- Banned
- #126
GOt them from on the couch about 2 weeks ago
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Is Judd a great leader now?
- Thread starter Marc Shmurf 3
- Start date
- Tagged users None
GOt them from on the couch about 2 weeks ago
Indeed but we're not talking about me thanks all the same .
Juddy came off because he had to , pissed off , because of the blood rule not because of duress . No doubt it hurt but he'd have been far more debilitated , frustrated and in more pain by his groin problems in the past few years than tonight . Yet with a broken , bleeding nose he suddenly becomes more courageous and more of a leader because there is a visual aid that people can follow ?
Please , that's for internet plebs that know no better .
Yeah his nose will be as sore as all **** , he'll have a headache from hell and it's not a lot of fun with blood running down your throat but I'm sure he'll live .
Shaker_Maker
Senior List
Nathan Buckley anyone?
Shaker_Maker
Senior List
should sit at half-back minding "fresh air" getting the same kudos as some over-hyped Hawthorn player?
Get over it, you ****ed up and chose the wrong player in the draft.
Butera
Senior List
Broken noses can lead to breathing problems, its not rocket science, depending how bad the brake is, and the position the nose is in after the brake can block passages.
Judd was coming off not only for the blood rule but to get his passages cleared, they would not simply put another layer of tape over the top, but they took off the existing bandages and reapplied fresh ones once he could breathe again. He was loosing air intake which leads to fatigue of the muscles as there is no oxygen going to them. He would of been feeling very lathargic and always out of breath.
9/10 when u break your nose you recieve a concussion, the fact that he smashed his head on a skull would almost garuntee a concussion.
Judd played his heart out tonight, 9 clearences, 11 contested possesions showed that even with his broken nose he didnt shark an issue. Courages and pure leadership for a side that struggles in that department.
Judd was coming off not only for the blood rule but to get his passages cleared, they would not simply put another layer of tape over the top, but they took off the existing bandages and reapplied fresh ones once he could breathe again. He was loosing air intake which leads to fatigue of the muscles as there is no oxygen going to them. He would of been feeling very lathargic and always out of breath.
9/10 when u break your nose you recieve a concussion, the fact that he smashed his head on a skull would almost garuntee a concussion.
Judd played his heart out tonight, 9 clearences, 11 contested possesions showed that even with his broken nose he didnt shark an issue. Courages and pure leadership for a side that struggles in that department.
I can't believe that jealousy can lead to so many stupid posts on this thread. I bet if any of these silly nongnongs's teams could have snared Judd instead of Carlton, they would be crowing instead.
Judd is a great player, a great leader by example, and I wish to heck he came to Essendon instead. The guy is a real champion of the game.
Judd is a great player, a great leader by example, and I wish to heck he came to Essendon instead. The guy is a real champion of the game.
Carlton lost the game in the first 10 minutes because it lost clearances and midfield ball. Judd is the leader of that group at Carlton, so when the game was won and loss Judd was pathetic. He can't have it all one way.
You're just jealous because Eddie couldn't convince Judd to go to Collingwood. I bet if he had gone to Collingwood, you'd be praising him like he was the greatest of all time.
if he came to Collingwood he'd at least learn that you've got to be accountable for his opponent
JeffDunne
TheBrownDog
Not sure it's always jealousy.
There's a lot around here that might watch a lot of football but appear not to understand the game.
And quoting media opinions is the gutter to sit on when you can't even manage that.Stats are like poles for drunks to lean on.
Truly a great now that he's at Carlton............
He was always a great leader... now that he seems to have shaken his groin issues he is able to play his true roll of leading the team from where the ball is, rather than the end of his career at WCE where he played in the forward line.
He needs to win a few finals with his team before he can be considered absolutely a great leader. Leaders who have not led their team to finals success cannot truely be considered great leaders.
He needs to win a few finals with his team before he can be considered absolutely a great leader. Leaders who have not led their team to finals success cannot truely be considered great leaders.
Does anyone believe he was really the leader at the Eagles?
- May 6, 2009
- 10,622
- 25,578
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
By the sounds of things, Judd was tearing it up until he broke his shnoz, and consequently this was the deciding factor in the match.
Im curious to know which game this was?
I was at Etihad last night so I missed this pre-broken nose, Judd dominate game.
Must have been good though.
Im curious to know which game this was?
I was at Etihad last night so I missed this pre-broken nose, Judd dominate game.
Must have been good though.
- Mar 23, 2007
- 34,932
- 23,542
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Man U, Canucks and 49ers
I'm with you. Saw it on TV and loved the way when he handballed and missed a target, a commentator described it as 'Judd handballs perfectly into open space'.
Judd's flashy to watch, but doesn't hurt with his possessions as much as others and doesn't get a bucketload of it.
Yeah agreed.
I thought Judd was pretty impressive with the way he kept coming back on with his broken nose. I hate west coast and carlton and I still think that the guy is a great leader.
Juddy's nose was completely taped up. He was breathing through his mouth, which not only makes you considerably more tired quicker, but when his nose kept bleeding and blood was running into his mouth, he was gagging on his own blood and couldn't breath. Not only that, but there were thoughts that maybe the blood was even running down his throat as it couldn't get out ofhis nose.
He was gagging on his own blood and could barely breath, yet saw that we needed him in such a tight finish, and was doing all he could to get on the field and help out.
Get a clue ya big tough keyboard hero. You're pathetic
- May 6, 2009
- 10,622
- 25,578
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
How did all of this effect his game in the first half?
To be fair, it must have been the incredible hard tag the saints had on him. oh wait....
That's right- we didnt bother.
C Judd = Money well spent.
Similar threads
