Judd for?

Remove this Banner Ad

Johnny_3

All Australian
Aug 19, 2006
901
3
AFL Club
Carlton
You are John Worsfold.
End of 2007 Murphy has one Carltons B&F while Bryce Gibbs has taken out the NAB Rising Star. Judd has one another Brownlow.

Judd requests a trade to a Victorian based club.
Would you take Marc Murphy & Bryce Gibbs.





I don't have an opinion on this as i beleive Judd is the best the games ever seen while Murphy and Gibbs combined havn't quite lived up to the expectation. No doubt in my mind both will be very good players. I am leaning towards the Murphy & Gibbs trade.
 
Mate you have just made youself look like the biggest fool in the land. Can some1 please delete this Poll. Murphy future Captain of our club. Played 12 & a bit games in his debut year and came 4th or 5th in the Rising Star competition, Came in the top 10 of our best & fairest and is a star already. B. Gibbs hasnt even played a game yet but all the experts say that he is a future champion. Not holding my breath on that comment because it has backfired in the past but the guy already in our extended leadership group. Could potentially be another captain of Carlton. Now lets see, W.C receive 2 no. 1 draft picks that are paying combined lees in the salary cap. Carlton receive a Gun no doubt, Best player in the competition, could possibly one of the best players to ever play the game, but how much would he command $$$ wise. when guys like kennedy, simpson, walker, fevola, stevens come out of contract will we be able to fit them all in the cap... finding it tough i would have thought.

Finally the thing that stands out most in this poll is this comment made by youself
Murph, lgnd in just 13 games 3.3.3., which is written right under your post.

Please mate save this type of stuff for bay 13.
 
Only player id swap for Chris Judd is Mitch Brown but Mitch Brown plays for Eagles so you will have to trade with the club to get Mitch Brown then give us back Mitch Brown for Chris Judd for it to work
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Mate you have just made youself look like the biggest fool in the land. Can some1 please delete this Poll. Murphy future Captain of our club. Played 12 & a bit games in his debut year and came 4th or 5th in the Rising Star competition, Came in the top 10 of our best & fairest and is a star already. B. Gibbs hasnt even played a game yet but all the experts say that he is a future champion. Not holding my breath on that comment because it has backfired in the past but the guy already in our extended leadership group. Could potentially be another captain of Carlton. Now lets see, W.C receive 2 no. 1 draft picks that are paying combined lees in the salary cap. Carlton receive a Gun no doubt, Best player in the competition, could possibly one of the best players to ever play the game, but how much would he command $$$ wise. when guys like kennedy, simpson, walker, fevola, stevens come out of contract will we be able to fit them all in the cap... finding it tough i would have thought.

Finally the thing that stands out most in this poll is this comment made by youself
Murph, lgnd in just 13 games 3.3.3., which is written right under your post.

Please mate save this type of stuff for bay 13.
Thats why the whole, B&F Rising star comment was written. I'd just like to know who people would pick.

Murphy & Gibbs
or
Judd
despite the salarry cap.
 
Because those guys would command much higher salaries than Cox, Kerr, Cousins (Past Tense!), Embley & Glass?

Amature read between the lines. at the moment both gibbs and Murphy will not command the type of wage as Judd. gibbs for the next 2 years 50,000 plus game fee, murphy as well for the nest to years 50,000 plus game fee. Murphy sign an extended 1 year contract when he came to the blues but i would expect that there would be a clause in there with that last year. Therefore at years end the combined total of $$$$ for murphy and Gibbs at most would be $300,000 compared to Judd's $800,000. Does that make sence now. Ohhh and to let you know W.C have a larger cap than we do.
 
