***Live 'Pick-by-Pick' Discussion Thread***

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

I am going to kill Dodoro..seriously...we are crying for a gun mid..Rich, Yarrand and Ziebell there..and he takes a KPB!

WTF...we also need a gun KPB.

The good thing about Hurley is he can also play forward.

At the moment our spine is Lloyd, Lucas, Watson, Ryder and Fletcher

Three of them will be gone in 3 years time, Fletcher most likely at the end of next season.

Who are there replacements Neagle (injury prone, poor fitness levels, unproven), Gumbleton (injury prone, unproven), Pears (some injury problems, unproven) Daniher (some injury problems, unproven).

So in other words we have no one who has proven at this stage that they are a lock to replace any of our aging KPP players.
 
can any Geelong fans give me more insight to Davenport?
I don't know as much as others, but won our VFL Best and Fairest in 2008. Blistering pace. Only spent one year (2008) on the senior list but had been a rookie and VFL player I think. Kicked 8 from the wing once in 2007. Sometimes questionable by foot.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Begley to saints - glad hes getting a go

We passed on the last one - if its used on Davis and not Cousins I will be livid!!!!!!!!

After Voss and Gubby both said on SEN that we categorically weren't getting him? Hope you enjoy being livid.
 
Im pretty pissed off with our picks :(
Don't be. Jones is a bottom ager, tall, agile possible ruckman-forward - a bit like Cordy. Roughead is a ruckman-tall who can kick a goal. Those are the sort of blokes the club needs. Your other 2, Cornelius, who describes himself a a 3rd tall forward (Welsh, Murphy, Tiller) and O'Keefe, a medium defender (think Hargrave, Morris, Addison, Callan) are types we have already.
 
can any Geelong fans give me more insight to Davenport?

Yeah he's a great player (worth pick 78 anyway)....came to prominence in a VFL GF kicked I think 4 or 5 goals off a wing....so we eventually upgraded him.....our VFL B&F 08 which says something considering how strong our list is.

What you'll like about him is he's very quick, and will kick goals from the midfield, like say Burgoyne and Rodan.

All the best Jason...glad to see you get a chance :)
 
Surprised that Carlton didn't take any talls
We didn't rate the talls on offer at our picks.

Robinsin is just what we need for our midfield.

Have Hawthorn finished their picks yet?

I'm surprised that Hawthorn took another forward ahead of Trengove when they need tall defenders.

I guess you don't rate Dowler, Boyle and Thorp...

Hawthorn drafting another ruck is overkill IMO.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

***Live 'Pick-by-Pick' Discussion Thread***

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top