Footy.

Busy with woman, start a thread of pics of your latest conquests. You then become a Big Footy legend like me!!

 

[geelong_crazy26]

as if hodge wouldn't get a game at the expense of mackie, ling, milburn, bartel, i could go on . . .

what ? please read ,hodge can only take 1 players spot so he took wojinski's spot
hodge is in the team , forget who's on the bench it just makes it simpler that way

 

[Mcchawk]

I don't think this thread worked out quite as liked

 

[Eel_storm]

the OP says differently

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Roughead is better than Mooney
A few Hawthorn defenders are better than Taylor
Rooke, Stokes, Mackie and Hunt are all very replaceable. With who would depend on matchups etc.

So that would be 9/22 at least.

While I don't have the time or inclination to go through Hawthorns list and pick the replacements, they are certainly there.

who is better than taylor ? gilham is a dud and croad use to get set 2 the 2nds when he played for freo

mooney is a big time finals player so no way will roughead take his spot

 

[geelong_crazy26]

I don't think this thread worked out quite as liked

its going perfect cause i am educating people

 

[Mcchawk]

its going perfect cause i am educating people

Dude you're failing miserably. You had a few nibbles but no big bites. I suggest you take MCCHawks Trolling 101 at your local uni.

 

[Hawkk]

mooney is a big time finals player so no way will roughead take his spot

This is hilarious.

Had a massive influence in the 1999 premiership

Everyone's a 'big time finals player' when the finals are over at half time.

Mooney = frontrunner

 

[Eel_storm]

Mooney would at least go to FF, Franklin would take CHF

 

[geelong_crazy26]

This is hilarious.

Had a massive influence in the 1999 premiership

Everyone's a 'big time finals player' when the finals are over at half time.

Mooney = frontrunner

ahhahahahah why do you think the finals where over at half time ? the score always starts at 0-0 ahhahahahahahahha owned

 

[El_Scorcho]

Mooney benefits massively from the perfect delivery he gets. Roughead is a better player.
Croad is better than Taylor

 

[Hawkk]

ahhahahahah why do you think the finals where over at half time ? the score always starts at 0-0 ahhahahahahahahha owned

Like I said, if he was such a massive 'finals player' why did he get the donuts in the '99 GF?

Anyone can kick 6 goals when you win by 119 pts.

 

[didak04]

who is better than taylor ? gilham is a dud and croad use to get set 2 the 2nds when he played for freo

mooney is a big time finals player so no way will roughead take his spot

Croad is also an All Australian Centre Half Back. Think he might nearly have Taylor covered

 

[ripitup27]

Honestly?

I think the team would lokk something like:

B: C.Brown M.Scarlett T.Harley
HB: L.Hodge T.Croad D.Milburn
C: J.Corey S.Mitchell B.Sewell
HF: S.Johnson L.Franklin P.Chapman
F: M.Stokes C.Mooney J.Roughead
R: B.Ottens J.Bartel G.Ablett
Int: R.Campbell C.Ling A.Mackie J.Selwood
Emg: C.Rioli J.Lewis C.Enright

But it's not going to happen and I wouldn't want to take any Hawks players to ruin the balance of our side. Except maybe Buddy.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Like I said, if he was such a massive 'finals player' why did he get the donuts in the '99 GF?

Anyone can kick 6 goals when you win by 119 pts.

at geelong hes been a massive finals player in every final game, was too young when he played in the 99 final.lol you know if mooney didnt kick 5 goals than guess what ? geelong wouldn't of won by 119 points , weather you win by 100 or 1 point the score always starts of at 0 to 0