luke mcpharlin v josh gibson

Remove this Banner Ad

kanye_best

Cancelled
Jul 1, 2011
1,096
1,383
Levi's Beard
AFL Club
Carlton
was having this debate today with a hawthorn supporting (scum) mate. which of the 2 players is a better player? and why?

mcpharliun imo has him covered in one-on-one and marking, actually the only facet that gibson wins in is speed (maybe)
 
was having this debate today with a hawthorn supporting (scum) mate. which of the 2 players is a better player? and why?

mcpharliun imo has him covered in one-on-one and marking, actually the only facet that gibson wins in is speed (maybe)


Well unless Im mistaken, Gibson's not suspended for being a sniping dog :thumbsu::D
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Both worse than Henderson.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

mcpharlin of course recieved his formative training at the hawks so however good he is is down to HFC...and he is good!!

Better than Gibson, dont know.

Gibson has more counter punch and attacking qualities.

Mcpharlin is a stopper who can swing forward.

Both good qualities but as an out and out defender has to be Gibson.

Much quicker.
Better disposal
better decision making.
Spoiling just as good.

Gibson played in the middle as well for north.
 
Gibbo bagged a Pussycat doll and McPharlin joined a bunch of fruitloops in a nutbag religion. Give me Gibbo's expoloits anyday.
 
Gibbo bagged a Pussycat doll and McPharlin joined a bunch of fruitloops in a nutbag religion. Give me Gibbo's expoloits anyday.

This is what I came in to say.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

luke mcpharlin v josh gibson

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top