![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/carlton.png)
- Aug 25, 2014
- 1,301
- 2,966
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Norwood
for example: you suggested that Voss has erred in NOT adding talls to the defensive mix- and I stated Voss's choices are: Young and Akuie in VFL - do you have any tall hiding away in VFL to add to this list? Do you prefer Young over ANY of the selected defenders that played yesterday?
Thanks for replying. As for this bit.. yes as much as I don’t rate Young, I think he should have played to take Cox. This would have freed up Kemp to be more attacking and have a more favourable matchup. I also prefer Young going through the ruck than McKay. Last thing we need is McKay getting smashed and hurt in the ruck. I said in the lead up to this weeks game that we’ll play Weitering on McStay and Kemp on Cox even though we shouldn’t. Another poster pointed out he thought we’d go Weitering on Cox and Kemp on McStay. In the end, sadly I was right. It was an obvious mismatch we should have accounted for. For all Young’s faults, we need to play two genuine KPDs- it creates better matchups and allows for our third talls (Gov, Kemp) to actually play as third talls .