Frankston Rover
Academy Award Winner
- Nov 25, 2005
- 33,503
- 42,549
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Packers-Spurs-Melbourne City
Judd didn't deserve his Normie, we all know that.
West Coast Judd > Carlton Judd - no muatter how much charity he gets.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Judd vs Hodge case closed
- Thread starter Big Red is back
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Judd didn't deserve his Normie, we all know that.
West Coast Judd > Carlton Judd - no muatter how much charity he gets.
Just wondering if u might have started a thread like this before 2008???
Judd AA captain. What a joke. Shouldnt even be in the team. Its supposed to be the best team for 08. If anyone can convince me he has been one of the 2 best onballers for the year then you will likely be able to sell me on Cam Cloke being a starting ruckman too.
The Ruck Rover and Rover should be the 2 best mid's for the season. Ablett is definitely one of them. Judd, although he has had a pretty good year, has not been one of the best 2 mid's for the year by a long shot.
Selected on reputation alone.
Selected for his year in spite of his reputation as a line breaker.
samira
Senior List
You mean anyone who watched Hawthorn
GOLD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
they are sooooo self centered they forget that there are 15 other sides.
Judd is a Born champ live with it dawk fans
hodge is a great player but hasn't reached judds champ status
one day just mayb
- Banned
- #31
Why is Ruckrover>>HBF?
If we're going by AA selection then Mooney>Franklin in 2007 as well.
Walls thinks Judd is better than Ablett, so that explains a lot.
If we're going by AA selection then Mooney>Franklin in 2007 as well.
Walls thinks Judd is better than Ablett, so that explains a lot.
Case is closed...it's official....
Judd is the greatest player to ever play the game and Carlton are a powerhouse of the competition.
Hawks unfortunately are stuck with poor old Hodgey and will have to put up with this hack and playing finals for the next 10 years....oh well, sometimes you just can't help bad luck..
Judd is the greatest player to ever play the game and Carlton are a powerhouse of the competition.
Hawks unfortunately are stuck with poor old Hodgey and will have to put up with this hack and playing finals for the next 10 years....oh well, sometimes you just can't help bad luck..
List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
To end the debate from the insecure and bitter inbred Tassie fans who somehow think that overrated reciever Luke Hodge comes close to the brilliance that is Judd
Premiership Medal: 2006
Brownlow Medal: 2004
Leigh Matthews Trophy: 2006
All Australian Captain 2008 (Captain)
Norm Smith Medal: 2005
AFLPA Best First Year Player Award: 2002
Luke Hodge ???
SFA
Debate over, Chris Judd always has been, always will be far superior to Luke Hodge.
To end the debate from the insecure and bitter inbred Tassie fans who somehow think that overrated reciever Luke Hodge comes close to the brilliance that is Judd
Premiership Medal: 2006
Brownlow Medal: 2004
Leigh Matthews Trophy: 2006
All Australian Captain 2008 (Captain)
Norm Smith Medal: 2005
AFLPA Best First Year Player Award: 2002
Luke Hodge ???
SFA
Debate over, Chris Judd always has been, always will be far superior to Luke Hodge.
- Banned
- #34
Re: List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
hodge at least deserved to be part of AA squad
hodge at least deserved to be part of AA squad
WeAreHatedAgain
Club Legend
Re: List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
He's won the most likely to succeed award for people not being able to string two words together award from Colac High
He's won the most likely to succeed award for people not being able to string two words together award from Colac High
Re: List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
please stop bringing judd down to chubby cheap kicks level, its embarressing for the great man.
please stop bringing judd down to chubby cheap kicks level, its embarressing for the great man.
WeAreHatedAgain
Club Legend
Re: List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
Says he who has Mark (I only play for Essendon because my best mate is Lloydy) McSchmend
Says he who has Mark (I only play for Essendon because my best mate is Lloydy) McSchmend
Hawks1523
Brownlow Medallist
Re: List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
And only one of those was while at Carlton. Well done riding on his past glories at West Coast.
And only one of those was while at Carlton. Well done riding on his past glories at West Coast.
CrippsonBlue
Cancelled
Re: List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
Well, in 1 year at Carlton, he has already added to that list. What has Hodge added in all his years at Hawthorn?
...Thought I'd have a go at this bantering. The only real fact is that no one really gives a sh^t about this argument anymore.
And only one of those was while at Carlton. Well done riding on his past glories at West Coast.
Well, in 1 year at Carlton, he has already added to that list. What has Hodge added in all his years at Hawthorn?
...Thought I'd have a go at this bantering. The only real fact is that no one really gives a sh^t about this argument anymore.
- Thread starter
- #41
Re: List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
And yet the AA selectors and the players re the MVP do not agree... think I will run with those guys sorry mate LOL
And yet the AA selectors and the players re the MVP do not agree... think I will run with those guys sorry mate LOL
Why is Ruckrover>>HBF?
If we're going by AA selection then Mooney>Franklin in 2007 as well.
Walls thinks Judd is better than Ablett, so that explains a lot.
Are you serious with that question?
Are Carlton supporters that starved of success that they have to claim West Coast's success as they own by buying one of their players.
Fancy Carlton buying some success....
Fancy Carlton buying some success....
Goldhawk
Premiership Player
- Jul 17, 2007
- 4,343
- 3,414
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Beaconsfield JFC Melbourne Storm
You can have Judd and stick it up your backside,we'll have Hodge the Number 1 draft pick.
Luffy
Senior List
Judd is better than Hodge, prove me otherwise Dawks supporters with some evidence that he isn't.
Thanx for reading my post, flog.
Thanx for reading my post, flog.
Now that it's case closed- is Luke Ball better than Hodge?
Re: List of Awards that Chris Judd has compared to Luke Hodge...
West Coast Judd >>> Carlton Judd >>> Hodge >>>>>>>>> any Essendon player.
West Coast Judd >>> Carlton Judd >>> Hodge >>>>>>>>> any Essendon player.
- Banned
- #48
Here ya go. And before you tell me that stats mean nothing, Duddles actually wins more stats than Hodge, but quality>quantity
http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/supercoach_season
Good to see some people taking a positive attitude in the face of such a blunder. Top marks my friend!
It would be great to see them go head to head this weekend to settle the debate. But Im afraid Ball (if declared fit) will play in the midfield while Hodge will be gathering cheapies in defence.
