Toadvine
17?19?
- Feb 29, 2008
- 8,331
- 14,801
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens
He was still coming back from a foot injury against SA so I'll cut him slack on that game.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
He was still coming back from a foot injury against SA so I'll cut him slack on that game.
Fair enough. It's tough commenting sometimes. Caddy is an excellent prospect with a reasonable chance of being a useful AFL player. I guess what I'm trying to say is I doubt he's a certainty to be influential at AFL level. Of course none of the 2010 draftees are certainties, but kids like Gaff and perhaps Atley, with the benefit of full-time preparation, seem (to me) more likely to succeed. My comments shouldn't be seen as a knock on Caddy. I think he's a good player, with a good chance of doing well. Just don't think he's going to be Top 10. A good TAC finals series might change my opinion.
I don't know what you've been sniffin Kenny Whiffen. You say he seems very developed? Please explain further. The game in SA, you obviously were not at the game. He was better in that game than the one against NT. Against SA he had 26 touches kicked a goal and hit the post twice. Did turn it over a couple of times, but understand he gets contested footy under pressure for most of his possessions. The beauty of Josh that seperates him from most other inside mids, is that he can also play as a leading forward.He would have made the metro team playing that role alone if that was all he could do. Lets not forget that.
I just watched a youtube video of Josh. I don't understand why he is not a certain top 10 pick. Is there anything wrong with him?
Thats what I thought when I saw his video, this blokes a dead set gun. He's as hard as nails, gets clearances, has decent pace and is versatile in the fact he can go forward and kick goals. I'd almost lock him in the top 10 but it depends on who slides and who's available for each club. Personally if Atley or Gaff aren't available at pick 8 I'd love to get Caddy.
Defnately won't be breaking any 20 metre sprints at DC.
Inside mid with power. Very good ability to go forard and look at home. I'd say we'll see a lot of him in the F50 of whoever drafts him in his first year.
I (and a lot of recruiters) was very happy and surprised to see that.Ran a 2.91 20m sprint at draft combine yesterday. Thats definately not slow wall-e.
This:What's with all the deleting off posts?
A reminder to people who wish to post on this board...
These threads are about the players, how they're performing and where they are likely to be taken in the draft.
What these threads are NOT for are comments along the following lines:
Inane rubbish like this has been (and will continue to be) deleted on sight.
- "I really like player X".
- "I hope player X slips to pick Y so that my club can select him".
- "Player X would fit in really well in the back line at team Y."