rfctigerarmy
🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
**** off Carltank supporters.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Lance Whitnall
- Thread starter GhostofJimJess
- Start date
- Tagged users None
oldfashiondefender
Debutant
No to the fanta pants
tony_montana
Cancelled
- Banned
- #28
delricho12
Senior List
He did win carltons best and and fairest last year and if he can get fit and get the Knee right can play across CHB im not saying grab him with our first pick but later on if available.or Pettrie been delisted from Crows would he be a better chance.
delricho12
Senior List
He has had more success than Cogs over the last 2 years.
lay off redheads, Keith Grieg, C Ling, B Hardie, D Brereton, N Kidman, J Gillard (or perhaps not)
If we pick up Whitnall I will be convinced that Miller is trying to see what he can get away with before being fired.
- Banned
- #34
I think if he actually worked on his fitness he would be a good pickup for the dogs because they lack height, not us though. We want Brennan.
Brennan has the potential to play 2 or 3 tall behind Richo and can go back and help out Polak, Thurty, and McGuane against teams like Essedon who have tall foward lines
Brennan has the potential to play 2 or 3 tall behind Richo and can go back and help out Polak, Thurty, and McGuane against teams like Essedon who have tall foward lines
A 1 year contract...
$300,000....
He pays US
As Benny said....a sad day indeed when we are considering a Tankton reject!
$300,000....
He pays US
As Benny said....a sad day indeed when we are considering a Tankton reject!
meownotroar
Team Captain
I have a Krispy Kreme donut franchise- can I set up at Punt Road Now?
peejay
Brownlow Medallist
pass
- May 3, 2007
- 1,153
- 519
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- WEST HAM : THE POSH : FORT WILLIAM
Oh dear......
i would never consider him at no.1, but if he slips through the cracks to your next pick id say why not? hes got four more years left in him and if he gets into shape, mentally and physically then he could help richmond rebuild into the force it once was
Agree with this. Definitely not the first pick but if no-one else takes him and we can fit his salary in, would be a decent addition.
But Brennan Hasn't signed yet
He would be a great pick up
Rutten hasnt signed with Crows that would bolster our backline
Plus Bolton is still up for PSD
oh christ on a crust
- Sep 19, 2006
- 2,613
- 4,247
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Draft-pre-season Whitnall
Whitnall wants to play on
10:35 AM Sun 14 October, 2007 | Back
with AAP
Whitnall wants to play on
10:35 AM Sun 14 October, 2007 | Back
with AAP
News
Whitnall, 28, says he intends to nominate for the NAB AFL pre-season draft, despite the club offering to keep him on in an off-field role.
"At this stage, I want to play football so I would say yes [to the draft]," Whitnall told Channel Nine. "But I will have a good think about what options I have and where I will go."
Whitnall has played 11 seasons with the Blues, but missed seven games with a knee injury in 2007.
Carlton chief executive Greg Swann said a medical report convinced the Blues Whitnall's knee would not stand up to another AFL season. Coach Brett Ratten broke the news to Whitnall on Friday.
"[He] sat down and he looked me in the eye and told me that is the way they are going to go and I couldn't argue, that was it," Whitnall said.
"It hasn't really sunk in at the moment. I only got the news late yesterday afternoon so it hasn't really sunk in. I am a bit disappointed but that is football."
Swann said the Blues were not prepared to nurse Whitnall, who had post-season knee surgery, through a "compromised" pre-season campaign.
Whitnall conceded his injury was persistent.
“It's still there but it hasn't got worse, that is what the doctors told me," Whitnall said. "They said it could get worse at some stage, but they just gave it a quick clean-out."
surely, would rather brennan, regarding the age difference.
- Blues tell Whitnall: no future here
Sat, Oct 13, 07
Whitnall, 28, says he intends to nominate for the NAB AFL pre-season draft, despite the club offering to keep him on in an off-field role.
"At this stage, I want to play football so I would say yes [to the draft]," Whitnall told Channel Nine. "But I will have a good think about what options I have and where I will go."
Whitnall has played 11 seasons with the Blues, but missed seven games with a knee injury in 2007.
Carlton chief executive Greg Swann said a medical report convinced the Blues Whitnall's knee would not stand up to another AFL season. Coach Brett Ratten broke the news to Whitnall on Friday.
"[He] sat down and he looked me in the eye and told me that is the way they are going to go and I couldn't argue, that was it," Whitnall said.
"It hasn't really sunk in at the moment. I only got the news late yesterday afternoon so it hasn't really sunk in. I am a bit disappointed but that is football."
Swann said the Blues were not prepared to nurse Whitnall, who had post-season knee surgery, through a "compromised" pre-season campaign.
Whitnall conceded his injury was persistent.
“It's still there but it hasn't got worse, that is what the doctors told me," Whitnall said. "They said it could get worse at some stage, but they just gave it a quick clean-out."
surely, would rather brennan, regarding the age difference.
Re: Draft-pre-season Whitnall
I would rather us to pass on the PSD pick than pick up Whitnall.
I would rather us to pass on the PSD pick than pick up Whitnall.
Re: Draft-pre-season Whitnall
you would doubt it. i mean if he could get fit he might be a good player, but way too risky for mine. hopefully we can entice one of rutten/fraser/brennan or even bolton into the psd. if not, then guy richards as a back up ruck would be better than whitnall.
you would doubt it. i mean if he could get fit he might be a good player, but way too risky for mine. hopefully we can entice one of rutten/fraser/brennan or even bolton into the psd. if not, then guy richards as a back up ruck would be better than whitnall.
- May 8, 2007
- 48,686
- 71,373
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #49
Re: Draft-pre-season Whitnall
Miller said Travis Johnson was out of the question because of his age, so no way we would grab big Lance. Collingwood would be a better home as they are close to a flag and big red could give them a bit of back up.
Brennan would be nice for us
Miller said Travis Johnson was out of the question because of his age, so no way we would grab big Lance. Collingwood would be a better home as they are close to a flag and big red could give them a bit of back up.
Brennan would be nice for us
