If you could choose 3 players over 30 years of age.....

[saintkildaman]

Only rule is that players have to be 30 or older by 2011.

Heres my go-
1. Adam Goodes
2. Jonathan Brown
3. Lenny Hayes

Unlucky-
P.Chapman
B.Harvey
B.Hall

I think I am forgetting a couple of players.

And sorry if this thread has already been done.

 

[omit]

choose them for what?

 

[Donakebab]

choose them for what?

Play football? Derp a derp.


Fletch, Hayes, Goodes.


BTW, Chapman and Brown don't turn 30 until after the season is finished, stupid to put them in.

 

[pazza]

1. Fletcher
2. Goodes
3. Hayes

 

[royboy2]

Black
Hayes
Goodes

No Brown as he wont be 30 until the 2012 season

 

[TerryWallet]

Anyone but Cam Bruce.

 

[NYJetsfor2029]

Goodes, Hayes and Goodes again

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Hayes, Scarlett, Black

 

[Danair]

Adam Goodes
Brent Harvey
Ryan O'keefe

 

[Colin D'Cops]

Lenny Hayes
Adam Goodes
Simon Black

 

[joeyavalanche]

Anyone but Cam Bruce.

brock mclean gets around like he's 30

 

[GameOver]

If we're talking about their impact in the 2011 season then I'll go Hayes, Harvey, Goodes.

Career: Goodes, Black, Hayes

 

[Eddie Dingle]

Whitten
Skilton
Farmer.

 

[jayjones1]

goodes
hayes
harvey

 

[RooHooDoo]

goodes
hayes
harvey

These guys

 

[MarkT2]

If I have to give up much then I'd rather none of them and stick with what we have and draft from there. If they came free then Hayes and J. Brown is all I would bother with. Nothing wrong with the others but not needed or have decaying bodies.

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

For Hawthorn:

Fletcher to walk into FB
Harvey to provide us with a goal kicking crumber
Adam Goodes to play across HF with Buddy.

 

[AG]

If I have to give up much then I'd rather none of them and stick with what we have and draft from there. If they came free then Hayes and J. Brown is all I would bother with. Nothing wrong with the others but not needed or have decaying bodies.

You wouldn't take Goodes for free?

 

[Bad Brain]

If I have to give up much then I'd rather none of them and stick with what we have and draft from there. If they came free then Hayes and J. Brown is all I would bother with. Nothing wrong with the others but not needed or have decaying bodies.

Can we please have Tarrant back then!

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Grand Final would have been nice if StKilda had Brown instead of Kosi, Harvey and Goodes instead of Eddy and McQualter.
Alongside Lenny Hayes, Stephen Milne, Steven Baker, Jason Blake and Michael Gardiner.

In fact you'd be able to put together a more than decent team out of 30+ players.

 

[WATTSJURRAHDUNN]

By next season start:

With Dees headint forward-
GREEN, HAYES, SCARLETT

Fletcher struggle to get a game in our backline at his age and ability.
Milburn the same.

Goodes just behind Black for his career for mine. Brownlow's mean nothing to me.

 

[AG]

Fletcher struggle to get a game in our backline at his age and ability.

He is still better than all your key defenders apart from Frawley imo.

 

[WATTSJURRAHDUNN]

He is still better than all your key defenders apart from Frawley imo.

Wouldn't think so. Long kick but not as quick as our slowest defender. Great career but wouldn't want to rely on him going forward. When you don't have the talent to make the finals, let the old boys go. eg: Junior McDonald. Talented, but not going to win a play in a flag.

 

[Donakebab]

Wouldn't think so. Long kick but not as quick as our slowest defender. Great career but wouldn't want to rely on him going forward. When you don't have the talent to make the finals, let the old boys go. eg: Junior McDonald. Talented, but not going to win a play in a flag.

Slow? Get a clue and watch a game, he may be old but he's lost none of his pace.

He is easily in front of any of your defenders bar Frawley. He would have made the AA team this year if it wasn't for injury/suspension.

Don't be daft, having a general in the backline to teach the youngsters is great, just the same as having an old hand like Green in your forward line.

 

[im_a_lazy_sod]

As of today we only have two players over 30 - yesterday we only had one so Happy Birthday to Roger Hayden

Lenny Hayes
Paul Chapman
Would maybe have Taz back