Josh Kennedy > Chris Judd

[Trump]

Why?

Because he can run.

For such a smart man like Judd to convince himself that hed be ok to play after suffering from OP the following year is very naive.

He's had a chop that is a quick fix and will mask his true problem for a short time.

He's shot himself and the Carlton Football club in the foot.

Mean while Josh is making leaps and bounds in his new proffesional club with an outstanding culture of success.

 

[GuzzLG]

Good luck to the kid, hope he becomes a star.

 

[anti.]

haha no way! i'd take an injured judd over a fit kennedy any day!

 

[Trump]

Good luck to the kid, hope he becomes a star.

Oh he will be, a good stable culture free of price-fixing and the abilit to run are priceless in the modern game.

 

[k00k]

Trump, the mention of the word 'culture', and you've left yourself wide open for some baiting there. Even as a WCE supporter, I can see where this thread is going to go rather quickly...

 

[BLue_Bloys]

Oh he will be, a good stable culture free of price-fixing and the abilit to run are priceless in the modern game.

3 months ago the guy was supposed to be a spud?

 

[mollyfud]

Its interesting that you West Coast supporters would be comparing the son of a Hawk Champion still making his way in the game to your former champion, Brownlow Medalist. I think it is way, way to early to compare Josh to Judd and even at the peak of his powers I am not sure he will be as good.

Having said that he is huge across the shoulders and seems to be quite powerful if he has enough pace and endurance to go in the midfield he could be an extremely handy player.

So don't put extra pressure on the young fellow, being the son and Grandson of Hawk champs is bad enough with out comparing him to Judd!!!
;-)
Molly

 

[Trump]

3 months ago the guy was supposed to be a spud?

A spud who can run.

Your attention to detail is as profound as Judd's surgeon.

 

[didak04]

Why?

Because he can run.

For such a smart man like Judd to convince himself that hed be ok to play after suffering from OP the following year is very naive.

He's had a chop that is a quick fix and will mask his true problem for a short time.

He's shot himself and the Carlton Football club in the foot.

Mean while Josh is making leaps and bounds in his new proffesional club with an outstanding culture of success.

mmm sounds to me like the words of a bitter eagles fan...chin up

 

[Underdog]

3 months ago the guy was supposed to be a spud?

He still is

It will be a while until we see the results of the superior WC development team's impact...if we see results at all

 

[Silvagnis]

Armfield>>>>>>>>>>Masten.

 

[adelaide_40]

I reckon kennedy is going to be a good player in a few years

however I would take Judd

 

[BLue_Bloys]

A spud who can run.

Your attention to detail is as profound as Judd's surgeon.

You do realise all Judd has been doing at training is running? Perhaps you're the one lacking with the details?

 

[Underdog]

Armfield>>>>>>>>>>Masten.

Armfield will be a great little pick up but there is little basis for that comparison.

 

[bzparkes]

Armfield>>>>>>>>>>Masten.

Who?

 

[Windas_Magic]

For the future, Ryder and Gumby>>>>>>>Judd and Kennedy

 

[Embers]

Armfield will be a great little pick up but there is little basis for that comparison.

I didnt even want our club rookie listing Armfield. Biggest downhill skier around.

 

[Trump]

You do realise all Judd has been doing at training is running? Perhaps you're the one lacking with the details?

Damaging himself in the process.

Judd's gone. We got the best of him and its sad to see such a talent be shot doen at such a young age.

He will never be the same.

Where as Josh, wow, he is going to be special.

And the culture around him is so beneficial, rather than those dirty price-fixing tankers over east.

 

[Lance Uppercut]

And the culture around him is so beneficial, rather than those dirty price-fixing tankers over east.

yep, at the very least he should increase his speed over there; if he doesn't take to the speed you can always put him on ice

 

[didak04]

Damaging himself in the process.

Judd's gone. We got the best of him and its sad to see such a talent be shot doen at such a young age.

He will never be the same.

Where as Josh, wow, he is going to be special.

And the culture around him is so beneficial, rather than those dirty price-fixing tankers over east.

Hahaha, this is great, a west coast fan preaching about culture, surely trying to get a bite out of someone. Can't wait to see Judd tear the eagles apart, and this is coming from a collingwood fan

 

[rumblah]

For the future, Ryder and Gumby>>>>>>>Judd and Kennedy

Right.....

 

[Underdog]

I didnt even want our club rookie listing Armfield. Biggest downhill skier around.

rubbish

 

[anti.]

<insert kennedy related drug culture joke>

 

[anti.]

yep, at the very least he should increase his speed over there; if he doesn't take to the speed you can always put him on ice

ah you beat me to it, you damn predictable bastard you!

 

[BLue_Bloys]

Damaging himself in the process.

Judd's gone. We got the best of him and its sad to see such a talent be shot doen at such a young age.

He will never be the same.

Where as Josh, wow, he is going to be special.

And the culture around him is so beneficial, rather than those dirty price-fixing tankers over east.

1) you're still bitter about Judd leaving

or

2) You're looking for people to bite.

Either one, I couldn't be bothered wasting my time