Player Watch Mark Keane - Signed to End of 2028

Remove this Banner Ad

agree with your commentary Wayne. He has not progressed as we thought he might. He needs to work on his craft and that very well may be the seconds for some time next year. Narrow shoulders not a help. He needs to build up his confidence and body and work on his kicking.
This is always a bit of a give away ......he hasn't a big arse, or low centre of gravity .....he goes up for marks already off balance, and often completely opened up to get hurt
 
This is always a bit of a give away ......he hasn't a big arse, or low centre of gravity .....he goes up for marks already off balance, and often completely opened up to get hurt

Agreed. So many people on here just look at height and weight but there is so much more to it. That's the problem with picking up a KPD in the draft, how their body matures is key to their success and it's not always obvious how that will unfold.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Bigman ....what are your thoughts on Butts .....I just can't see it

Introvert, is knocked off balance too easily (core strength) ......and panic kicks too often, sometimes slewing it off his boot, in his haste

Will he ever outgrow this lack of strength / composure
I don't believe Butt's form has been as bad as many have made out... particularly as he has been playing under some duress with shoulder & foot issues.

We have subbed him out in a few games, but should he have been rested before his injury became chronic?
 
This is always a bit of a give away ......he hasn't a big arse, or low centre of gravity .....he goes up for marks already off balance, and often completely opened up to get hurt
Agree.

More a second KPD over a number one.



On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
This is always a bit of a give away ......he hasn't a big arse, or low centre of gravity .....he goes up for marks already off balance, and often completely opened up to get hurt
Imo Butts has already showed that he's a strong KPD (2020 and 2021). Was consistently shutting down the best key forwards and his kicking was solid.

Has lost form. If he can get fit and rediscover that form, he's a good KPD. Murray has shown that his best is better than Butts best, so he'll no longer be number 1.

I don't think we should rule out Butts as the second KPD after Murray.
 
After an expected shaky start he was surprisingly really good. Mind you, it was only Dixon. (remember when they said Dixon was better than Tex).

Charlie Dixon might be the most overrated player in the history of the game.

1.6 goals a game and never 50 in a season.

Played in two finals wins one of which was 2020 and barely counts
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Mason Cox a former team mate of Keane said he was a 'player that gets under your skin' on his podcast.



I'm liking the sound of this lad more and more.
 
Was thinking because his son has played Gaelic Football before which does have at least some similarties - he might have found it easy to follow than someone with 0 context.

Plus, Keane has been a pro footballer for 3ish years, seeing his stint at Collingwood. So it's not a new thing.
 
Didn’t get to see him play due to covid

You know there is this fandangled technology called the internet, right?

Next week, i'll show you what pasta is.
 
Impressive debut.

I said earlier in the year that a combination of Keane and Murray as our key defenders would be a mobile attacking defence. Let's hope Murray comes back with the same mobility and we can see the best of them.

If you have Twitter, check this out, vardy magic has done a highlight video.



7 incept marks

Let's see how he goes the rest of the year, but we may have found another one!


On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Impressive debut.

I said earlier in the year that a combination of Keane and Murray as our key defenders would be a mobile attacking defence. Let's hope Murray comes back with the same mobility and we can see the best of them.

If you have Twitter, check this out, vardy magic has done a highlight video.



7 incept marks

Let's see how he goes the rest of the year, but we may have found another one!


On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

outstanding debut. every thing we could have asked for.

I thought we chased Keane but an article last week said he contacted the club after Mc Asey quit earlier in the year. Either way, a huge win and bright future and no wonder Pies were keen on him.

One thing though. The small hands in the back on several occasions may become an issue with other forwards flopping where as to big Charlies credit he didnt
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Mark Keane - Signed to End of 2028

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top