Mate you have just made youself look like the biggest fool in the land. Can some1 please delete this Poll. Murphy future Captain of our club. Played 12 & a bit games in his debut year and came 4th or 5th in the Rising Star competition, Came in the top 10 of our best & fairest and is a star already. B. Gibbs hasnt even played a game yet but all the experts say that he is a future champion. Not holding my breath on that comment because it has backfired in the past but the guy already in our extended leadership group. Could potentially be another captain of Carlton. Now lets see, W.C receive 2 no. 1 draft picks that are paying combined lees in the salary cap. Carlton receive a Gun no doubt, Best player in the competition, could possibly one of the best players to ever play the game, but how much would he command $$$ wise. when guys like kennedy, simpson, walker, fevola, stevens come out of contract will we be able to fit them all in the cap... finding it tough i would have thought.

Finally the thing that stands out most in this poll is this comment made by youself
Murph, lgnd in just 13 games 3.3.3., which is written right under your post.

Please mate save this type of stuff for bay 13.

This is why people think that the blues fans are the REAL drug problem in the AFL.

Would the trade happen? No, because West Coast are too smart for that.

Gibbs hasn't done anything, any guess on his future is speculation. Murphy has played well but is early times.

Compare this to Judd, place Judd in most sides and he'd carry them to top 6, even Carlton would make the 8 IMO with Judd. Judd is a premiership winner and they are gold. Murphy and Gibbs aren't anything yet. West Coast would be stupid to trade their success away for two hopefuls, because after all, it's because of Judd primarily that the eagles are premiers.
 
Thats why the whole, B&F Rising star comment was written. I'd just like to know who people would pick.

Murphy & Gibbs
or
Judd
despite the salarry cap.


So you are willing to give away
1. a player in his second year who wins the b&f and came in the top 10 the year b4 in his 1st year after playing 12 games.
2. a player in his first year to win the Ron Evans medal. Doesnt way up.

In my personal experience winning club B&F was way more important than winning Competition B&F's. I know Juddy's won club B&F's as well but you dont give away 2 Number 1 draft picks. Especially with the quality that they are.
 
This is why people think that the blues fans are the REAL drug problem in the AFL.

Would the trade happen? No, because West Coast are too smart for that.

Gibbs hasn't done anything, any guess on his future is speculation. Murphy has played well but is early times.

Compare this to Judd, place Judd in most sides and he'd carry them to top 6, even Carlton would make the 8 IMO with Judd. Judd is a premiership winner and they are gold. Murphy and Gibbs aren't anything yet. West Coast would be stupid to trade their success away for two hopefuls, because after all, it's because of Judd primarily that the eagles are premiers.

Question - Would you trade - Delideo and Franklin (Woops) Tambling for Judd???
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

That would only get a Chris Judd personalised signed photo.

LOL yeah probably
Dont get me wrong here guys i would love C. Judd at my club. So does every1. But at what cost??? Giving up to number 1 draft picks who POTENTIALLY could be superstars in their own rights (could even turn out flops) would be unthinkable. Enough said
 
**** yes. Worsfold would do it.

Thing is, Carlton wouldnt.
 
**** yes. Worsfold would do it.

Thing is, Carlton wouldnt.


What Ali just said. The stupidity of some of the tiger and WC posts on this are staggering. Woosha would probably throw in his left nut to ensure this trade happened.
Carlton would laugh at this rediculous offer.

If anyone thinks that Murphy and Gibbs will not be playing about 15 years of brilliant football each they are mad. Compare this to maybe 10 years of Judd.

I don't think Carlton would even swap one of these guys for Judd.

How anybody thinks that Carlton would entertain losing both of their future stars is beyond me.
 
If Judd wanted to go back to Victoria and West Coast were offered that trade, they'd jump on it before carlton had a chance to change their mind. But if Judd decided he wanted to stay in the west and Carlton offered Murphy and Gibbs for him, you can't imagine West Coast would even consider it.
 
If Judd wanted to go back to Victoria and West Coast were offered that trade, they'd jump on it before carlton had a chance to change their mind. But if Judd decided he wanted to stay in the west and Carlton offered Murphy and Gibbs for him, you can't imagine West Coast would even consider it.

There is no way that Carlton would even offer 1 of the two to the Eagles.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Judd for?

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top