Mitch Duncan v David Zaharakis v Jack Redden

[CollarJazzKnee]

Simple question: who is the best of these players?
All about the same age, average about the same number of touches etc.
None have quite taken the next step though..

 

[cripppa9]

Duncan easily.

 

[ManOfClay]

Duncan easily better so far. Zaka has been disappointing based on what he promised early.

Don't really have an opinion on redden

 

[Bobby_]

Duncan fairly comprehensively.
Zaharakis isn't as damaging as what Duncan is. Duncan has aerial smarts along with goal kicking smarts.
Redden's an intriguing prospect. Looks like he's about to elevate his game in a big way shortly.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Redden's a plodder. Zaka's a fraud. Duncan's a star.

 

[juss]

Yeh easily Duncan.

 

[Super Hans]

Duncan by a mile. One of the more underrated players in the league. Was on fire before he got injured last year.

 

[Ambrosia]

Duncan no question. Hopefully Zaharakis steps up in 2016 as his 2015 was extremely diaspointing

 

[hawkman]

Duncan easily

 

[TwentyNine]

I reckon Zaka at his best is the best of the lot, but, not nearly as consistent as they are.

 

[blueiris]

None of the above dislike all of them especially Redden

 

[Stan Van Gundy]

Yeah Duncan quite easily. Zaharakis seems to have really regressed as a player and Redden is just vanilla and not damaging at all.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Duncan easily, Zaharakis has been very average since he did 3 quads in 12'. Lost a yard of pace and with it his ability to be a damaging outside mid. Would be trying to revert him to his half forward role at the start of his career.

 

[Oraaaaazio]

None of the above dislike all of them especially Redden

Yeah, I guess none of them would make your best 22 so that makes sense

 

[Mitchell54]

Duncan without a question. He's not far behind Selwood and I reckon he had as good a year as Selwood last year. Injuries were frustrating though. My favourite Geelong player.

Redden is just an ordinary ball magnet. Gets the ball but then whats happens after that is quite ordinary.

Zaharakis was great back before his injuries. now he's good but meh.

 

[Bardo State]

Players like Redden will never really go out of style, would be seen as a fair player in a good team IMO. Duncan with the higher ceiling.

 

[tunksy]

redden seems to have hit a plateau, needs some spark
zaca has been hit with an injury sledge hammer but has shown he can be good. needs to get over those injuries tho
Duncan, having a good year last year.. then injury sadly see how he goes this year

 

[Sando22]

Duncan by a fair way.

 

[Mitchell54]

Redden out of the question IMO.
Ducan winning so far but Zaharakis has a good chance to show what he's got to offer this year(barring injury of course

 

[cotter101]

1. Duncan, 2. Redden, 3. Zaka.

Duncan at his best is a star. Redden hit a brick wall with us and didn't progress as he should have. But you take out his injury affected games from last year and he was on of the better inside mids stats wise. He isn't quick and is an average kick but he has slowly been making improvement.

 

[eth-dog]

Duncan. Zaka is too up and down, and his defensive running leaves a lot to be desired

 

[MightyDons4]

Could probably just leave Redden out of the poll. Duncan better than Zaka, both very good when injury free.

 

[eth-dog]

Duncan. Zaka is too up and down, and his defensive running leaves a lot to be desired

Must admit, his defensive running tonight was excellent. Best I've seen, could be in for a big year.